Asking for help - need a pro to evaluate my business idea

21 replies
Is there any pro on here willing to evaluate my business idea in a private message? I will gladly pay I just need a pro to give me an honest opinion of my idea.

Thanks
#business #business idea #evaluate #idea #marketing #pro
  • Profile picture of the author addyonline
    Hey man,

    I'd be happy to help - just shoot me a PM .

    Cheers,
    Adam.
    Signature
    The CRO Pro :)
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10335599].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Jason Kanigan
    Ask Claude Whitacre or Ken Michaels if they'd be willing.

    There are others I'd also trust. Those are the two at the top of MY list for bouncing ideas off.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10336008].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author sandalwood
      Originally Posted by Jason Kanigan View Post

      Ask Claude Whitacre or Ken Michaels if they'd be willing.

      There are others I'd also trust. Those are the two at the top of MY list for bouncing ideas off.
      Jason,

      You are too modest. So, I will add you to that duo and make it a trilogy. I don't see how the OP can make a mistake talking to one or all of you.

      Tom
      Signature
      Get 30% or More Retirement Income If you are serious about your retirement, you'll love this product.

      The Money Ferret Finance Article Directory
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10336593].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author bizgrower
    It would help to know what market, ie. financial services, internet services...

    But, yeah, the above gentlemen, and possibly Warriors Peter Lessard, Oziboomer, IamNameless,
    savidge4, ewenmack, and DABK. (Sorry for leaving anyone else out, but it's the end of the day.)
    Signature

    "If you think you're the smartest person in the room, then you're probably in the wrong room."

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10336820].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author DaniMc
    Just post it here. You will get lots of input.

    Nobody is going to steal it and ideas are 100% worthless anyway - it's all in the execution.
    Signature
    Be kind, for everyone you meet is fighting a hard battle.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10336849].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Jason Kanigan
      Originally Posted by DaniMc View Post

      Just post it here. You will get lots of input.

      Nobody is going to steal it and ideas are 100% worthless anyway - it's all in the execution.
      Exactly.

      Yes, I could have written quite a long list of qualified contributors to this sub-forum.

      Agreed--the OP should just post the idea and we can all comment.

      @Legendary, if you are worried someone will steal your idea, consider this:

      1 > execution as DaniMc pointed out is the name of the game, and most people are too lazy to execute

      and

      2 > the competent business owners are already busy with their own pet projects, and while happy to note and give their opinions on another, simply don't have time or energy to start yet another thing

      and

      3 > your idea is in a niche you feel comfortable in...but I probably wouldn't and the same goes for other entrepreneurs.

      I for one have far too many projects I'd like to get to "someday"...and they all take precedence over some idea I just heard of two seconds ago on the internet
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10336878].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author bizgrower
    Reminds me of a mastermind group I was in.

    The lawyer in the group had the idea of performing legal exposure audits for a fee.
    I did not see anything particularly proprietary or original about the idea, but the other
    four guys sure did and we all swore to secrecy - so to speak.
    Signature

    "If you think you're the smartest person in the room, then you're probably in the wrong room."

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10336911].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author LEGENDARYJUSTICE
    The idea I have is this

    I have an existing graphic design/screen printing business. Not your typical one though. i really just market to law enforcement and public safety because its the career I am in already and most of the work easily comes through networking.

    Due to the fact that I am a one man show with this and I pretty much have a good hold on local stuff, in an effort to branch out. I would either need a long lesson on marketing and strategy and all that and hope for the best, or I can attempt to use the networking theory and utilize other cops looking to work as commission based sales reps. They would not have to do much work other than bring the leads to me. I would do most of the selling because I have the knowledge. I would just give them something like 20 percent of the net for the work. Sounds simple, however this is where i am wondering if this part is a good idea.

    I am also setting up an online tactical store where I would sell all kinds of top brand equipment. There are plenty of competitors, however I am not looking to compete with them. What I am looking to do is incorporate the two together in an incentive program. If my sales person brings me jobs, depending on the type of money involved, I would provide the customer with a custom coupon code with a pre determined life that they can give to their department, union or whatever to save excellent amounts of cash on items they would pay way more at my competitors. I am thinking that if I incorporate the two together, I would make money on both ends, so would my sales reps, and the word of mouth spreads and gets me a better hold on the industry. It is a simple idea, but I am wondering what professionals think of it.

    There is no overhead for me. The sales reps bring me business that i would never get in places I probably never knew existed. So I think its a win win for everyone. Once I get a better hold, I planned on rolling out a line of apparel designed by me to market to these same customers.

    Law enforcement is an industry that its members, family, friends and enthusiasts love wearing their t shirts and sweatshirts and hats. That is what I am looking to capitalize on.

    Also my pricing for printing is competitive, and way better than the online companies that so many people go to when they cant find a good screen printer.

    Please send me feedback

    Ty
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10337189].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author gjabiz
      We have a uniform shop right down the street, would this be the type of outlet which could be used for your products? Here is the link:

      Levinson's Uniforms

      Dozens of law enforcement people a day go in and out and their UPS trucks are filled to the brim.

      Just wondering, if you could work through these types of places (you may already be doing this)...but if this is your target, I think a place where they already are buying from (and there is one in every city)...would help you expedite your distribution.

      gjabiz


      Originally Posted by LEGENDARYJUSTICE View Post

      The idea I have is this

      I have an existing graphic design/screen printing business. Not your typical one though. i really just market to law enforcement and public safety because its the career I am in already and most of the work easily comes through networking.

      Due to the fact that I am a one man show with this and I pretty much have a good hold on local stuff, in an effort to branch out. I would either need a long lesson on marketing and strategy and all that and hope for the best, or I can attempt to use the networking theory and utilize other cops looking to work as commission based sales reps. They would not have to do much work other than bring the leads to me. I would do most of the selling because I have the knowledge. I would just give them something like 20 percent of the net for the work. Sounds simple, however this is where i am wondering if this part is a good idea.

      I am also setting up an online tactical store where I would sell all kinds of top brand equipment. There are plenty of competitors, however I am not looking to compete with them. What I am looking to do is incorporate the two together in an incentive program. If my sales person brings me jobs, depending on the type of money involved, I would provide the customer with a custom coupon code with a pre determined life that they can give to their department, union or whatever to save excellent amounts of cash on items they would pay way more at my competitors. I am thinking that if I incorporate the two together, I would make money on both ends, so would my sales reps, and the word of mouth spreads and gets me a better hold on the industry. It is a simple idea, but I am wondering what professionals think of it.

      There is no overhead for me. The sales reps bring me business that i would never get in places I probably never knew existed. So I think its a win win for everyone. Once I get a better hold, I planned on rolling out a line of apparel designed by me to market to these same customers.

      Law enforcement is an industry that its members, family, friends and enthusiasts love wearing their t shirts and sweatshirts and hats. That is what I am looking to capitalize on.

      Also my pricing for printing is competitive, and way better than the online companies that so many people go to when they cant find a good screen printer.

      Please send me feedback

      Ty
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10337225].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author LEGENDARYJUSTICE
        I want to be able to supply certain types of uniforms to cops that do not require the custom fitting needed of a seamstress. The newer uniforms do not require that too much. I am wondering if the lure of the discount for the equipment and uniform end of my business is enough bait for me to get the design and printing busness.

        I see the printing business for me as the real goldmine because of the frequency of it should I build a good base. The equipment stuff is just gravy but I felt it gives everyone in my profession money back in their pocket as a thanks for the printing. You understand my thought process. The reason I want the outside reps is because they are in the industry like me already, considered inherently trustworthy and easier to funnel business toe and they get a cut for their efforts.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10338059].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Oziboomer
      Originally Posted by LEGENDARYJUSTICE View Post

      i really just market to law enforcement and public safety because its the career I am in already and most of the work easily comes through networking.

      Please send me feedback
      Hey Ty.

      I trained a guy whilst he was still in the Air Force as part of his re-training when he was due to to retire so to speak.

      He had already tested the market much like you have with your connections.

      When he first approached me for training he asked me if he had 18 months to get his business going what should he do.

      I suggested a much longer planning period and shorter execution period than he had estimated.

      Years later he thanked me and although he spent less time on the planning stages than I suggested he was successful even though he had to do a few re-designs that he could have avoided.

      I did an intensive training program with him that was partially Government funded and he set up a business from home.

      He did segment the business into an adjoining area so he could isolate his business from the private life.

      Within about two years he had part time help but he specialised is supplying a military base that was local to home and where he had been previously employed.

      This gave him a really solid foundation for his business because he had the support of past relationships and the people that also had left the military.

      He did feel the pressure of supplying to a price because of his previous engagement but he did make a really successful go of it.

      His approach was so professional and his organisation was so precise, I guess due to his military training.

      He was extremely successful in my eyes.

      The only sad part was he was exposed during his service period to some chemicals that affected his well being in later life which prevented him from fully enjoying the fruits of his labor.

      Just make sure that you ensure you get an adequate return for your efforts and even though you have close connection and understanding of your target market please make sure you make a commercial return for you efforts.

      Best wishes for your success.

      Oziboomer.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10337968].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Barry Unruh
      Originally Posted by LEGENDARYJUSTICE View Post

      i really just market to law enforcement and public safety because its the career I am in already and most of the work easily comes through networking.
      I'm going to bet those statements mean you already know a bunch of great guys/women in other departments scattered around your state and the country.

      Reach out to people in that network and see what a few of them think. People you have already met at training sessions, conferences, about cases, etc... May be interested, or will know trustworthy people in their departments who might be interested in your opportunity.
      Signature
      Brain Drained...Signature Coming Soon!
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10338243].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author LEGENDARYJUSTICE
        Thanks for the feedback so far. I do not have much business experience so let me ask. The theory that I have with hiring the outside sales reps, possibly increasing the commission and working how I stated earlier, does that sound like a sounds business idea?

        Does the incentive plan of the discounted equipment also help the idea? I thought it was a great carrot for people, especially unions where there are elections because they can show they are giving their members something substantial.

        I know I can sell to people, my problems is getting the exposure to the people. Besides the sales reps, I am hard pressed to find another way to connect to the decision makers on these jobs who need this kind of work. I thought about mailers, flyers etc. I have tried facebook ads, but have trouble targeting.

        Any input is greatly appreciated
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10338687].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author bizgrower
          Originally Posted by LEGENDARYJUSTICE View Post

          Thanks for the feedback so far. I do not have much business experience so let me ask. The theory that I have with hiring the outside sales reps, possibly increasing the commission and working how I stated earlier, does that sound like a sounds business idea?

          Does the incentive plan of the discounted equipment also help the idea? I thought it was a great carrot for people, especially unions where there are elections because they can show they are giving their members something substantial.

          I know I can sell to people, my problems is getting the exposure to the people. Besides the sales reps, I am hard pressed to find another way to connect to the decision makers on these jobs who need this kind of work. I thought about mailers, flyers etc. I have tried facebook ads, but have trouble targeting.

          Any input is greatly appreciated
          Please get a track record on all actual costs, overhead, taxes, payroll taxes, and cash flow...
          before offering commissions and discounts. Can't make promises you can't keep and sustain
          a real business.

          I'm a bit afraid you want to be the low price leader over the value leader.

          There is a lot to be said for brain damage prevention by positioning correctly in terms of
          profits and working with desirable customers.
          Signature

          "If you think you're the smartest person in the room, then you're probably in the wrong room."

          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10338839].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Jason Kanigan
    Legendary,

    I don't see much of a downside to your sales rep plan. Other than time & energy, you don't have much to lose...except if you get a bad reputation as "that pushy company that keeps trying to get in here."

    So here's what it comes down to, if you go in the sales rep direction:

    You have to be really careful about choosing your reps.

    This is true in car dealerships, even though they act otherwise--what's the cost of adding one more commission sales rep? Nuthin'...nothing financially as an outlay, anyway...but what if they suck? What if they're offensive? Now that hurts your reputation.

    So pick carefully. Give them some skills and knowledge. Don't just dump them out there into the world of selling...give them a process to follow. Show them you're there to support them.

    Make sure they've got proof they've done sales work before, or have the interest for it. Do not look for people wanting to make a quick buck--they'll represent you badly and come and go fast.

    What you're looking for boils down to a network of people "inside" who are consistently bringing you qualified leads.

    You can get them to sell as well, but if they bring you the leads that's cool at this point, too.

    Screen heavily...and if you can, I'd reward them with a higher amount than just 20% of the sale. Remember as you said yourself, they are probably bringing you business you'd never get otherwise. Unless your margins are razor thin, you can afford to reward them more for doing so.

    Be cautious. Slow. Deliberate. "I was thinking about this...just an idea...what do you think?" See if it fits the individual's mindset and beliefs about themselves. Don't go crazy pushing the idea. There's a gestalt thing with this stuff...the more you push the more they draw back. Let the good ones think it's their idea.

    Have a system outlined before you start recruiting. If you want some instructional video content on commission sales teams, let me know and I'll link you. Key is be deliberate, be cautious. Don't be in a rush. Build a real team and take the time to create relationships that last, which you already know are so important. This isn't a fit for everybody. Let them pick themselves.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10338098].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Jason Kanigan
    Having someone "on the inside" is incredibly valuable as you've noticed.

    I used to be the product manager for an Inc. Top 1000 mobility equipment firm, and to sell inside hospitals it was a huge advantage to have a retired nurse as the rep.

    The nurses were delighted to be able to wear nice clothes and not have to lug patients around (and occasionally drop them accidentally.)

    Our top franchisees' parents owned some hospitals.

    The tech training head of a major supplier was a nurse, and he ran a nursing industry & training association.

    To walk into a hospital and try and see the administrators and decision makers without that nursing certification and experience was a tough road. With it, they knew you were "one of us" and had been through the experiences they had.

    So this is why I recommend going the rep route. Your marketing materials will have a much greater chance of "bouncing off", while someone who's in the organization will be taken much more seriously.

    Another target: Bored retirees who want a reason to come back and see their buddies on the force. I'm sure you can get names and referrals without difficulty.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10338720].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author DaniMc
    There is a good bit of diagnosis that could be done here before someone can give you a clear answer on the way forward. I am feeling that there is a bit of uncertainty in your value proposition.

    If you know exactly what you are offering and exactly why they should buy from you and exactly who should do this buying - you will have a much easier time.

    In my opinion, this is something that you need to work out before bringing on outside sellers. You will need to be able to tell them who to talk with and how and train them to make the sale.

    For the first few months, it needs to be you out there making these sales so you can learn exactly what people are looking for and how they want it.

    It seems that getting someone else to handle this part for you is the best way (everyone thinks that at first) but you have to know - this IS the business.

    The things you sell are not the business. People can get "things" anywhere.

    HOW you get the things to the customer and the customer to pay for them - THAT is the business.

    So, you can't expect other to build your business for you until you have actually laid the foundation yourself.
    Signature
    Be kind, for everyone you meet is fighting a hard battle.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10338766].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author LEGENDARYJUSTICE
    Guys, thank you so much for all of this input. I wish i knew about this forum a few years back

    bizgrower, you hit the nail on the head with one thing. I do worry about being the low price leader. I assume that its not necessary, I am just looking for ways to lock in business. I figured that if I offer the incentive program showing the discounts on the gear, I could charge competitive full freight for the printing. That would give me a little juice on the gear but the regular profit on the printing.

    In police departments, its hard to find the decision makers, hence the reason I believe that the inside people are so important. The plus to this part of it is that once you do a good job, the word of mouth goes crazy.

    Another question I have is this. My wholesaler provided me with access to their site, they also provided me an FTP site with all of their databases of their items and CD of photos. The site I use for my site now (weebly) accepts the data, but in a different format, making it damn near impossible for me to migrate it over.

    Any ideas on what I can do. I spoke to a few companies online and was getting quoted 15k. But on freelancer getting quoted 300 in India.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10338928].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author DaniMc
      Originally Posted by LEGENDARYJUSTICE View Post


      In police departments, its hard to find the decision makers, hence the reason I believe that the inside people are so important. The plus to this part of it is that once you do a good job, the word of mouth goes crazy.
      When I was in the military, many companies targeted us with equipment and clothing. We would add custom accessories to our weapons, wear cool t-shirts under our uniform (matched the required colors with cool slogans and images), hang things in our vehicles and tents/huts.

      Eventually, we could get our unit to order a lot of this stuff too.

      I am sure cops are the same. Target the individuals too maybe? Start showing up at events where these people will be buying things. Tactical shows and events. Get simple catalogs printed and set up tables possibly?

      There are lots of special military/police sites that exclusively serve that community with discounted gear and clothing - could you get into some of those?

      http://www.govx.com/
      https://www.promotive.com/

      I used to shop promotive a lot.

      If I were you, I would not try to reinvent the wheel. There are so many online shops, social media, and events. Start marketing and selling direct to consumer via online and offline promotions.
      Signature
      Be kind, for everyone you meet is fighting a hard battle.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10338955].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author LEGENDARYJUSTICE
        Thank you. GovX is not too appealing to me. I like the idea of it, but the savings dont appear to be too real.

        What is that Promotive
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10339002].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author bizgrower
    Brand Contact | Promotive


    https://www.thegrommet.com/about-us/what-is-a-grommet
    (I think the products they list have to be original.)
    Signature

    "If you think you're the smartest person in the room, then you're probably in the wrong room."

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10339622].message }}

Trending Topics