endlock25

I was discussing mobile websites with someone the other day and he suggested that in a very short time there will be no need for them, due to increased bandwith and improving technology with smartphones and other mobile devices and regular sites will just load the same as they do on a desktop/laptop. Can you see this happening anytime soon?

umc

I don't know, but I personally hate mobile sites. I want to see the real deal, not a boring scaled down version of a site. With 4G speeds, I have no reason to not go to a full site. Just my opinion though. I know that many love the mobile version, including my wife.

Simple "pay what you want" life coaching services online.
Get out of your own way in business. It's personal. Click Here

Nail Yener

Let's say we reached a point in technology that the loading speed of a website is exactly the same on a desktop device and a mobile device. What difference it would make? The main point for a mobile friendly site is the usability. "Loading speed" is just one part of the usability. How bigger can a smartphone screen get? 1/4 - 1/5 of a 15" laptop screen? There is a limit for the screen size that you can carry in your pocket as a "phone" and as long as there are small screens accessing web, the need for mobile friendly sites (mobile version or responsive) will not disappear.

What do you mean by the real deal? If a mobile website does its job well, then one shouldn't need to access the full site. If you have a reason to go to the full site, that means the mobile representation of that site is not doing its job.

ltrain_riders

Responsive web design is where it's at. If you're building a new site make sure it's responsive so it can adjust to the different resolutions your visitors will be viewing at. This makes things easier because you don't have to manage yoursite.com and m.yoursite.com.

Most websites are poorly coded/designed for smaller devices, not the other way around. I think you are going to see more web sites change their design to conform to the changing screen sizes. There's no reason not to do it now, if you are building a new site.

cloudchief

Agreed. I would rather just go to the full site.

umc

I mean just that, the real deal, not a copy, the original. Often I'm going to a site that I know and like already, and I'm familiar with where everything is. I don't want to have to reacquaint myself with the site in the form of the mobile version. I also find many mobile sites to be incredibly devoid of graphic design and boring. I like shiny objects, so I like the more graphic intensive full site. I find many mobile sites to be more utilitarian, and although that will do in a pinch, if I have options, I'm going full site. With that said, I do seem to enjoy responsive sites for the most part. This isn't exactly something I've done a case study on, but just my opinions as a heavy internet user both on my mobile phone, tablet, laptop, and desktop.

Simple "pay what you want" life coaching services online.
Get out of your own way in business. It's personal. Click Here

NewParadigm

w/ bigger smart phones, its easier to handle the regular site, but still many people w/ needs for a simpler mobile site. Geez, retailers/restaurants put your dang hours of operation on your first main page! quit making me search high and low!

In a moment of decision the best thing you can do is the right thing. The worst thing you can do is nothing. ~ Theodore Roosevelt

Nail Yener

I can understand that. Everyone has different preferences and webmasters should be aware of that and respect that although they cannot make every single user happy with their solutions. But again I should say, if a mobile site makes you feel like visiting the full site, then it is not doing its job well.

For example, if I was visiting a restaurant website to call them for a reservation while I am on the move with my mobile device, I would expect a quickly loading website to get the info I am looking for in a few seconds. I wouldn't be happy to wait like 20 seconds to see all that shiny objects and images (or Flash) and then have difficulty to find the info I am looking for.

Another example, if I was checking a forum frequently on my mobile device on the move, I would expect a lightweight, quick loading website so that it will not take minutes to view and reply to threads and it will not scroll down like infinitely to find the post I am looking for.

I personally don't use excessive graphics and shiny objects in my mobile designs and I don't recommend it to anyone simply because the more graphics and shiny objects you have, the slower your site will be. We might think differently on this but the days of shiny objects, excessive graphics and Flash in websites are soon to be history because users want speed. Check all the major websites and their latest updates Google, YouTube, Facebook, Amazon etc. and you will see that they are in a trend for simplifying their interfaces.

When I create something for mobile, I first focus on users on the move, I don't focus on users who connect to Internet from their mobile devices at home or Wi-fi spots where the Internet speeds are considerably higher.

cjagodka

I can say personally that I prefer mobile sites when doing a search on my phone. I have fat thumbs (seriously fat thumbs.) It's easier to navigate through a mobile site than a full site just because buttons are bigger without having to zoom in. By the way I have a GS3 and still have to zoom in on some sites.

I don't think mobile sites are ever going to go away. They will just become more elaborate.

Wanna hire an iphone or android app developer? Check out the best place to hire an app developer on the net.
Be sure to check out Asset Mobile LLC's Affiliate Program.

MobileMarketingMogul

The thing is with responsive design is that it just shrinks the desktop site, this is no use as the content you see on a desktop site is not what you want to see on your mobile device.

I would recommend a separate mobile site as you can get straight to the point with your mobile customers.

Check out how many of the gurus are missing out on the new gold rush 'MOBILE IS THE FUTURE' http://dominatemobilemarketing.com/freemobilereport/

mjbmedia

hey endlock, who was this 'someone' you were discussing mobile websites with and why have you put so much weight on what they said?

Mike

Shellyannr

Oh absolutely. The very fact that someone even thought of it makes it possible. A few decades ago who even knew of smartphones at all, now look where we are.

Shelly-Ann Roper is a Translator and multi-lingual Marketing/PR professional for SMEs. She specializes helping small businesses integrate their products and services into foreign markets. She is CEO/founder of Neue Medien PR/Marketing Inc and the Smart-Up Business Guide.Direct link to her blog here.

Hengky Ongko

Is tablet access from ipad including in mobile site? If yes, then I think it will be more dominant one day..You should have responsive themes that can adjust easily when visitor access your web from any devices they use

endlock25

It was my daughters boyfriend. He's pretty switched on when it comes to "teccy "stuff and it just got me thinking.

Workman

Ideal mobile sites should have: all the features of a full site with the streamlined look of a native app.

Will it happen? Probably not, but the sites that do adopt a good mobile strategy will likely benefit since they will provide a better experience with their visitors. (Remember what's important in Google's Panda update? The visitor experience.)

If you work with a business who says a mobile version is not important to them, please make the case that the web is becoming increasingly more mobile and this is preparation for the very near future.

mjbmedia

OK then ask your daughters boyfriend how he uses a site on his PC compared to how he uses it when mobile on his mobile device(s) and why the hell he honestly thinks there will be a huge change in the way users use the sites on their different platforms in the future.

When Im on PC, I take more time, am prepared to look around , making decisions based on searching a number of sites and pages, Im going out to eat in 3 nights time and want it to be special so am prepared to do some (lengthy) homework.
When Im mobile, the decisions are generally more imminent, I want to eat now, im more interested in filling my stomach than researching the absolute best option, and the one that resonates with me most within the first few sites (and they have to be mobile friendly and engaging) will win my business.

You ask your daughters boyfriend why he thinks the above will change from a users perspective just because technology can allow a PC site onto a mobile device doesnt mean users will engage with it.

Mike