Need expert advice on contradictory seo info

6 replies
  • SEO
  • |
Hi Guys,

I have received contradictory advice from sources that are supposed to know what they are talking about when it comes to seo, so I need some help to get to the "real" facts.

Firstly, I've been told on one hand that blog sites like Wordpress are treated to better rankings from Google than regular sites that have the same content quality and the same off-site seo (banklinks, etc), and have also been told that this advantage is only for about 7 to 10 days after the
site is launched and then it makes NO difference at all whether or not the site is a blog or a regular website. What the actual fact?

Secondly, I've been told on one hand that if you have a keyword targeted domain name that is 3 words or longer, then you should use dashes (-) between the word so that the SE spiders will be able to better read and decipher the domain name, and on the other hand I have been told that the SE do not like it when you use dashes and that the non-dash domain name will rank higher than the one with dashes. What is the actual fact?

I would greatly appreciate some expert advice on the above.
#advice #contradictory #expert #info #seo
  • Profile picture of the author bgmacaw
    On question 1, it's a matter of people not understanding what's going on behind the scenes on a blog, namely pinging and RSS feed aggregation. Since this is built into WordPress and other blogging/CMS systems this will give them an advantage unless this is done manually.

    On question #2, dashes don't really matter for SEO purposes unless your domain name might have a double meaning like experts-exchange. It can matter for resell purposes and branding purposes though.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1735889].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author dburk
    Hi gordonr,

    I will try clear up some misconceptions for you.

    Search engines do not care which platform you use to create your web pages with. They look at the final HTML and judge that the same no matter which tool you used to create it.

    There are factors that matter, like how you have structured your navigation, whether you have used keywords in your URL, page titles and anchortext. The nice thing about Wordpress and other well designed CMS platforms is that they automatically handle much of the mechanics of those elements for you.

    However, you still must alter the configuration and/or add plugins to fully optimize a Wordpress blog for search engines. You could easily build a website by hand coding that is far superior to the default Wordpress configuration.

    Another nice feature of Wordpress is that it has pinging built in. Ping-o-matic, which is made by the same company that developed Wordpress is installed by default and alerts search engines to your new posts so they are more likely to be promptly crawled by search engines spiders. However, pinging can be done by anyone, it is relatively easy to setup for any website and is certainly not anything exclusive to Wordpress.

    The bottom line is that Wordpress sites are not treated differently. How you optimized and promote your website is what makes any difference that you see. You might find Wordpress to be a tool that you prefer to make the work easier, but it has no significance to search engines.


    As for your second question, search engines ignore dashes, so a domain with dashes is roughly the same as a domain without dashes.

    There is one signal that makes a rather small difference that favors non-dashed names, but ever so slightly. Search engines, particularly Google use prominence as one of the 200+ signals that determine relevancy scores. Since the second and third words contained within a 3 word domain name would be 1 and 2 characters greater in prominence without dashes it might score slightly better. I don't think that difference is enough to be concerned with.

    Some folks prefer domains with dashes because they can make the multi-word phrase slightly more readable to humans. One of the best uses of dashes within domain names is to prevent the unintentional word combinations that could be awkward or embarrassing. For example, consider the following domain name for an online pen and pencil retailer without the dash. It could be a bit embarassing if you didn't seperate the right words:
    pen-island.com
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1735891].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author gordonr
      Frank, thanks a lot for your feedback. It is extremely helpful.

      And Don, thank you VERY much for taking the time to give such a detailed response. It is MUCH appreciated, and has given me great insight into, and a clearer view of, the situation.

      Hope I can return the favor at a future date. Thanks again.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1748167].message }}
  • I agree with Don Burk's reply above.. I was going to type a lengthy reply, but thank you for stealing the cake, Don.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1748611].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author paulgl
      dburk nailed it, but hopefully he won't mind a shout out from
      me on blogspot. Google loves blogspot. Heck, they own it.
      It comes SEO'd out of the box. Everything as far as search
      engine stuff is built in. Plus, you get added to google's blog
      list and show up in the "next blog," if anyone clicks on it and
      you are indeed the next blog.

      My experience with wordpress on my own domains, is that my
      free blogspot ones have kangarood right over the wordpress.

      But seriously, it matters more what you do to the site, not domain,
      platform, etc.

      Like I always say, .... If it were only that easy.

      Paul
      Signature

      If you were disappointed in your results today, lower your standards tomorrow.

      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1749434].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author webeserve
    What it happens is that in website like wordpress or quality website, googe send their spiders more often and the sites ranking are faster than other website

    in the two, you should us "-" so spiders can recognize pictures
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[1749567].message }}

Trending Topics