are blog comments powerfull?

Banned 8 years ago

Originally Posted by axel9

if lets suppose a site is da70 and pa40 will the comment in that page get enough value or comments dont get value, lets suppose is dofollow.

Count the number of links on the root domain and the number of links on each click to get to the page where you are going to place the followed comment.

So if the root domain has 75 links to internal links
if the category page links from the root domain has 50 links
and the page the link will be on has 45 links

then figure out what the order of links are, so if the link is the 43rd link on the page the calculation would be something like this:

(1/75 * .85) * (1/50 * .85) * 1/(45+43)

so if it's a DA 60, it will be worth about .0001302689393939389 DA

This doesn't factor in any deep links, or the fact that the navigation is a bunch of cross links. So it might be 10-1000x higher depending on those factors.

But it's likely lower since google will know it's a comment anyways and likely completely devalue it.

Comments don't really work man, seriously.

[ 3 ] Thanks
2 replies

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10473177].message }}

pororo

8 years ago

Originally Posted by irawr

Count the number of links on the root domain and the number of links on each click to get to the page where you are going to place the followed comment.

So if the root domain has 75 links to internal links
if the category page links from the root domain has 50 links
and the page the link will be on has 45 links

then figure out what the order of links are, so if the link is the 43rd link on the page the calculation would be something like this:

(1/75 * .85) * (1/50 * .85) * 1/(45+43)

so if it's a DA 60, it will be worth about .0001302689393939389 DA

This doesn't factor in any deep links, or the fact that the navigation is a bunch of cross links. So it might be 10-1000x higher depending on those factors.

But it's likely lower since google will know it's a comment anyways and likely completely devalue it.

Comments don't really work man, seriously.

Haha.. Nice explanation.

For ranking purposes it will not, but for generating backlinks they are. If you give value to the post and put a link relevant to it, someone (visitor(s)) of the site will link back to you or the blog itself.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10473651].message }}

axel9

8 years ago

Then what works man? what are powerfull backlinks?

Originally Posted by irawr

Count the number of links on the root domain and the number of links on each click to get to the page where you are going to place the followed comment.

So if the root domain has 75 links to internal links
if the category page links from the root domain has 50 links
and the page the link will be on has 45 links

then figure out what the order of links are, so if the link is the 43rd link on the page the calculation would be something like this:

(1/75 * .85) * (1/50 * .85) * 1/(45+43)

so if it's a DA 60, it will be worth about .0001302689393939389 DA

This doesn't factor in any deep links, or the fact that the navigation is a bunch of cross links. So it might be 10-1000x higher depending on those factors.

But it's likely lower since google will know it's a comment anyways and likely completely devalue it.

Comments don't really work man, seriously.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10474119].message }}

Sumon2k7

8 years ago

Blog comment is powerful, if you can make it. It depends on you. Doing relevant comment and adding appropriate links to every comment will surely help you build a good conversion growth for your website.

Blog comment nowadays a powerful way to become familiar with bloggers.

Thanks

Signature

**Unlimited Monthly Wordpress Maintenance Service**

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10473717].message }}

gaby81

8 years ago

It`s still a great way to spread your word about your business, gain new friends in the same niche and and diversify your backlink profile.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10473943].message }}

axel9

8 years ago

so is more about getting know and sprezading the word about your business but not so much a rank game changer?

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10474117].message }}

patco

8 years ago

Blog commenting is a good way to diversify your backlinks map! You can easily get some nofollow backlinks from good websites.. But be sure to use QUALITY blogs and write the comment manually (try to be informative and add something interesting, new, not just spam!)

... And if the niche is related and the blog aritlce doesn't have so many other comments (50+!) you could get a small benefit too!

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

A blog that will show you How to Lose Weight with a cool Quick Weight Loss guide...
Also enjoy some of my favorite Funny pictures and photos that will make you smile :)

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10474732].message }}

TotalWebsiteControl

8 years ago

Originally Posted by patco

Blog commenting is a good way to diversify your backlinks map! You can easily get some nofollow backlinks from good websites.. But be sure to use QUALITY blogs and write the comment manually (try to be informative and add something interesting, new, not just spam!)

... And if the niche is related and the blog aritlce doesn't have so many other comments (50+!) you could get a small benefit too!

I'm not sure if serious or not here.

nofollow links are bad by the way

Thanks

Signature

Get Your Website Ranked on Google Page ONE in 2016

ALL-IN-ONE SEO SOLUTION FOR YOUR BUSINESS

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10491907].message }}

malikmati

8 years ago

You can get very little benefit from comments links but don't spam and your backlinks should be mix

Thanks

Signature

Naya KPK
[/B]

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10474999].message }}

hieronymusf01

8 years ago

The thing to remember is the fact that even before the introduction of Penguin, utilizing blog comments for link building only offered value if the blog/website was credible (meaning it contained unique and quality content) and if it offered true "do-follow" links (versus "no follow" links), since these are the only links that offer link juice that will get noticed by Google.

Thanks

Signature

Get Best Cheap SEO Services India and Cheap SEO Packages India
Low Cost SEO Services India

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10475197].message }}

KylieSweet

8 years ago

Originally Posted by axel9

are blog comments powerful?

Blog commenting is so powerful to spam your website's link and honestly this kind of method is not for link building purposes but to improve the blog site with its suggestions and ideas.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10475206].message }}

tekruiter

8 years ago

If the blogs on which you are doing commenting are relevant to your niche as well as if the blogs give away a do follow back link into your website. Then you can say that the blog commenting are still valuable link building activity.

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

Kloakarbejde
Kloakservice DÃ¸gnservice

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10475345].message }}

nettiapina 8 years ago

Originally Posted by howareyou

The purposes of blog commenting is to building backlinks

No. The purpose is to comment on the article. That link is just a nice gesture from the site owner.

Originally Posted by tekruiter

Then you can say that the blog commenting are still valuable link building activity.

No, you can not. Read irawr's excellent example and try to understand what he talks about. And then consider the fact that Google may devalue even links that don't have rel="nofollow" attribute set as irawr pointed out. Blog comments are some of the least useful links from their perspective.
- Thanks
Signature
Links in signature will not help your SEO. Not on this site, and not on any other forum.
Who told me this? An ex Google web spam engineer.

What's your excuse?
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10475424].message }}

creaturelocaljohn

8 years ago

For ranking purposes, I don't think so. For conversion and brand awareness, maybe so. Just make sure you post something interesting and insightful that gives the reader some value.

Thanks

Signature

10% OFF For All Local Citation Services

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10475602].message }}

Campbell24

8 years ago

Comment links are not valuable generally because anybody can make them and Google knows this.

They are great as an extra thing to have if they are clean comment links and not spammy but still just not the core of link building.

Thanks

Signature

FREE SEO CONSULTATION/ADVICE (from a 7-figure earner)

I will answer your SEO questions 100% for free.

Just ask me whatever you want!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10476012].message }}

vishwa

8 years ago

Blog commenting is still effective and will drive traffic to your site. you have to provide relevant and quality comment to the blog topics.

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

Techbizmasters.com- Blogging, Technology, and Digital Marketing

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10480018].message }}

nettiapina 8 years ago

Originally Posted by dmammar

Blog commenting from from good blogs can increase your rankings in google

Originally Posted by cybnetics

Blog Commenting is the best technique to generate back link for your web page .

It's not anywhere near "the best technique". Theoretically these backlinks can increase your rankings, but it's not likely that they do. They're the lowest quality links available.

I know you guys are just sig spamming, but it takes the exact same effort to post something that's factually correct.
- Thanks
Signature
Links in signature will not help your SEO. Not on this site, and not on any other forum.
Who told me this? An ex Google web spam engineer.

What's your excuse?
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10481522].message }}

anhtt265

8 years ago

Originally Posted by axel9

if lets suppose a site is da70 and pa40 will the comment in that page get enough value or comments dont get value, lets suppose is dofollow.

Blog comments, forum postings and social marketing. You can use 3 things even without SEO. And you can get huge traffic. It depends on the way you do.

Thanks
2 replies

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10482015].message }}

maniarora 8 years ago

Hey axel9

First of all, nice question

For me blog comments have always been great for generating traffic and building relationships with bloggers, however they don't play any role in search ranking.

But I must tell you that the traffic you receive from blog comments rarely converts.

So overall, comments are only powerful for building relationship with bloggers.
- Thanks
Signature
Download My Free Book: A Simple 3 Part Process To Build a Money Making Website on Any Topic
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10482155].message }}
Andrew514 8 years ago

Originally Posted by anhtt265

Blog comments, forum postings and social marketing. You can use 3 things even without SEO. And you can get huge traffic. It depends on the way you do.

So what is the best way or technique to do that?
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10482362].message }}
- seocuibap1111 Banned 8 years ago
  
  [DELETED]
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10482388].message }}
  
  nettiapina 8 years ago
  
  Originally Posted by Andrew514
  
  So what is the best way or technique to do that?
  
  Perhaps to not do that? If you want "huge traffic" take a moment and do a sanity check. Is there "huge traffic" on the page you're getting a link on? Is your link prominent and visible on that page? Usually the answer would be "no" to both questions if you're doing blog comments and forum posting. Your CTR is going to be minuscule.
  
  Social marketing is a totally different animal. Good targeting may yield exceptional results, but you probably have to experiment a lot.
  
  Originally Posted by seocuibap1111
  
  I do not valuable backlink
  
  Well, your sigs pretty much says that you indeed "do not valuable backlink".
  
  Thanks
  
  1 reply
  
  Signature
  Links in signature will not help your SEO. Not on this site, and not on any other forum.
  Who told me this? An ex Google web spam engineer.
  
  What's your excuse?
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10483555].message }}
  
  Bishwajit1995 8 years ago
  
  Blog comments are still powerful if you post comment with relevant with your site and grow your conversion. Blog commenting is default nofollow. So, It doesn't affect ranking but helps to increase visitor to your site.
  
  Thanks
  
  Signature
  Upwork Freelancer
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10491739].message }}

eurohttp

8 years ago

Blog commenting is good for making specific page popular which you are commenting. Also blog comments can contain your website link or a blog and your username. Seems fair way to get something out of it.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10492067].message }}

Curtis2011

8 years ago

Google is well aware of blog comment spam for backlinks. This type of backlink is one of the least valuable that you can get.

I would bet that Google nowadays probably reads the text on the page and determines which part of the text is just blog comments, and specifically makes blog comment links less valuable, given how spammed they have been by SEO'ers historically.

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10492463].message }}

Campbell24 8 years ago

This is a tricky one because things like these ARE COMPLETELY SUBJECTIVE.

We can't tell, based on some arbitrary PA/DA metrics, what is going to happen in the SERPs in relation to your question.

For example, DA can be "faked" and pumped up with GSA but will not be respected by Google.

And this is what I suspect in this case.
- Thanks
Signature

FREE SEO CONSULTATION/ADVICE (from a 7-figure earner)

I will answer your SEO questions 100% for free.

Just ask me whatever you want!
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10492472].message }}

abhishek786

8 years ago

Originally Posted by axel9

if lets suppose a site is da70 and pa40 will the comment in that page get enough value or comments dont get value, lets suppose is dofollow.

Blog Commenting on High DA and High PA will get you High Quality Backlinks and Traffic. They Generally Do not affect your ranking but helps in increasing DA and PA of your Web Page.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10492707].message }}

techvalens

8 years ago

Yes, Blog comments is powerful but it gives you little benefit on increasing your Page Rank and Traffic. If you are commenting on relevant or niche blog with proper links, definitely you will get some good and quality backlinks.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10492739].message }}

mindtricks18

Banned 8 years ago

Blog commenting can serve as a powerful marketing strategy. By posting insightful, valuable comments on blog articles related to your own niche, you can drive traffic to your site and increase its authoritativeness within your industry.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10492770].message }}

alinajack218

Banned 8 years ago

[DELETED]

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10492772].message }}

nettiapina

8 years ago

Originally Posted by techvalens

Yes, Blog comments is powerful but it gives you little benefit on increasing your Page Rank and Traffic. If you are commenting on relevant or niche blog with proper links, definitely you will get some good and quality backlinks.

So what you're saying is that blog commenting "is powerful" except that it doesn't really work for increasing rankings or getting traffic, but it still works for increasing rankings. You know, that's a tad confusing.

Originally Posted by mindtricks18

Blog commenting can serve as a powerful marketing strategy. By posting insightful, valuable comments on blog articles related to your own niche, you can drive traffic to your site and increase its authoritativeness within your industry.

Maybe, maybe not. I'd claim that it's devilishly difficult to make a blog comment so good that even a small portion of the readers are actually going to click your link. Maybe the blog author notices you, but if they're running a huge blog they're going to forget your name soon. In this sense blog comments may help you, but don't expect too much.

Thanks

Signature

Links in signature will not help your SEO. Not on this site, and not on any other forum.
Who told me this? An ex Google web spam engineer.

What's your excuse?

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10492927].message }}

Jonathongs

Banned 8 years ago

Blog comment is not helpful for seo but can be used as traffic source.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10497537].message }}

Engineer2Blogger

8 years ago

Blog commenting on good quality blogs, especially if you're able to provide value and strike up a conversation can definitely get you some decent traffic.

Thanks

Signature

-->2 Teespring Campaigns That Have Made me Over $3,000 Profit!<--

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[10497982].message }}

are blog comments powerfull?

Trending Topics

How did you turn it all around?

Any thoughts on golf's latest phenom...Scottie Scheffler??

What's the Best IM-Related Skill to Learn Today That Can Help in the Future?

Some interesting stats about brand comms

best high quality crypto traffic.