You could use the same theme Jarida | Just another WordPress site

I am using the same theme...That is why I wanted to replicate the look

There's no difference except the base color.
If your just looking to change the color and can't find the setting in your option panel,
you should ask the theme author where you purchased the theme.

you need to study the theme options and figure out how to change the colors and play around with the widgets.

go to the theme style and change the colors you want

you are facing the problem with theme setting issue. Just check that everything at admin is correct. If not then apply the correct setting.

Thats strange send me a PM Ill help out.

WILL-