Clickbank Rejecting Forex Products?

Banned 11 years ago

Originally Posted by theforexgeek

Surely if they are rejecting new products they MUST remove all existing vendors?

This isn't what they normally do, at all. For example, when they tightened up last year over some changed FTC policies and stopped approving some of the more obviously fraudulent representations on the sales pages of newly submitted products, they made no apparent effort to change exactly the same things on pages previously accepted.

Originally Posted by theforexgeek

How can they say "we do not accept this type of product" yet allow existing vendors to promote them?!

It does seem a little strange, at first. However, there may be (and presumably are?) logical explanations for it. ClickBank (as is also true of PayPal, 2Checkout, Plimus under their new name, and other businesses) have to make these changes in accordance with the demands of their own upline financial service providers, and that's why "those businesses" all seem to change their policies at around the same time. It may be that what they really have to do is confirm a change of acceptance policies, without necessarily disturbing what they've already accepted in the past, when they had different acceptance procedures. If they can get away with that ... :confused:

I agree it does seem a little strange.

Ezine Articles is similar, in a way: they've changed their acceptance procedures (editorial guidelines) but the database is still full of previously accepted, now non-compliant stuff.

It must be a nightmare for them to keep checking everything all the time, but the general trend is still one of improvement.

Good luck in finding a home for your product. Clicksure may be worth a look, if you want to do business with a much newer Chinese company who seem to specialise in accepting all the products that everyone else declines.

[ 1 ] Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7804853].message }}

rosetrees

11 years ago

Originally Posted by Alexa Smith

Clicksure may be worth a look, if you want to do business with a much newer Chinese company who seem to specialise in accepting all the products that everyone else declines.

I think (??) that's an excellent example of the old saying - "damning with faint praise".

[ 1 ] Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7804861].message }}

theforexgeek

11 years ago

There seems to be a grey area here...Can anyone confirm 100% that clickbank DO NOT accept NEW forex products anymore?

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7804957].message }}

MilesBaker 11 years ago

That's strange, but not surprising. ClickBank really seems to be moving in the direction of lowering risk. Perhaps your product and some of the statements were just too risky for them. I would respond and ask them, you can also email/call them and see if you can get an answer.
- Thanks
Signature
Join the Community for ClickBank Marketers, it's Free.
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7805681].message }}

phowell23

11 years ago

There have been a ton of new Forex product launches on Clickbank within the past 30 days. So they are still accepting them but maybe tightening down some on which ones get in.

[ 1 ] Thanks

Signature

Stop wasting time. Just do it!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7805691].message }}

Makabongwe Maseko

11 years ago

My forex trading product was approved by Clickbank early this year (January). The product does not offer promises of making a certain amount with forex trading, it just guides you on how to get started with forex trading.

Thanks

Signature

Website Design | App Creation | Video Marketing | Social Media | Web Hosting

==> SlashTouch.Com

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7806053].message }}

theforexgeek

11 years ago

Were those accepted non-automated products? The only reason I can think of is because my software is automated, but there are TONS of automated forex systems on Clickbank already!

I have had to change a sales page before to get accepted but I was not even given that choice this time. I have asked them why I was rejected and awaiting a reply.

Thanks
2 replies

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7806218].message }}

Cool Hand Luke 11 years ago

Originally Posted by theforexgeek

I have asked them why I was rejected and awaiting a reply.

Since they're the only ones who can say with certainty why your product wasn't approved, you're going to have to wait for a response from them. Nobody on the forum here could tell you anything besides a few guesses as to what *might* be happening. Wait for CB to get back to you, it shouldn't take more than a day or so.
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7806227].message }}

phowell23

11 years ago

Originally Posted by theforexgeek

Were those accepted non-automated products? The only reason I can think of is because my software is automated, but there are TONS of automated forex systems on Clickbank already!

I have had to change a sales page before to get accepted but I was not even given that choice this time. I have asked them why I was rejected and awaiting a reply.

I'm promoting an automated Forex product right now that was just released a few weeks ago. I agree though wait on CB. They normally respond within 24 hours but with it being the weekend they may not respond until Monday.

Thanks

Signature

Stop wasting time. Just do it!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7806235].message }}

theforexgeek

11 years ago

If they dont give me a reason for rejection or reject me again is it worth resubmitting a product approval request ticket after making a few changes to my sales page? I am thinking it may be due to the sales page or maybe I was just very unlucky with the member of staff who reveiwed it. Seems CRAZY that people have released forex robots in recent weeks on clickbank and I was rejected because "they have had problems in the past with similar automated trading software"....

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7806320].message }}

phowell23

11 years ago

Originally Posted by theforexgeek

If they dont give me a reason for rejection or reject me again is it worth resubmitting a product approval request ticket after making a few changes to my sales page? I am thinking it may be due to the sales page or maybe I was just very unlucky with the member of staff who reveiwed it. Seems CRAZY that people have released forex robots in recent weeks on clickbank and I was rejected because "they have had problems in the past with similar automated trading software"....

If you want, PM me your site's sales page and I'll be happy to look it over and see if it's on par with others I've promoted.

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

Stop wasting time. Just do it!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7806394].message }}

theforexgeek 11 years ago

This is the Clickbank (Tessa C) reply:

I did not say that ClickBank does not accept Forex software. We do. What ClickBank does not accept is automated trading software, which means we do not accept any software that places the trades automatically on behalf of the customer. If this software generated suggestions and notified the customer the best times to place the trades, this would be a software we could consider because it requires the customer's manual action to place the trade themselves.

So basically they say they do not accept automted forex software (forex robots) yet they have tons of them in the market place and have allowed existing vendors to keep selling forex robots - double standards or what?! Hypocrites! If they DO NOT ALLOW them then surely they should do a Plimus and remove them all together!

Looks like regnow is now the best automated forex affiliate place!
- [ 4 ] Thanks
- 2 replies
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7815921].message }}
- Alexa Smith Banned 11 years ago
  
  Originally Posted by theforexgeek
  
  This is the Clickbank (Tessa C) reply:
  
  Thanks for the update. Interesting.
  
  Originally Posted by theforexgeek
  
  double standards or what?!
  
  "Double standards" in the sense that whether something is sold there depends on what the acceptance regulations were at the time of its submission, perhaps, yes. (Maybe "time-dependent standards" would be a fairer description?) But that's nothing new at all, and the reasons for it are explained in post #2 above (as far as they can be "explained", anyway).
  
  Originally Posted by theforexgeek
  
  If they DO NOT ALLOW them then surely they should do a Plimus and remove them all together!
  
  They feel not, evidently. And you can't really blame them, I suppose, if (for whatever reasons) they can get away with doing it that way.
  
  To be fair, ClickBank suddenly getting rid of all existing, similarly operative products wouldn't actually help you to get your own new product on the market, you know?
  
  Good luck!
  
  Thanks
  
  1 reply
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7815981].message }}
  
  SunilTanna 11 years ago
  
  I hate this double standard argument, because it doesn't make sense if you put yourself in ClickBank's shoes even for a moment.
  
  Imagine for example:
  
  There are 100 "old" products that do X.
  
  Now imagine a high percentage, say 90% as an example, of them are unacceptably risky with too high refund rate, etc.. So if you were Clickbank you'd kick them out.
  
  If the other 10% were okay with minimal refunds & charge-backs, if you were ClickBank, you would probably decide to keep them.
  
  Now a new vendor comes along and says they want to do X. Would you accept them?
  
  Wll if I were ClickBank I wouldn't. Based on previous vendors in this category, I would know there is about 90% chance they'd cause problems.
  
  The fact, that through expensive trial and error, I've found a few decent "old" products in the X category, has no bearing on this calculation.
  
  That aside, for the OP, I have a suggestion:
  
  Why not offer 2 versions of your product under 2 brands/names on different sites?
  
  Through regnow, you can do your automated versions.
  
  Through ClickBank, you can simply change the software to make suggestions - this is surely virtually a subset of the automated version.
  
  [ 2 ] Thanks
  
  Signature
  ClickBank Vendor?
  - Protect Your Thank You Pages & Downloads
  - Give Your Affiliates Multiple Landing Pages (Video Demo)
  - Killer Graphics for Your Site
  SPECIAL WSO PRICES FOR WARRIORS + GET THE "CLICKBANK DISCOUNT" TOO!
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7816098].message }}
- 1one 11 years ago
  
  Originally Posted by theforexgeek
  
  Looks like regnow is now the best automated forex affiliate place!
  
  Regnow also don't accept forex products: http://www.warriorforum.com/main-int...s-anymore.html
  
  Thanks
  
  1 reply
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7819923].message }}
  
  1one 11 years ago
  
  Shareit.com also do not accept. Damn, can anyone suggest payment processor for forex?
  
  Thanks
  
  1 reply
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7822324].message }}
  
  Alexa Smith Banned 11 years ago
  
  Originally Posted by 1one
  
  can anyone suggest payment processor for forex?
  
  See post #2 above.
  
  Thanks
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7822353].message }}

PerformanceMan

11 years ago

They shouldn't allow 'automatic trading' software. What a great way for uninformed people to lose ALL their cash.

[ 2 ] Thanks

Signature

Free Special Report on Mindset - Level Up with Positive Thinking

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7816111].message }}

theforexgeek

11 years ago

They wont get rid of existing vendors because they make so much commission from them. They are now saying that forex robots give them problems but still allow existing vendors to sell them, it doesnt matter if you think that's right or wrong, it goes against ClickBanks OWN current policies! They do have rating system now based on refund rates, so that may be the way they "punish" existing vendors, so surely they would give new vendors a chance to prove themselves with this rating policy rather than just dismiss them right away, whilst they still allow other products in the same category. Forex robots aside, this applies to EVERY TYPE OF PRODUCT/NICHE! To say you do not allow that type of product but still have a large percentage of your market selling that product is WRONG and imo they do not rid of existing products because they make so much commission from them.

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7816594].message }}

Alexa Smith Banned 11 years ago

Originally Posted by theforexgeek

They wont get rid of existing vendors because they make so much commission from them.

Clearly.

Originally Posted by theforexgeek

They are now saying that forex robots give them problems

I think that's slightly missing the point of the situation.

They make changes like this because of the demands of their own upline financial service-providers.

If they can't get away with continuing to accept these products, they can't.

Originally Posted by theforexgeek

it goes against ClickBanks OWN current policies!

You seem to be confusing "acceptance policies" with policies relating to what they sell.

In your mind, what they sell and what they accept ought to be identical. You're the only one who thinks that, but that seems to be your stumbling-block, here. I agree that it's a little anomalous when they're not, but things like that sometimes happen (as in the Ezine Articles analogy I offered you above).

Originally Posted by theforexgeek

surely they would give new vendors a chance to prove themselves with this rating policy rather than just dismiss them right away

You're still missing the point, but it's already been explained to you so many times that I dont suppose it'll serve any purpose to keep repeating it at this stage. You're going to feel "victimised" and that "they're wrong and you're right" however many people try to explain it to you. I give in.
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7816627].message }}

theforexgeek

11 years ago

Look it's fine, I don't feel victimized in anyway, I don't mind if ClickWank refused my product that is better than 99.9% of the crap they sell (they did me a favor), it's not like they are the only option!

I thought it was strange (and wanted to let others know) that they wont "accept" a certain product but yet still "allow" a certain product. YES, that is my opinion that I am entitled to thank you and if you think I am the only person in the world that thinks that then (you must live in a small world) that is your opinion and I respect that (although I do not agree and will not attempt to mock you for it).

BUT,

There is no need to speak in a condescending and patronizing manner. Your opinion is not the authoritative one.

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7817211].message }}

Alexa Smith Banned 11 years ago

Originally Posted by theforexgeek

There is no need to speak in a condescending and patronizing manner.

I didn't intend to. I got exasperated and I apologise for coming across that way.

For the record, I'm also - so far - the only person in the whole thread who has actually offered you (in post #2 above) a positive and constructive suggestion for where you can actually sell your product without encountering such increasingly widespread and understandable difficulties, so don't be too cross with me!
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7817265].message }}

Alexa Smith

Banned 11 years ago

Not as much as I'd like to, DM: I'm ill-disciplined and far too easily distracted.

:rolleyes:

I did a lot of work between the end of September and Christmas, though.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7822374].message }}

theforexgeek

11 years ago

The plot thickens! Check out this reply from ClickWank:

Thanks for your response and I want you to know we understand your concern. We will reach out to the vendors you brought to our attention to determine if they are selling software that does trading on behalf of the customer. We appreciate your desire to work with ClickBank and our decision to not accept this product due to the auto placing of trades still applies.

Thank you again for understanding.
Best Regards,
Sheri Archambo
Manager
Business Services

I mentioned that they have vendors selling automated forex software (myself included!) and they are "going to look into it"...Right, so IMO what they are saying is they do not allow forex robots (new & existing vendors) and will remove any vendors selling automated trading products...Of course they wont, they make too much commission from them as I stated before. Acting like they are not aware of the hundreds of forex robots flooding the ClickWank marketplace!

RegNow dont allow forex products?! That's crazy because they have many forex robot vendors as well! Exact same situation as ClickWank if that is the case. Fair play to Plimus for the way they went about it removing ALL vendors.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7824597].message }}

SunilTanna

11 years ago

I have no dog in this fight, since I personally have zero interest in forex or promoting forex products, but how does this help you?

Even if you get CB and regnow to ban every single forex vendor, how does it help your business?

[ 1 ] Thanks

Signature

ClickBank Vendor?
- Protect Your Thank You Pages & Downloads
- Give Your Affiliates Multiple Landing Pages (Video Demo)
- Killer Graphics for Your Site
SPECIAL WSO PRICES FOR WARRIORS + GET THE "CLICKBANK DISCOUNT" TOO!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7824701].message }}

Anonymous Affiliate

11 years ago

Clickbank is simply covering their backs towards the FTC and towards payment processors, due to the fact that Forex is a niche with a long history of high refunds and plenty of customer complains. Since Clickbank acts as a reseller, it's normal they limit their risk by stepping away from some specific niches.

[ 1 ] Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7824770].message }}

MilesBaker 11 years ago

Why not make the automatic version an upsell for an extra $xx.xx per month or whatever.

Sell the upsell to your customers via follow-up email and put the upsell on PayPal or another network.

With every change comes opportunity!
- Thanks
Signature
Join the Community for ClickBank Marketers, it's Free.
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7825144].message }}

troy23

11 years ago

Yes they announced last year that they would reject Forex type products.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7825180].message }}

theforexgeek

11 years ago

Yes Miles! I like your thinking!

For anyone who does not know or wants confirmation, I received an email from regnow officially stating that they also DO NOT accept forex vendors anymore.

Alexa, thanks for recommending click sure but I see they only offer limited payment options NOT including PayPal. Please correct me if I'm wrong.

[ 1 ] Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7826373].message }}

Alexa Smith Banned 11 years ago

Originally Posted by theforexgeek

Alexa, thanks for recommending click sure but I see they only offer limited payment options NOT including PayPal.

Sorry; I didn't know this.

Thinking about it, though, that could perhaps be how they're getting away with listing all these products that people who do take PayPal are turning down? Which perhaps doesn't take you any further forward.
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7826552].message }}

phowell23

11 years ago

You might want to try calling Clickbank and speaking to them about this issue on the phone? There have been vendors here recently who have gotten their products accepted when they were first rejected just by calling them and making the necessary changes.

+1-208-345-4245
+1-208-472-9500
+1-800-390-6035

Thanks

Signature

Stop wasting time. Just do it!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7826627].message }}

Clickbank Rejecting Forex Products?

Trending Topics

Can google crawl a password protected pdf linked to from your site?

Grand entrance!

optimizing PPC campaigns

My hosting company says my Websites are down

Band Of Brothers