by emkay
16 replies
Everybody here is familiar with what normal list building is all about. So let me get straight to the point. This is my inbox





I'm pretty sure this is how most people's inbox looks like. I might read maybe 2 in 100 such emails. Why do the seasoned marketers still want to be there in people's inboxes while the chance of your email getting is read is less than 5%? Why not have them like your facebook page? I'm pretty sure the read rate is atleast 5 times higher over there. Also, there is the AR cost to consider. I moderate a movie fan page which has around 1000 likes. I posted a poster last Saturday and so far it has reached more than 800 people (Facebook page Analytics).

I seek the experts' opinion on why they still hang on to email list building.
#building #facebook marketing #list #list buiding
  • Profile picture of the author PROmotions LLC
    I totally agree with you and this is the reason I don't do solo ads. I probably have about 600 filters set up in GMail to get rid of stuff like this. I would never want my brand name to be synonymous with spam emails. I would cringe if I sent an email out and it was marked as spam. Most peoples "subscribed" people are clueless and are probably trying to figure out where the hell it was that they typed their email into to result in this.
    Signature

    Signature!

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8212264].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Alexa Smith
    Banned
    Originally Posted by emkay View Post

    Why do the seasoned marketers still want to be there in people's inboxes while the chance of your email getting is read is less than 5%?
    Some of us monitor our open-rates and click-through rates and know that this isn't so at all.

    It's all about establishing a continuity-process and having subscribers who want, expect, await and open your next email because they're looking forward to it.

    http://www.warriorforum.com/main-int...ml#post6123982

    Originally Posted by emkay View Post

    Why not have them like your facebook page?
    I don't have one, wouldn't want to use a social network for my business, wouldn't want to be limited to only Facebook subscribers, wouldn't want to be dependent on Facebook, and quite a few other reasons, too.

    Originally Posted by emkay View Post

    I'm pretty sure the read rate is atleast 5 times higher over there.
    Sorry to sound dismissive, but that wouldn't be possible, for any of my lists. There isn't room to quintuple any of my open-rates, under 100%.

    Originally Posted by emkay View Post

    Also, there is the AR cost to consider.
    It's a very tiny business expense, compared with its role in producing income.

    Originally Posted by emkay View Post

    I seek the experts' opinion on why they still hang on to email list building.
    I wouldn't earn a living without it. But I wish you well with your preferred method.

    (Any possibility of making your image a little less wide, so that it fits the screen/page?).
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8212280].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Devin X
    Banned
    If you can think of a new way to build lists, then by all means, do it. BUT, you haven't found it because having FB fans or Twitter followers DO NOT COUNT AS YOUR LIST!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8212290].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Alexa Smith
    Banned
    Originally Posted by emkay View Post

    List Building 2.0
    Please excuse the (only semi-facetious ) observation that this widely-used "2.0", in the context of internet marketing, is just a euphemism for "Something I don't myself own and control, so it isn't really part of my business."

    It's like running a "business" from "Web 2.0 sites" like Blogspot and Squidoo which you don't yourself own and control, where someone else makes up and interprets and enforces all the rules, policies and procedures and can change them whenever they feel like it. And you suggest that I should do the same with my lists, the actual income-producing asset of my business, and have that all dependent on someone else? Not going to happen ...

    But well done with the "image-shrinking"!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8212348].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Jeremy Bratcher
    I'm sure there are plenty of emails you do open otherwise you wouldn't ever check your inbox or even have an email address.

    Those are the emails I want to be sending. The ones that you need to see. The ones you are waiting on.

    Email marketing and list building remain viable ways to reach your target audience.
    Signature
    “The question isn’t who is going to let me; it’s who is going to stop me.” – Ayn Rand
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8212776].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Sarevok
    I've been slowly increasing the quantity of methods in which to communicate with followers.

    But emails will always be an integral component. (just my two cents)
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8212859].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author brubsss
    Even the most people don't open the emails you send, it is clearly more profitable than facebook.

    I can give you the example of the company I am employee. We have 100.000 mails on our list and 400.000 people which liked our fb page.

    Our mail list makes, more or less, $20,000.00 per day (don't be impress, it is a very huge company). Our fb page makes, barelly, $500.00.

    We have a small open rate, but even though, a lot of people buy it. Instead of facebook which a lot of people see our posts but don't even think about going to our website to buy something.

    They are different medias, the email is the most powerfull tool to sell (even more than any other including google adwords etc...) and fb is for making your brand powerfull.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8212862].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Willie Crawford
    This is what my inbox looked like in the not too distant past:



    and I didn't really categorize any of it as spam since it was
    mostly email lists that I "somehow" subscribed to over the
    years and was just too lazy to unsubscribe from. The fact that
    I didn't really want most of the stuff in my inbox did not make
    it spam (according to definitions that I understand).

    Today, my inbox rarely has more than 50 emails, even though
    I probably get thousands of emails some days. I simply learned
    how to set up my inbox properly, with a lot of automation rules,
    and tools and plug-ins tied to my Gmail box. I rarely miss
    important emails these days.

    On the usefulness of emails.... being consistent in your "From"
    field will very often get you noticed by those really wanting
    to receive your email. Next, a very clear subject line, tells a
    somewhat busy reader whether or not they want to open a
    given email from you.

    So, I find that using very clear From and Subject fields helps
    to keep email VERY effective for me.

    It is true that open and response rates are down compared
    to years ago, but I believe that's just a factor of there being
    a LOT more email marketers. Many brick-and-mortar businesses
    are shifting their advertising dollars away from other less
    effective mediums to email and online mediums.

    I don't consider pages and groups on places like Facebook and
    LinkedIn as lists. I maxed out on Friends at Facebook 3 years
    ago, have 2 dozen fanpage (dedicated to differing purposes),
    and am a member of numerous groups on LinkedIn... some of
    which I can send direct messages to members inboxes, but I
    don't generally think of those numbers in the same terms that
    I do email lists.

    Incidentally, I also have Skype chat groups, Google+ followings,
    SMS list and autoresponders built via blog plug-ins, and a dozen
    other tools that I tinker with... but still consider email as
    the cornerstone of my internet-based business.

    Oh... I just remembered direct to desktop apps, and a lot of
    other technologies that I don't see discussed that much anymore.

    Use what works for you with your audience. Email still works with
    mine in numerous diverse niches.

    Willie
    Signature

    How To Make $3000 - $5000 in 48 Hours Or Less!
    Proven Step-By-Step Method. Only $17.
    Here!

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8213574].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author kinyash
    A fact is that list building is profitable meaning most marketers are able to get their subscribers not only to open their mails but also buy their products. I think the emphasis here is to get the subscribers to want to read your mail and they will look specifically for it among the clutter. Another fact is that list building also gives you total control over your business as opposed to your suggestion. What if facebook TOS changed today and they decided they dont like your page and it is taken down? Without a list you loose everything. If i have my list, even if i were to loose my websites or social pages, i can always rebuild them easily since i have my customers contacts.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8213600].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author paul nicholls
    if you start building your own good quality list you will then see how effective it is by having one

    facebook is ok to use and does have a purpose but you don'y own anything o facebook it's just part of your free account

    with a good quality list you own everyone on your list

    once you have been around for a while you start to figure out the people that send you good info and the ones that just fill up your inbox with junk
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8213721].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author MartinPlatt
    It is getting harder, but how many of those subject lines were interesting enough to stand out and grab your attention? Being the same as everyone else, you'll get no results, but standing out, and being different can get you excellent results.
    Signature

    Martin Platt
    martin-platt.com

    Stuck with earning commissions online? Get this get this uncensored affiliate marketing guide for free (sold as coaching for $4,997)

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8213732].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author andreas3
      Originally Posted by MartinPlatt View Post

      It is getting harder, but how many of those subject lines were interesting enough to stand out and grab your attention?
      I noticed "Do you make these mistakes in video?" -- but only because it's a 40 year old classic!

      Max Sackheim’s 40 Year Control Ad: “Do You Make These Mistakes In English?”
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8213804].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author JohnMcCabe
        Classic mistake - projecting your own preferences to the world at large. Yes, I still do it myself sometimes.

        I noticed myself slipping into the same space you did - email box cluttered with stuff I never read. Some of it is stuff that, while I opted in, is not what I was led to expect. Some is stuff that I was interested in once, but no longer. Some is stuff that, to be honest, I only wanted the freebie for research and was too lazy to unsubscribe.

        A combination of filters and unsub sessions has cleaned things up to where I probably open half of my email, and pretty much all the ones from people I want to hear from.

        Contrast that with my Facebook page. I really wish that they would allow two pages per person. My wife likes to use my page as her second one when she is entering contests and requesting coupons/freebies/samples. I have no clue who or what I've 'liked' over the last two years. Therefore, I pay no attention to what shows up on my page.

        I'm not about to change that, either. I'm typing this on a laptop she won for me...
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8214553].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Randall Magwood
    I'm still sure that you would make more money with an email list than a facebook fan page. I do use facebook in my business, but i dont put nowhere near as many emphasis on it as i do with building up my email list. And depending on the autoresponder service.... email marketing is more than worth it.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8214706].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author talfighel
    This is what most people's inbox looks like these days. When someone subscribes to your newsletter in the home business niche, just know that they are also subscribed to others too. They are bombarded with emails and if you can get them to buy something from you, you are really lucky.

    2-4 years ago when I had a large list, I did well but nowadays with so much competition and so many email lists, I just had to stop building a list. This is just my own point of view.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8214757].message }}

Trending Topics