I see 172 results in Google when I search for site:https://www.faremakers.com. If you believe more pages of your domain should be indexed, check out your robots.txt (https://www.faremakers.com/robots.txt). You have a lot of directories disallowed, what is probably OK, but double-check it to make sure you don't block there any part of your website which should be indexed by the search engines.

With robots.txt file you can mention the pages which you want to be indexed. Or if you don't have any developing issue, analyze your site as per SEO point of you.

As an aside KF I'd immediately get rid of that "Beware" pop up because fear is like the infection you speak of Meaning, you are afraid that visitors think you're some other website but you are the real deal, and that pop up with an exclamation point will scare off more readers than it informs.

Think of it this way buddy; if you were driving around a corner in Lowari, Pakistan. If you saw a "Beware" sign with an exclamation point you'd tense up, fearing you'd drive off a curve toward your death, unless you were very, very careful. Same type of feeling/conditioning when folks visit your site; tensing up, being cautious. Not a good first impression

In truth too this affects your SEO because your bounce rate will be high; I left your site immediately because of the pop up.

Ryan

For google rankings it's only important the content of your website. If it has lots of relevant keywords - it's a half of success.

Hi! Please do the analysis from SEO point of view or hire freelancer, who can do it for you.

If you are having a hard time you can get an SEO service