BREAKING: Facebook pads "likes" for advertisers!

by PBMax
8 replies
Of course, I don't know this for 100% fact...yet, but the evidence is mounting.

It happened when I noticed a major slowing up of my ads after I ADDED $1 to my daily budget, so naturally I was curious as to why the "likes" began to creep in when they were steady at 500/day or more.

It wasn't the content, or EDGE, because that was getting commented on and shared rather well. (Google Plus has a much better engagement/conversation rate, but that's a whole 'nother argument.)

So after a few days of creeping along in "likes" I stopped advertising for not just 1 page, but for 3 pages I was doing. Almost immediately the likes started dropping. Not in big, noticeable chunks, but one by one they disappeared and are still disappearing.

I've heard that there are 1 billion+ "active" users on Facebook, but I've also heard 250k or more of those are fake, inactive or, now, "like fillers" for Facebook's advertisers.

Why would they do this? Simple. If you see a flood of people liking your stuff, then you're very likely to keep putting money in the Facebook machine with little regard to who's actually doing the liking.

It should be noted that MANY advertising accounts have large numbers of likes, but low "people talking about this" numbers. Why the discrepancy? The numbers should at least be 3:1, but that's not even close. Do "targeted, interested" people like a page, then abandon it altogether? That doesn't seem right.

My Bible devotional page actually has a higher ratio of likes/engagement because it has 14381 likes, but only 4669 talking about it - BUT that's a much better ratio than I've seen elsewhere. It's not the way I use the page because I get multiple likes and comments on every post - I do 2 a day right now. (Of couse, as my likes slowly start to fade, all these numbers will come crashing down.)

So, something's up. I can't quite actually claim Facebook is scamming the advertisers and cooking the books to keep people paying, but it seems highly likely.

It's a shame, too. I was really starting to like Facebook...again.

Maybe I'm wrong and that would be awesome...
#advertisers #breaking #facebook #likes #pads
  • Profile picture of the author Aaron Doud
    Devil's advocate. If you are advertising you are getting more people to view it thus more people have a chance to like it.

    Not sure if that is it but that would be the first thing that would come to my mind based on what you said.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8579326].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author PBMax
      Originally Posted by Aaron Doud View Post

      Devil's advocate. If you are advertising you are getting more people to view it thus more people have a chance to like it.

      Not sure if that is it but that would be the first thing that would come to my mind based on what you said.
      The problem wasn't getting likes - not at first anyway - because if my theory is correct, Facebook has an endless supply of accounts to give "likes" from. I have 14k+ likes, 4k+ people "talking" yet I see the same comment/photo likes from the same people over and over. Either I only have a few dozen outgoing people and the rest are hermits, or something's rotten in Denmark...

      Once I stopped feeding the beast, it started taking away likes. I didn't change anything as far as my methods go.

      I posted the same things, at the same (approx.) times, interacted with the people, engaged, etc etc - ALL the same activity on my end.

      It looks like I get real likes and as they come, Facebook sneaks in their "likes" to bump the numbers.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8579345].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Aaron Doud
    Which "like" on posts or on the page itself?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8579410].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author PBMax
      Originally Posted by Aaron Doud View Post

      Which "like" on posts or on the page itself?
      Page likes from ads, post likes from the likers.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8579454].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author dexture
    if real likes very less chances in droping likes
    if likes from bot (fake ), they can drop 3k in one minutes ,
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8579467].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author PBMax
      Originally Posted by dexture View Post

      if real likes very less chances in droping likes
      if likes from bot (fake ), they can drop 3k in one minutes ,
      These were real because they were from FB Ads.

      Could be nothing, could be a big deal. We'll wait and see...
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8579512].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author ppcmanager
    Hi,

    The "# of people talking about this" takes a lot more factors into consideration than just 'liking' a page. # of people who liked the page, who commented/shared the post, added it to favorites etc. Generally, you will notice that a very active, engaging page will have this ratio higher (total number of likes to total number of talking about this).

    So this is not a accurate way of saying that the likes are fake. Facebook did took action a few months ago and there was mass deleting of fake profiles.

    Link 1
    Link 2
    Link 3

    What main challenge for Facebook is to show that their Ads & Platform can deliver ROI to a business. Supporting fake likes certainly won't help them proving it.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8580519].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Dennisknows
    Interesting point you make. I to noticed that my ads do great in the beginning and then kinda slump... but I honestly believe it's due to ad blindness. They see your ad a few times and become immune to it.

    Plus if you're choosing "Do not show my ad to people who have liked YOUR PAGE" then the most interested people would have liked your page and now you're just going after the OTHERS...

    Facebook isn't a "set it and forget it" type business. You have to monitor your ads because what worked today might not work next week. Just the way it goes.

    Great that you're observant like that. Keep up the great work.
    Dennis
    Signature
    "May the optimism of your tomorrow fuel your drive for today"
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[8584088].message }}

Trending Topics