A Triple Listing in Google??

11 replies
  • SEO
  • |
Apparently I haven't been keeping up with things. I always thought a domain couldn't have more than two listings on any given search results page. Today I was checking the position of one of my sites for a particular keyword, and three separate URLs are in the top three spots. And then right below that is a link that says, "More results from domain.com", that goes to the rest of my indexed URLs for that keyword it looks like.

This site has fluctuated between having the top 1 or 2 spots for this keyword for a while so that part wasn't a surprise, but I don't recall ever seeing the same site listed 3 times on a page before, so that did surprise me. Mind you, I'm not complaining, but I'm just curious if this is some kind of weird anomaly that might go away tomorrow, or is it something I can hope to repeat with other keywords?

Like I said, for all I know it's been going on in Google for a while. If that's the case, I've obviously been working too hard.
#google #listing #triple
  • Profile picture of the author camalus1026
    That's kind of funny. Most people try to get at least ONE of their links within top 10 and here you are with 3. Perhaps google will assume you've broken their alogrithim and are working on a "Google Slap" this very moment.

    See what happens when you're an overachiever ?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1495143].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Dee Scofield
      Originally Posted by camalus1026 View Post

      See what happens when you're an overachiever ?
      If you only knew... NOT!! Google has nothing to fear from me, LOL.

      This was my first website, that I started about 3 1/2 yrs ago when I didn't know what the heck I was doing. It succeeded mostly in spite of my efforts, not because of them.

      Hmm, I guess I'll just enjoy my three links while they last...
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1495979].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author rickkettner
    Are you getting a full "brick" listing, or three completely separate title/desc/link listings?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1495987].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author TheRichJerksNet
    Yes the same exact domain name can show up with the same exact title on page 1 of google many times.

    James
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1496008].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Dee Scofield
      Originally Posted by rickkettner View Post

      Are you getting a full "brick" listing, or three completely separate title/desc/link listings?
      Yes, I'm not familiar with that term but I suppose that's it. There's one listing at the very top, and then two indented listings below that, all with their respective descriptions. And also indented, below those, is the "More results from..."

      Originally Posted by TheRichJerksNet View Post

      Yes the same exact domain name can show up with the same exact title on page 1 of google many times. James
      Actually the titles of each page are different, so I'm not sure that applies here?

      Originally Posted by captivereef View Post

      are you sure you are not seeing your google personal search results? clear your cookies and log out of any google services you use and search again
      I always log out of any google services when I'm checking on my sites' positions, to decrease the likelihood of the results being skewed by the differences between data centers.

      UPDATE: I finally did what I should have done in the first place (duh), and I googled the issue. It turns out that this is something google has been doing since March of this year from what I can tell. But it's possible that it's something they're still experimenting with, since it's still relatively rare.

      If I can believe the chatter I read about it, to get a triple listing apparently you need to have 3 pages on your site optimized for the same keyword, and the pages need to be linked together.

      But based on the URLs that are listed for my site, that optimization doesn't need to extend to having the same titles on each page, and it doesn't necessarily even require a certain keyword density. For example, let's say my keyword is 'how to clean blue widgets.' The page I actively optimized for that keyword is listed at top, and then below that is a page optimized for 'helpful tips about blue widgets', and below that is a page about 'how to clean other household items.' As you can see, there is some overlap in the titles, and the main keyword does appear at least once on the other pages. But the indented listings are definitely optimized for completely different keywords; however, they are all related to the same subject, and google, in all its algorithmic wisdom, obviously knows this.

      I noticed a small but significant increase in traffic on this site in the last 7-10 days, but since I'd been doing other SEO work I can't attribute it to the triple listing (wish I knew when it first appeared). But this is good news, and now I'm motivated to strive for a triple listing for another competitive keyword. I'm sure it helped that my site already had a modest amount of authority in this niche, otherwise I doubt that this is something you could easily accomplish with a new site. BUT, I'm no google expert, so I don't know. Anyway, having three links all grouped together is certainly more noticeable than two, so I've got nothing to lose by trying.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1497405].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author olamilekan2
        Congrats that is awesome. Just a quick note, i read that to get a double listing, you need to use thesame anchor text (keywords you wat to rank for) pointing to 2 different pages on your site from thesame link source. So i suppose getting 3 listings will be a matter of using thesame anchor text on 3 different pages. I have not actually tried this before, but i have had double listings by using thesame anchor text pointing to different pages on thesame site( one anchor text pointing to the main page and the other one pointing to the inner page).
        Signature
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1497521].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author captivereef
    are you sure you are not seeing your google personal search results? clear your cookies and log out of any google services you use and search again
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1496426].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author UKTim29
    Originally Posted by Dee Scofield View Post

    Apparently I haven't been keeping up with things. I always thought a domain couldn't have more than two listings on any given search results page. Today I was checking the position of one of my sites for a particular keyword, and three separate URLs are in the top three spots. And then right below that is a link that says, "More results from domain.com", that goes to the rest of my indexed URLs for that keyword it looks like.

    This site has fluctuated between having the top 1 or 2 spots for this keyword for a while so that part wasn't a surprise, but I don't recall ever seeing the same site listed 3 times on a page before, so that did surprise me. Mind you, I'm not complaining, but I'm just curious if this is some kind of weird anomaly that might go away tomorrow, or is it something I can hope to repeat with other keywords?

    Like I said, for all I know it's been going on in Google for a while. If that's the case, I've obviously been working too hard.
    Just out of interest it isn't a PR4 4 words seperated by dashes dot com registered in 2002 is it? I won't say the domain name itself but think I've coincidentally found it looking for decent keywords to rank for!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1497711].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Dee Scofield
      Originally Posted by olamilekan2 View Post

      Just a quick note, i read that to get a double listing, you need to use thesame anchor text (keywords you wat to rank for) pointing to 2 different pages on your site from thesame link source.
      It's true that I did use the same anchor for all three listings, but in varying amounts (going on the theory that you need to mix it up a little). But the anchor text for the two indented listings were definitely weighted to their corresponding primary keywords. As for them being from the same domain source, I didn't do it deliberately, but yes that's true, e.g. web 2.0 sites. I've never heard that before, hmm...

      Originally Posted by olamilekan2 View Post

      ...i have had double listings by using thesame anchor text pointing to different pages on thesame site( one anchor text pointing to the main page and the other one pointing to the inner page).
      Interestingly, all three of these listings are of inner pages, not the home page, although the home page does appear on the second results page for the keyword in question. However, I have very few anchor text links using this particular keyword going to the home page, so I'm sure that figured into the equation.

      Originally Posted by UKTim29 View Post

      Just out of interest it isn't a PR4 4 words seperated by dashes dot com registered in 2002 is it? I won't say the domain name itself but think I've coincidentally found it looking for decent keywords to rank for!
      No, not even close. And actually I made a mistake when I stated earlier that I created this site 3 1/2 years ago - it was 2 1/2 years ago, I had a major brain fart there (oops, where did that year of my life go??).

      But I think it's funny you would mention that, because I guess it points up how rare this is right now. Until it happened to my site I'd never come across it before myself, but now that I know there are other triple listings out there I'll probably see more of them. Kind of like when you buy a new car and then you realize that the roads are full of cars that look exactly like yours, lol.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1498267].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author UKTim29
        Originally Posted by Dee Scofield View Post

        No, not even close. And actually I made a mistake when I stated earlier that I created this site 3 1/2 years ago - it was 2 1/2 years ago, I had a major brain fart there (oops, where did that year of my life go??).

        But I think it's funny you would mention that, because I guess it points up how rare this is right now. Until it happened to my site I'd never come across it before myself, but now that I know there are other triple listings out there I'll probably see more of them. Kind of like when you buy a new car and then you realize that the roads are full of cars that look exactly like yours, lol.
        Ah right. The one I found had a pretty high Alexa rank 56,000 or something like that, not bad for a niche site. I was wondering how much the site I found made seeing it's doing quite well.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1498407].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author Dee Scofield
          Originally Posted by UKTim29 View Post

          Ah right. The one I found had a pretty high Alexa rank 56,000 or something like that, not bad for a niche site. I was wondering how much the site I found made seeing it's doing quite well.
          Alexa ranking of 56K?? Holy cow, it must get some good traffic. But you certainly don't need that kind of Alexa ranking in order to make a nice bundle from a niche site. The site I've been talking about in this thread? It's only got an Alexa ranking of 677K, but it consistently makes enough to pay my monthly bills each month. Not much more than that, but it's my insurance against being forced to get a j-o-b again. Now I'm working on making lots more niche sites, even if they don't earn as much as my first one. Once I make enough from those, I won't have to worry about something happening to my main money-maker.
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1498577].message }}

Trending Topics