Creative Direct Mail Idea To Create A Potentially Powerful Response.

25 replies
Ok so after quite the dry spell I did some quick thinking that resulted in our buisness finally getting some great leads. I wound up setting up a presentation but this is not what this is about.

I'm feeling a bit more confident now in my ability to REALLY make a complete turn around, and this is my idea. It HAS been used before, so people may have heard about it, some not.

My question is if you think this idea could become a highly effective way to pull in some business.

The business we are marketing here is for energy audits.
This is the plan.

I have seen guys on here send letters using a dollar bill as the headline. Naturally I thought this was a good idea, but I still didn't believe it was creative enough to trigger the emotional response I really want.

So after some reading, some thinking, some reading, and some more thinking, I thought what message is our business REALLY trying to get across? Well we do energy audits, so we're trying to save people MONEY.

After seeing an example of a highly effective ad, I got the idea to actually DESTROY MONEY. This would piss people off big time, ESPECIALLY if you gave the money to them first.

It would create a lot of tension, than I'd resolve that tension with my offer, which would apparently be better than the $5. Thats another thing I'm stuck on is whether to use a $1 or a $5 bill. I think the $5 would be perfect.

Heres the plan. First get a highly targeted list.
Second, craft the piece. It will be a simple 2 fold brochure, that opens and closes 1 page on the left, 1 on the right just so we're clear lol.

I take a $5 bill, I glue one side of the bill to the inside right of the brochure, the other side of the bill to the inside left of the pamphlet. Then I make a small cut in the middle edge of the $5 bill.

The front of the brochure will say something about how theres free money inside. It will be designed so you can see the bill, but not the glue that binds it. When the person opens the pamphlet, the $5 bill rips in half. Then on the inside I write something like "Fed up with losing money? - Look our company doesn't enjoy ruining your day, but if we weren't so good at making our clients money, do you think we could afford to destroy cash like this?"

Then we plug our offer for a free energy audit.

So naturally my question, do you think this could work? I'm definitely testing this no matter what, I still want some feedback on the idea.

Thanks WF - Red

ps. these may have to be delivered personally, as the money will be somewhat visible by the postal carrier, but thats not a problem imo.
#create #creative #direct #idea #mail #potentially #powerful #response
  • Profile picture of the author NickSway
    Very creative idea. Very unique. It all depends on what you're selling and what you're conversion rate is.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6149365].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Jerry McGough
      I've never looked for it, but I think you can buy bags of shredded money cheap (?)

      If so, staple a wad of that to the top of the page with a headline underneath;
      WAS This YOUR Money ?

      ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
      Just peeked on ebay out of curiousity....
      There's fiftysome offers. Sample: a bulging sandwich baggie (about $300 worth) is $5.00
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6150125].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author wesb
        Originally Posted by Jerry McGough View Post

        I've never looked for it, but I think you can buy bags of shredded money cheap (?)

        If so, staple a wad of that to the top of the page with a headline underneath;
        WAS This YOUR Money ?

        ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
        Just peeked on ebay out of curiousity....
        There's fiftysome offers. Sample: a bulging sandwich baggie (about $300 worth) is $5.00

        I really like this ideal Jerry! I checked on eBay and I do see the bags of money! I might use this in one of my campaigns! I didn't know eBay sold shredded money like that.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6152336].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author wesb
          I think that you are definitely using your creative side of your brain. That’s what direct response marketing is all about. Great ideal! When I owned a cleaning business years ago we ran a campaign with our brochure & a white glove in the envelope. (The type of glove users may wear in church) With a tag line saying something to the effect of,

          “Take this white glove & wipe (I forgot where we told them to wipe) And if it comes up dirty… Give us a call for we provide White Glove Cleaning Services”.

          I don’t remember exactly its been 20 yrs, but the point I am trying to make is that you must get creative in your marketing efforts. Good Luck!
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6152401].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author sandalwood
        Originally Posted by Jerry McGough View Post

        I've never looked for it, but I think you can buy bags of shredded money cheap (?)

        If so, staple a wad of that to the top of the page with a headline underneath;
        WAS This YOUR Money ?

        ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
        Just peeked on ebay out of curiousity....
        There's fiftysome offers. Sample: a bulging sandwich baggie (about $300 worth) is $5.00
        5 lb bags for $45 sold by the USG at:

        5lb Bag of Shredded U.S. Currency

        You can buy all you want :-)

        Tom
        Signature
        Get 30% or More Retirement Income If you are serious about your retirement, you'll love this product.

        The Money Ferret Finance Article Directory
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6153482].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Baadier Sydow
    A really interesting method that will invoke a strong emotive response from the letter opener. I like it.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6150132].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author ewenmack
      Red, it appears that you are letting the mechanics
      of this override what the target audience really wants.

      One of the biggest reasons, if not the #1 reason advertisers
      lose money in all forms of advertising, is they believe
      the reader cares what the advertiser says.

      Wrong!

      Winning is when you discover what a group of people really want,
      and give it to them.

      Existing wants, not convincing people they should have it.

      That's why selling is so darn hard for so many people,
      they are attempting to push things on to people that don't want it.

      The listener gets annoyed and so does the pitchman.

      So to overcome this rejection and lost money is to really find out what people want.

      Do you really and truly know what they want?

      Or are you just making an educated guess, at best?

      Best,
      Ewen
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6150229].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author goindeep
        Im unsure as to what you are selling. Whats and energy audit? Is that where someone comes to your house and tells you that you are using way too much energy and then tries to flog something off to you?
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6150358].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author marketingstatic
        Ewen I couldn't agree with you more in what your saying here. In fact I just told a guy that wants to partner with me the same thing. He keeps falling for WSO after WSO and is only seeing half the picture. The idea he has is to is a pitch to the so called "Low Hanging Fruit" on their lack of presence on Facebook and other Social Media sites. Then to which I replied how do you know they can afford your offers?
        - There may be a reason their low hanging fruit, no money or brains or both. In many cases I have found they don't understand the Value so you cant make them see it or force them to take your advice.
        However this post still leaves me with the Million Dollar question? How do you know what the target markets Pain is if its a Niche you have little to no experience in?
        Signature

        Happy new Year 2019

        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6159467].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author ewenmack
          Originally Posted by marketingstatic View Post

          However this post still leaves me with the Million Dollar question? How do you know what the target markets Pain is if its a Niche you have little to no experience in?
          Great question.

          I've no experience in the home energy saving business,
          so how did I come up with that headline which has a high probability
          of connecting with the target audience..?

          Red mentioned he saved big money on his power bill
          without dialing down it's usage.

          Now we connect that with a right person.

          The right person is a home owner, not renter
          because the home owner is the buyer.

          Next we connect it to those that are conscious of the power bill
          to the point of annoyance. Remember, we are only targeting
          those that want something, not convince and educate them.

          The whole headline is reaching out to the right person.
          We aren't trying to achieve any more.

          That's the thinking I did on this market I knew nothing about.

          In other markets that you know nothing about,
          looking for pain points are a fertile place to look for.

          I've built and sold businesses based solely on connecting
          the service to pain points.

          Best,
          Ewen
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6160843].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author RedShifted
    First, thanks everyone who responded especially Ewen. That was very helpful and now I feel like I'm just promoting a stupid gimmick tbo.

    To the last guy who responded, is the sarcasm really neccessary?
    You don't seem to know anything about what we do just by using words like "flog". We're not whipping people into submission here, people buy our product because it saves them money. The government has now decided that people are so energy ignorant in this county they're now FORCING an incandescent ban in 2014.

    You know why Mr. Rotariu? Because everyone likes to believe for some reason that energy efficiency is a scam. Its really one of the stupidest things I've ever seen in my life. You bring your car to the mechanic when it leaks gas right? Ok well, 80% of homes are known to be energy ineffecient and LEAKING GAS, LEAKING ENERGY, so how is what we do any different?

    We go in, upgrade things, people save money. They ALWAYS wind up saving more than they pay for the system. But you DO have to invest a good buck to get everything set up. Is it worth it? Well that depends completely on your home. If its over 10 years old, great results are guaranteed. This is also why we do the audits FREE for homes over 10 years old. We can afford to. In my own house I use to pay $200 a month on my bills, haven't had a bill go above $63 in a looong time. I don't try to conserve energy, I leave my lights on all day. Just that my homes is very energy efficient, I personally love it. Saves me money, and I don't have to stress about my bills all the time.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6151760].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Jerry McGough
      Red,
      Do you take infrared photos ?
      If so, is there much setup ?
      Can you do a quick sample phote of the front of a house....have a photo on the spot.....mark a few notes with a sharpee....tape it to a sales letter and drop it in their door ?

      A personalized salesletter might work....if it only tales a few minutes.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6152078].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author goindeep
      Originally Posted by RedShifted View Post

      First, thanks everyone who responded especially Ewen. That was very helpful and now I feel like I'm just promoting a stupid gimmick tbo.

      To the last guy who responded, is the sarcasm really neccessary?
      You don't seem to know anything about what we do just by using words like "flog". We're not whipping people into submission here, people buy our product because it saves them money. The government has now decided that people are so energy ignorant in this county they're now FORCING an incandescent ban in 2014.

      You know why Mr. Rotariu? Because everyone likes to believe for some reason that energy efficiency is a scam. Its really one of the stupidest things I've ever seen in my life. You bring your car to the mechanic when it leaks gas right? Ok well, 80% of homes are known to be energy ineffecient and LEAKING GAS, LEAKING ENERGY, so how is what we do any different?

      We go in, upgrade things, people save money. They ALWAYS wind up saving more than they pay for the system. But you DO have to invest a good buck to get everything set up. Is it worth it? Well that depends completely on your home. If its over 10 years old, great results are guaranteed. This is also why we do the audits FREE for homes over 10 years old. We can afford to. In my own house I use to pay $200 a month on my bills, haven't had a bill go above $63 in a looong time. I don't try to conserve energy, I leave my lights on all day. Just that my homes is very energy efficient, I personally love it. Saves me money, and I don't have to stress about my bills all the time.
      They have been doing this in Australia for years. My best friend works for the auditors that audit the energy companies and I work for the manufacturer of the products lol
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6154488].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author RedShifted
    My jaw honestly just dropped to the floor when I read that. Thats really a phenomenal idea!

    There isn't a lot of set up no. You just turn the camera on it operates similar to a digital camera it just has infrared technology.

    I'm absolutely going to try that this week. It would definitely take some time to take the picture, print it out, mark it up, but I'm thinking a few minutes max per house. Either way I love the idea and its absolutely worth running some tests.

    Thank you! - Red
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6152248].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author RedShifted
    We should really make a dedicated thread with nothing but extremely creative marketing ideas in it. I think I'm always thinking about this stuff because I'm a lefty/right brain dominant thinker. There are some really great ideas in here too I had no idea ebay sells shredded money I might go buy some just to see if I can piece the bills back together lol.

    One of these days I'm just going to find every single creative idea I possibly can, and put them all together in one big guide or even a WSO might work. I will make it a rule that all the ideas are new and fresh, or even twists on old ideas. Either way I'm on a mission to take my marketing to the next level so I will never stop searching for new ideas.

    -Red
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6153058].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author wesb
      Originally Posted by RedShifted View Post

      We should really make a dedicated thread with nothing but extremely creative marketing ideas in it. I think I'm always thinking about this stuff because I'm a lefty/right brain dominant thinker. There are some really great ideas in here too I had no idea ebay sells shredded money I might go buy some just to see if I can piece the bills back together lol.

      One of these days I'm just going to find every single creative idea I possibly can, and put them all together in one big guide or even a WSO might work. I will make it a rule that all the ideas are new and fresh, or even twists on old ideas. Either way I'm on a mission to take my marketing to the next level so I will never stop searching for new ideas.

      -Red
      Great Ideal Red! I'm talking about the shredded money... Lol. But yeah putting together a thread just for creative ideas is a good idea. The WSO too. Now lets get creative and put some of that money back together!

      Jerome Wesb
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6153169].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author bob ross
    I don't think the shredded money thing is what he was going after in his OP. Red had a cool idea of affixing a $1 or $5 to the envelope so that as you open it, it tears apart, therefore 'wasting money'.

    I thought that was really neat and nothing I've ever heard of. Kudos to thinking of that Red!

    Jerry's idea is FANTASTIC but yeah that's a lot of work to do.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6153582].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author vndnbrgj
    I would use the shredded money.
    Tearing money in half is illegal.

    Great idea... Just have to change the execution of it.
    Signature
    Life Begins At The End Of Your Comfort Zone
    - Neale Donald Wilson -
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6154616].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Mister Natural
    Banks will replace the "bill" as long as the serial numbers on both ends match.
    So it's not really "wasted".

    I think "you" would be wasting your own money on that method.
    A phoney bill would communicate the same message and save you from sending out your own cash.

    The infra red idea is an attention getter.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6154633].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author bob ross
      Originally Posted by Mister Natural View Post

      Banks will replace the "bill" as long as the serial numbers on both ends match.
      So it's not really "wasted".

      I think "you" would be wasting your own money on that method.
      A phoney bill would communicate the same message and save you from sending out your own cash.

      The infra red idea is an attention getter.
      And send you to jail in the process! haha, I know what you mean though.


      Also... to do the infrared thing you'd need to take pictures during the cold season in order to see the heat loss.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6154691].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author ewenmack
        The money theme is going down the wrong track Red.

        We work on what's on the home owners mind.

        Having a headline like...

        -------------------------------------------
        To The Homeowner Who Still Feels The Sting
        Of Winter Power Bills...
        --------------------------------------------

        This is calling out who you are after as well as their pain
        related to what you have to offer.

        Being relevant trumps being clever or persuasive.

        Best,
        Ewen
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6154771].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author bob ross
          Originally Posted by ewenmack View Post

          The money theme is going down the wrong track Red.

          We work on what's on the home owners mind.

          Having a headline like...

          -------------------------------------------
          To The Homeowner Who Still Feels The Sting
          Of Winter Power Bills...
          --------------------------------------------

          This is calling out who you are after as well as their pain
          related to what you have to offer.

          Being relevant trumps being clever or persuasive.

          Best,
          Ewen
          totally agree with Ewen. Save the crazy stuff for when there's money to burn and test it.
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6155140].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author RedShifted
    Once again you guys give me solid advice!

    I also like the headline Ewen wrote, in fact it will go on my next postcard. =]
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6155877].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Eugene Celestine
    Offline Marketing Formular:

    Strategy + Massive Action = Success
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6330968].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author prismkuet
    Creative idea but I am not sure how people react after destroying a $5 bill. Do you feel the conversion rate is high? And how you feel after tearing the bill? It's a good strategy but I think, a little change of it would be better.
    Signature

    check out the Pros and Cons of CPA

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6331874].message }}

Trending Topics