I have a dilemma and what better brains to pick than those of fellow warriors.
I made the mistake of going to broad with keyword targeting on a page. It was an experiment of sorts and did not pan out.
So, instead of being precise and making a separate posts about, say, "best red apples", "best yellow apples"...etc...I went with "best apples" and tried to cover everything in the post.
I then got some nice links to it but it, but results are noting to write home about. Basically, I tried to get it all and got diddly-squat.
My question is - what do you guys think I can expect if I write a new "narrower" post and 301 the old gigantic page to a more focused one. The sources & anchors of the links will be still highly relevant, but the the post would focus on only a part of the keywords.
I'm afraid the links might be devalued since the page will be very different.
Thanks for your thoughts in advance