SEO Tools Comparison (SEnuke X, Xrumer, Scrapebox, AMR, BF SEO, BMD, Sick Submitter,Magic Submitter)

by 113 replies
165


#search engine optimization #amr #automated #bmd #comparison #magic #scrapebox #senuke #seo #sick #submitter #tools #xrumer
  • Thanks for the comparison!

    W/c is better or the bang for the buck! with high success rate.
    • [4] replies
    • Neat post. Will be great for people who are in the buying mode.

      By the way, since this is the SEO forum, it would be great if you start a different thread within this forum (or on the IM Products Review and Ratings forum) discussing your experience with each of them, and refer to this thread for your price comparisons...
    • What is W/C?

      Thank you.
    • Each of these tools is powerful, but the main power depends on how you are using it, which controls the success rate !!!
    • What is this W/C?
    • [DELETED]
  • Thanks for the nice post and great comparison. at the end which tool do you think is more reliable to purchase by price and work?
    • [1] reply
    • I personally rely on SEnuke X and Xrumer. Scrapebox is a must use software.
      - Using SEnuke X I create 1st tier links
      - Using Scrapebox I filter out the live links.
      - Then I use Xrumer Blast to create huge 2nd tier links.
      - Besides these, I use Nuclear Link Indexer to index all backlinks.
      This is my super SEO formula which is working after penguin too.
      • [ 8 ] Thanks
      • [1] reply
  • Hi

    Here is Alex author of Magic Submitter
    Nice job!

    Please make the following changes
    1. Magic Submitter has reporting ability it creates very nice report I excel format
    2. Magic Submitter has build in rank checker
    3. Magic Submitter works with third party captcha solving no OCR
    4. Add row Visual SEO campaign designer. Magic Submitter and senukex has it
    5. Add row Ability to add own sites. Magic Submitter has designer feature and you can add any site in it
    6. Add row socket mode submitting . Magic Submitter works in this mode and it is 10 times faster then browser
    7. Add row wiki posting. Magic Submitter has such ability
    8. Add row Preloaded Sites quantity . Magic Submitter has 3000+
    9. Add row sites network submittion. Magic Submitter ca do that
    • [ 3 ] Thanks
    • [2] replies
    • Hi, I am really sorry for the mistake and will update immediately.
      • [1] reply
    • But after scraping a list of sites and trying to scan it with magic submitter takes forever. This thing alone makes it worthless in my opinion
    • [DELETED]
  • Alexkandr Krulik , Updated. Do you offer any lifetime license for Magic Submitter ?
    • [1] reply
    • I am also looking for it, if you can find let me know too
      • [1] reply
  • I will be giving magic submitter a try in the coming weeks, does anyone have a good guide for it, for micro niche sites, or is there some built in training when purchased?
  • Have you done testing after Penguin? Rather than comparing features, I am wondering if you can do regression analysis per each software and keyword combination and its long term effect.
    • [2] replies
    • I am getting success after penguin too, none of my clients complained me. Its the strategy how I am using my tools- thats it.
    • Basically, I depend on SEnuke XCr, Xrumer and Scrapebox. After Penguin I am getting results too. Its not the tools, its how the SEO person is using them. My strategy is like following :
      - I create quality 1st tier backlinks using SEnuke XCr
      - Then I create 2nd tier Forum Profile backlinks using Xrumer
      - At last I create huge 2nd tier Blog Comments using Scrapebox.
      • [ 2 ] Thanks
  • The most powerful ones are Senuke X and MS, in my opinion. I used them both and based on the success rate (less than 65%) - I've quit on both. MS still has back linking bugs (doesn't post the anchor texts properly), but Krulik-the developer continuously improves its performance. What is common to both of them - for the asked monthly subscription they are waaay expensive and over-rated. I've posted my opinion on TheProgrammer's WSO promoting MS and my posts were deleted 3 times in a row. This is not a honest way to make money, man !
    For the $67/month or for $147/month I prefer to use Fiverr's guys - hundreds of thousands of more and better quality backlinks than using any of the above softwares. For me using MS and SenukeX was a big waste of time (open accounts, subscribe for each service, add new services and open new accounts for them when they become available, schedule backlinking, write and spin articles, etc.) and I prefer to focus on some other more valuable activities.
    This is my personal opinion and, from what I found on-line, I'm not the only one having it.
    • [ 5 ] Thanks
    • [1] reply
    • My opinion is don't compromise quality of backlink with money. Fiverr guys can provide you backlinks, but they will not ping and never index your backlinks. Without indexing backlinks have no value. When its SEO, never go for cheap $5 gigs, this may harm your site also. Rather hire experienced SEO contractors from Odesk, Elance who have positive feedback.
      • [ 2 ] Thanks
  • Really liked the comparison and the information provided. I am a novice getting into seo and this kind of information really helps. Thanks a ton guys.
    • [ 1 ] Thanks
  • this is a great review
    anyway, i will try to use the magic submitter.
    • [ 1 ] Thanks
    • [1] reply
  • Banned
    [DELETED]
  • Thanks for the sharing the chart. But for me all are still expensive.
  • While SENukeX is a fantastic tool it is an absolute rip off and the cost of owning it is beyond stupid when compared to other tools.

    Give me a lifetime license of Ultimate Demon anyday!
    • [ 1 ] Thanks
  • The comparasion is very limited. There are other aspects that needed to be inserted in.

    Nice post anyway!
  • There are lot of problem is SENuke like how to link a site in social network don't use usual link biut use the dofollow link format. In Article Submission almost all site don't have auto approve and only few sites. Also with press release. About forum.. You can't customize bio like {sitelink} is a broad term covering many different skills and disciplines that are used in the production and maintenance of websites. and the software just doing like this Web design is a broad term covering many different skills and disciplines that are used in the production and maintenance of websites. {Site link} also with web 2.0 profile.

    I think that tool is not the best in all of those softwares.
  • And most of the chart is wrong for Xrumer it can do all of those things except KW research, content spinning (which technially senukex doesnt do it uses an api), and pretty graphs

    Also it does have a free trial
    • [1] reply
    • I agree with you.. I have almost all SENuke softwares and of all that I usaully use SENuke even if it is not a complete software than xrumer.
  • I have a lifetime license for SEnukeX and it's the best decision I have made for seo. Senuke is by far the best software on this list... And yes, I have used every one on this list!

    Can't really compare senuke to. Xrumer though... But together they are a deadly combination!
  • I definitely have to support Magic Submitter. After all it's been one of the key factors in ranking many of the sites my partner and I have created.
  • Honestly, every one of these tools are great. It really doesn't matter which one you pick.... It's all about how you use them!
    • [ 2 ] Thanks
  • If anyone is interested to sell the Lifetime License of SEnuke XCr, please tell me, I am interested.
    • [1] reply
    • Senuke Xcr is the best software I think
      • [1] reply
  • I'm surprised Ultimate Demon has not found its way onto this list, it supersedes Bookmark Demon.

    Also Xrumer has a trial on the older version, and a scheduler too.

    Scrapebox can also be found for $57
    • [1] reply
    • I posted the comparison a lot of days ago...I will update this listing very soon.
  • I would be interested if someone updates the chart by adding Ultimate Demon and GSA Ser. Both of them are much more reasonably priced and offer lifetime licenses. Reviews for both have been pretty good as well. Also, could you add a row that lists which of the tools allow for addition of custom platforms/sites. I know Magic Submitter allows that and maybe Senuke XCR. Not sure about Ultimate Demon and GSA.
    • [1] reply
    • Sorry, I didn't use Ultimate Demon and GSA yet, I made this comparison chart based on my own experience.
  • What if you know nothing about 1st tiers, 2nd tiers etc and you're just starting out??? Which software is best for a real dumb dumb
    • [2] replies
    • No software is good for newbies, first one should have proper knowledge of SEO and then he/she should use automated tools, otherwise he/she can harm the website ranking.
      • [1] reply
    • I was just about to ask the same question :confused: Also who can recommend a good tutorial about tiers and footprints. I am still resaerching these info but would like to if anyone can point me to a good guide.
  • SENuke XCR is a great tool. gotta be smatr with it tho. really effective
  • I personally think that EACH SEO tool is a good addition to others. If I had the chance, I would have ALL of the tools, but currently with SenukeX, ScrapeBox and Bookmarking Demon, everything is alright. Many thanks for the post with the picture that you post different info about all tools!!!
  • Thanks, Very nice post
  • WOWW... very great yet informative table Faisal....
    Really good... but i had mention that Ultimate Demon not yet included... and GSA SER... Rank Builder Neo...


    =====
    A Healthier Life
  • For ranking low comp keywords, which tool is better in terms of being cost effective. Magic Submitter or Sick Submitter?

    I heard that Sick Submitter requires packets and a lot of tweaking to get efficient results. On that basis, is MS a better choice.
    • [1] reply
  • What tool should I use in the case I want to eliminate all the possible penalties??? My hunch tells me that there is no such tool that will guarantee 100% results. Am I right???
    • [1] reply
    • No, you are not right. Each of the tools I stated here is powerful and can work without penalty, if one uses it properly. Main thing is, it depends on the person who is using it. Proper SEO knowledge is very important to run these tools, otherwise one can harm his own site and that is not the fault of the tool.
  • you'll only get penalize if you use the tool wrong, scrapebox seemingly has a bad rap, maybe cuz the software's biggest advocates is another webforum. Anyway it is almost the best scraper in the world, some would argue hrefer takes the spot, i aruge with gscraper. some would say it's about the best poster as well... this is where a tool can get used wrong.

    commonly scrapebox is used to backlink your backlink of a backlink, in nearly all schemes it is used a tier 3, sometimes a tier 2 and it's in the hopes of passing on linkjuice much later while prioritizing indexing with mass link exposure.

    or you can use scrapebox wrong, read a "how to scrapebox" guide from 2010 and blast your money site with a 200k aa list.

    it might work, it might not, it'll surely dance, if it falls down or does a pirouette, is up to chance at that point.

    again it's in how you use the tool.

    amr is pretty cruddy now, but still works if you want to build a tier 2 and is a good way to update a pbn.
    • [ 1 ] Thanks
    • [1] reply
    • Scrapebox is an awesome harvester. I needed to drive some traffic to a new site awhile back so I fired it up, plugged in a few hundred niche-related keywords, & searched for forum posts that were indexed within the past 24 hours. I then ran the forums themselves through an Alexa & PR check to get a general idea of how popular they were. Trimmed the list down to 10 high traffic forums that have people actively posting about the niche I'm promoting.

      From there it was just a matter of joining, adding a link to my sig if allowed, and making a few GOOD posts / replies a day on each. The traffic is really, REALLY targeted and converts very well. Forum posting is old-school, but it's still one of my favorite traffic methods.
      • [ 1 ] Thanks
      • [1] reply
  • [DELETED]
    • [1] reply
  • Banned
    [DELETED]
  • Your wrong! Magic Submitter can index!
  • [DELETED]
  • You don't need any softwares tools to rank in the serps. The only tool you'll ever need is your "brain", if you have that, your onto a winner!

    Regards,

    Lee
  • Thank you for this. I've found that several competitors are using Magic Submitter and I've been considering it.
    Unfortunately, I'm allergic to monthly subscriptions.
    JP
    • [1] reply
    • GSA Search Engine ranker should be included in this comparison if you plan to revise this thread. Thanks for the comparison chart though, making it easier to compare those tools.
      • [1] reply
  • [DELETED]
    • [ 1 ] Thanks
  • [DELETED]
    • [1] reply
    • I've been using sick submitter for quite some time now, and I think it's pretty good, they just rolled out some new products which I'm testing now but in general I like their products.
      for those of you interested there's a coupon available for sick submitter on www.sicksubmitterdiscount.com , hope this helps
      • [2] replies
  • I vote SE nuke and Magic Submitter
  • Without being bias I am a big magic submitter supporter, I do 99% of my link building with MS and getting great results, from video ranking, blogs and websites.
  • Woefully inaccurate detailing of Xrumer.

    It is capable of posting at all of the CMS'es listed (or virtually anything without javascript), has had a scheduler for 5+ years, does have a trial, etc....

    I know Xrumer isn't very popular on this forum and that's okay. It's not for everyone and even less so these days than it had been in the past - but you would think if you were going to go through all the work to produce an infographic that they would have at least tried to get it right.
    • [ 2 ] Thanks
    • [1] reply
    • Edit: [Not sure, can't find it. Dont want to be seen as accusing]
      If you can write Mods for Xrumer. The possibilities are endless. The emphasis on if though. It's not a toy for kids to be playing around with, especially the eh College of Cowboy "SEO Experts".
  • SenukeX can be little pricey for everyone to afford it, Apart from this Magic submitter and Money Robot Submitter are really two good tools which I like to use at the moment for myself.
    • [1] reply
    • No better way to prove them then use them. I appreciate all the comments here as I'm still researching the value and use of these programs.

      I'm contemplating on leasing a VPS that will host licensed copies of SEnuke XCr, Xrummer (7.7) and Hrefer (3.85). There will be many more there as well, but I'm thinking some experienced partners to share the costs/use would be great value!
      • [1] reply
  • [DELETED]
  • What do you thinks about GSA SER ?
    • [1] reply
    • Its a good tool so far, I used it for a very short time, it is useful, but not very user-friendly !
  • [DELETED]
  • so for micro niche sites, what seo tool to buy?
    as i get better to have 2-3 tiers? so i need more than 1 programm?
    or magic submitter is enough?
    • [1] reply
    • My vote goes for SEnuke XCr. You can create 2-3 tier links also using this tool. Magic Submitter also can do this, but its not as much user friendly as SEnuke.
  • Great, can you tell me the novice should buy what kind of more economic and practical?thanks.
    • [1] reply
    • Novice should not go with the software which has monthly subscription. So, I don't recommend SEnuke or Magic Submitter for them. Start with Scrapebox (This is a must have tool for SEO persons), then gradually move with Article Marketing Robot, Bookmarking Demon etc.
      • [ 1 ] Thanks
      • [1] reply
  • [DELETED]
  • [DELETED]
  • [DELETED]
  • [DELETED]
  • [DELETED]
  • +1 for Magic Submitter
  • SEnuke XCr & GSA Search Engine Ranker are the best so far.
    • [1] reply
    • I don't want to re-iterate WHY I wouldn't touch any SEO software today anymore with a long pole.

      But just as a side-note, even in the past, before Hummingbird etc....did anyone EVER provide proof that they achieved great rankings using any of them?

      Claiming some vague statement how "XYZ is the best" is one thing...hard facts showing how Senuke ranked a site to the top are another. I have in-fact never seen evidence that, say, Senuke did ANYTHING in terms of rankings.
      (All you need to do is look over the extremely crappy list of sites Senuke spams to, say the list of article directories which must be the crappiest list of article sites in existence..same with Wikis or whatever other properties it uses)

      But...go ahead and pay the monthly fee for spamming some badly spun articles using brand-new Web2.0 accounts to PR0 pages...lol..and report back your "success" and what a good investment it was
      • [1] reply
  • [DELETED]
  • [DELETED]
  • This programs are getting close to their end.
    They are close enough to spam tools.
    I have tried them all and I can say the only one I keep using is Scrapebox, it has many nice and usefull tools and addons.
    Also you forgot about one which is way better, GSA ranker. I used it for a while, it was working great but on Hummingbird update everything went to hell.
    Hope someone find this post useful and learn to work it out organically and with real people with real choices.
    • [1] reply
    • I can say, SEnuke XCr, GSA and Scrapebox are still great tool and if they can be used properly, they can produce great result.
  • [DELETED]
  • [DELETED]
  • Hi guys! I really like the functions of Magic Submitter, but does it still work well after all the algorythm changes of Google?
  • Yes it does still work. It's the content and your strategy that make the difference. MS/GSA/SENX are all just tools.
    • [ 1 ] Thanks
  • Agree with you. Good Content counts + not going for tons of backlinks (quality over quantity).

    For example: a tool that i like GSA can build 1000's of backlinks which can help for nothing....and (by using strict rules), the same tool can build 20 or 30 backlinks (just to say something), that may help you to bump your ranks.

    Tip: GSA > YouTube Videos works very well.

    Just my 2 cents.
    • [ 2 ] Thanks
    • [1] reply
    • Actually, with Youtube I've found it BEST to create as many links as possible with SER. Most everything else I try and take a slower approach.
      • [1] reply
  • [DELETED]
  • [DELETED]
  • Nice report! But, I would still say Article Marketing Robot has the ability to take you so far, I used it for 1st tier backlinks and it was worth using them Thoughts may vary!
    • [ 1 ] Thanks
  • Thanks for the comparison. Would love to see comparison of "GSA Search Engine Ranker" with other tools.
    • [ 1 ] Thanks
  • Excellent post, some nice user reviews and opinions,

    I have used Senuke and it is fantastic and so easy to use,
    The price is extremely high tho,
    • [1] reply
    • Yes, SEnuke is still useful if it is used with proper SEO knowledge. Great result can be brought out using this precious tool.
      • [1] reply
  • Neat post. Will be great for people who are in the buying mode.

    By the way, since this is the SEO forum, it would be great if you start a different thread within this forum (or on the IM Products Review and Ratings forum) discussing your experience with each of them, and refer to this thread for your price comparisons...
  • [DELETED]
  • Last month i subscribed magic submitter it is not good tool but senuke xcr is good
  • Thanks for the updated table!

    I would personally go for GSA SER which is not included in the review above. Mostly though, i tend to stay away from those automated link building programs unless if you want to strengthen and diversify some 2nd and 3rd tiers.
Join the discussion

Next Topics on Trending Feed