Anyone up for critiquing a video sales letter?

14 replies
Hey guys, this is somewhat of an experimental approach to copywriting...it's basically used as a lead generation site for people looking to buy a new mattress. Never seen this done in this industry before.

It's in a video sales letter format, with a delayed contact form towards the end. Total length of the video is about 15 min.

Here it is: Mattress Los Angeles, CA - How To Sleep Better (Warning: Unusual Methods)

Thoughts?
#critiquing #letter #sales #video
  • Profile picture of the author Jennie Heckel
    Hi Lazersgopewpew,

    Overall this is a good video... but to be honest it does not grab me much.

    Now you asked for my opinion, and take it with a grain of salt, please...

    I write a lot of video scripts...

    Couple of problems...

    This video does load terribly slow... took over 15 seconds to load. You might want to put this on a video hosting plan so it loads faster.

    And does not run on all browsers... not AOL anyway... Does it run on Google Chrome?

    You state in the video that this is a short presentation... and it's 15 miinutes long?

    Sorry, but that sort of worries me, I would not say "short presentation" unless it is 3 minutes or less.

    I think I would have lead with the accidents... give it some WOW first, to get people to watch it... (Make sure the headline matches that if you split test this...)

    When you state 10 seconds to load... at the top, add some text there to give them some type of reason to wait 10 seconds so they don't miss this awesome content... that is missing.

    The image text above the video is not easily readable, you would want to make it larger and darker...

    Sorry, but I don't get it... Attention All Angelinos" What does that mean?

    The headline does not grab me enough...

    This is your headline....

    "Watch this FREE Presentation and Discover How Important Sleep REALLLY Is and What You Need To Know Before Investing In A New Mattress..."

    Headline needs work because...

    1. Most videos ARE FREE. Nothing exciting there...

    2. Most people already know how important sleep is... Where's the WOW FACTOR?

    3. What you need to know about buying a new mattress.... (snooze.... )

    I think the real sales letter did not start until over 50% of the way into the video.

    I would add a pause button....

    Maybe change the headline to something like this...

    Is a Temperapedic Mattress Really Worth The Extra Money?
    Here's What Separates Temperapedic From All The Rest....

    Does Your Boss Think Your Lack Of A Good Night's Sleep Is What's Making You Grumpy? Here's that to do about it before you lose your job!

    Find out why 94% of Temperapeadic Owners
    Are Less Grumpy than Owners Of Other Mattress Brands!

    I think you get the drift here.... Just add a little more EXCITEMENT to it...

    I would split test this and cut the video to start at the accident part... for a 7 to 8 minute video.

    I would also split test to start at the section towards the end that tells about the differences and make a super short 3 to 4 minute video...

    You will find the short one will probably get the highest click through rate.

    Good luck with your split testing!
    Signature
    ******* WSO & JV ZOO COPYWRITER -- VLS & SALES LETTERS PROVEN TO CONVERT ******* Get Higher Profits From Launches That SELL! Proven Copywriter with 17 Years of Copywriting Experience. Contact Me Via Skype: seoexpertconsulting Copywriting Website: http://www.VideoScriptCopywriter.com

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5453981].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Sean Fry
      Wow! That's a massive critique! I def appreciate that.

      Originally Posted by Jennie Heckel View Post

      Hi Lazersgopewpew,

      Overall this is a good video... but to be honest it does not grab me much.

      Now you asked for my opinion, and take it with a grain of salt, please...

      I write a lot of video scripts...

      Couple of problems...

      This video does load terribly slow... took over 15 seconds to load. You might want to put this on a video hosting plan so it loads faster.
      That's very interesting because it's really fast for me, even on my workplaces ultra crappy internet connection. I'll look into this. It's hard to make these kinds of sales videos load quickly without losing massive amounts of quality. I host on amazon s3, btw.

      The total data rate is 414kbps, and will steam over a 512kbps, DSL/Cable connection.

      And does not run on all browsers... not AOL anyway... Does it run on Google Chrome?
      I actually wasn't aware that AOL even had a browser anymore! I haven't tested it yet on chrome, but I'd be amazed if it didn't work on chrome.

      You state in the video that this is a short presentation... and it's 15 miinutes long?

      Sorry, but that sort of worries me, I would not say "short presentation" unless it is 3 minutes or less.
      Yes, almost every sales video I've ever seen said that, and then the video ends up being 20-30 minutes long. I didn't realize it was an issue. I just thought everyone says it's going to be a "short" video to get people to relax a bit, and then suck them in...next thing they know, they've watched a half hour long sales video.

      I think I would have lead with the accidents... give it some WOW first, to get people to watch it... (Make sure the headline matches that if you split test this...)
      I thought about that actually, I just couldn't figure out an angle to use because it just didn't "make sense" to lead with that without laying the foundation. So I went with Bencivenga's "Picture this..."

      When you state 10 seconds to load... at the top, add some text there to give them some type of reason to wait 10 seconds so they don't miss this awesome content... that is missing.
      Yeah, I just used what Haddad and Benson use at the top of their vids.

      The image text above the video is not easily readable, you would want to make it larger and darker...

      Sorry, but I don't get it... Attention All Angelinos" What does that mean?
      You've never heard that? Los Angeles residents are often referred to as "Angelinos." Maybe that hasn't made it out to Wisconsin. :p

      But that's actually a good point. Not everyone knows the term.

      The headline does not grab me enough...

      This is your headline....

      "Watch this FREE Presentation and Discover How Important Sleep REALLLY Is and What You Need To Know Before Investing In A New Mattress..."

      Headline needs work because...

      1. Most videos ARE FREE. Nothing exciting there...
      Only added the FREE thing 'cuz I see other copywriters do it in the headline.

      2. Most people already know how important sleep is... Where's the WOW FACTOR?
      I have to correct you on that actually. You would assume that people know how important sleep is...but that isn't actually true. I've got a background in this industry, and I can tell you with 100% certainty that people do NOT know how important sleep is. They "think" they know, but they really don't. Because they don't know, they actually don't place a high value on sleep. Even a lot of doctors don't know, which I mention in the copy.

      In fact, this entire point is literally the purpose of the sales video. It's the main reason why I made it in the first place. However I *do* agree with you that it isn't a big "wow factor" within the context of the headline. I had a hard time with the headline.

      3. What you need to know about buying a new mattress.... (snooze.... )
      Well, believe it or not, people on the market for a mattress do actually want to know what they should look for, etc. I know it's not exciting, but it's really hard to make this topic exciting, and I also agree that it isn't an exciting component of the headline.

      I think the real sales letter did not start until over 50% of the way into the video.
      I tried to go with Bencivenga's "educational" and "informative" approach to copywriting, then lead them to the natural conclusion.

      I would add a pause button....
      If you click the video it pauses, just like 99% of every other video sales letter. I realize this is something that irritates a lot of warriors, but evidently it does increase conversions for many people.

      Maybe change the headline to something like this...

      Is a Temperapedic Mattress Really Worth The Extra Money?
      Here's What Separates Temperapedic From All The Rest....
      I did consider that. But that would be opening with the solution, and people on the market aren't necessarily looking for a tempurpedic right away. In addition, tempurpedic is very polarizing. Tempurpedic is the solution in my case, and I didn't want to lead with that without laying the foundation.

      Video sales letters give you the opportunity to lay the foundation in a way that literally not possible in "real life." I didn't want to alienate viewers who would be predisposed to click away as soon as they see Tempurpedic (because they are quite expensive.)

      I'm basically "fishing" for folks who are interested in tempurpedic and who have the disposable income for it.

      Does Your Boss Think Your Lack Of A Good Night's Sleep Is What's Making You Grumpy? Here's that to do about it before you lose your job!

      Find out why 94% of Temperapeadic Owners
      Are Less Grumpy than Owners Of Other Mattress Brands!

      I think you get the drift here.... Just add a little more EXCITEMENT to it...

      I would split test this and cut the video to start at the accident part... for a 7 to 8 minute video.
      Again, yeah I did think about opening with that video. I'm still not 100% sold on the idea yet. Could be worth split testing, I agree.

      I would also split test to start at the section towards the end that tells about the differences and make a super short 3 to 4 minute video...

      You will find the short one will probably get the highest click through rate.

      Good luck with your split testing!
      Any suggestions for how to split test within wordpress and without using PPC?
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5454570].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Jennie Heckel
        Hi Lazers,

        Wordpress is a little funky with split testing.

        I would invest in Optimize Press lots of goodies there for you to use to help with split testing.

        You know the ONLY way anyone really knows is to test, and test and test...

        That's the nature of the beast.

        Good comments, and remember that over 120 MILLION users STILL use AOL for their browser, so you are effectively blocking a large part of the market when a video does not run on AOL. Lots of newbies use AOL too.

        Remember a video should always be tested on dial up, not everybody has a high speed connection... or uses a low high speed... or even satellite, which is slow high speed.

        Now if this is a LOCAL only market then that is fine... but don't always use what the gurus are using in IM for a Mattress product or it could backfire on you.

        What works in IM does not convert well to many other markets... You did follow Ryan Deiss's Video Sales Letter Forumula quite well.... So just split test it in different flavors, headlines, times, etc.

        Good luck with your sales!
        Signature
        ******* WSO & JV ZOO COPYWRITER -- VLS & SALES LETTERS PROVEN TO CONVERT ******* Get Higher Profits From Launches That SELL! Proven Copywriter with 17 Years of Copywriting Experience. Contact Me Via Skype: seoexpertconsulting Copywriting Website: http://www.VideoScriptCopywriter.com

        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5458781].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author billyme
    Here's some improvements I'd make (from the eyes of a consumer):

    x The first three things I saw when I opened the page were a black screen (video not loading - Google chrome), bland title, then something telling me to wait 10 seconds - though I did love the follow-up about the speakers.
    x The video isn't showing up (worth another mention).
    x Lack of passion - some nice, emotional words but lacking anything behind them
    x I'm not emotionally involved.
    x How is this super important to me RIGHT NOW?
    x Why should I stay?
    x Any form of testimonials or evidence to back up your claims. I wouldn't watch more than a few seconds of the video, if at all, because of this.
    x Too plain, honestly.

    This list was made with an extremely critical eye; hopefully, this will be to your benefit. I don't think you need to fix everything and a lot of it is simply repetitive. You can easily run a website, but I'd recommend looking at most of these eventually. I'll check back later to see if your video is up.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5459639].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Sean Fry
    There's an issue with the plugin that I'm using and google chrome for some reason. I'm working on that. It does work in Firefox however.

    In the meantime, does anyone have a suggestion for a reliable video plugin for wordpress that supports the .mp4 format that works in all browsers?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5460606].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author BrianMcLeod
      Originally Posted by lazersgopewpew View Post

      There's an issue with the plugin that I'm using and google chrome for some reason. I'm working on that. It does work in Firefox however.

      In the meantime, does anyone have a suggestion for a reliable video plugin for wordpress that supports the .mp4 format that works in all browsers?
      Easy Video Player

      EasyVideoPlayer »
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5464089].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Sean Fry
        Alright, finally fixed it so it plays in Chrome and other browsers...had an issue with my server that was preventing it from working.

        Anyone else want to take a crack at it? Feel free to rip it to shreds.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5481963].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author betanet
    Hey... SO I would say the lack of header is kinda weird... and I personally think you should add a sentence below sayign something like: "The follow up page (whatever that will be) will be available after the video..." Cause youre gonna get a lot of people to the page who have never seen pages like this before. I know the first time I did I thought the page was broken, and left.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5482705].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author marc643
      Hey i'm answering solely as a consumer as i'm no copywriter.

      I watched the video through and if I were looking for a mattress I would be interested in your offer.

      However I feel that if i were shopping i would have probably clicked out before the video finished and ill tell you why.
      The section where you discuss why sleep is so important goes on for too long, the video was fine in some bits, but then it became too much, but once it passed and you got on to the mattress I was interested in what you had to say about tempur ( i think thats right) mattresses. In my opinion the video is decent but needs to be condensed inorder to keep peoples attention.

      Hope this helps!
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5482868].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Sean Fry
        Originally Posted by sebastian643 View Post

        Hey i'm answering solely as a consumer as i'm no copywriter.

        I watched the video through and if I were looking for a mattress I would be interested in your offer.

        However I feel that if i were shopping i would have probably clicked out before the video finished and ill tell you why.
        The section where you discuss why sleep is so important goes on for too long, the video was fine in some bits, but then it became too much, but once it passed and you got on to the mattress I was interested in what you had to say about tempur ( i think thats right) mattresses. In my opinion the video is decent but needs to be condensed inorder to keep peoples attention.

        Hope this helps!
        Thanks. I agree about the sleep bit -- another top copywriter told me to get rid of it completely, lol.

        Looks like I'm starting over.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5485167].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Sean Fry
      Originally Posted by betanet View Post

      Hey... SO I would say the lack of header is kinda weird... and I personally think you should add a sentence below sayign something like: "The follow up page (whatever that will be) will be available after the video..." Cause youre gonna get a lot of people to the page who have never seen pages like this before. I know the first time I did I thought the page was broken, and left.
      Wait, because there is no "header" stretching across the top of the page? Is that what you mean?
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5485156].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author The Copy Nazi
    Banned
    "Overall this is a good video" Jennie says. What? I beg to differ. This is a COMPLETE DUD. Terrible. A snoozefest. No-one is going to watch that. Make it entertaining. There is NOTHING...I repeat NOTHING, worth saving from that schlock.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5485477].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Ross Bowring
    You need an overhaul... and that should definitely include the statistical laundry list about "drowsy driving" and the accompanying video of the guy in the car accident.

    You're best to refer (quickly) to studies that show how a lack of sleep can contribute to serious on-going health problems, mood issues and aches and pains.

    Plus... is there a special technological breakthrough associated with the mattress products you're selling? If there is, why aren't you making it a big deal in your copy?

    --- Ross
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5489994].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Sean Fry
      Originally Posted by The Copy Nazi View Post

      "Overall this is a good video" Jennie says. What? I beg to differ. This is a COMPLETE DUD. Terrible. A snoozefest. No-one is going to watch that. Make it entertaining. There is NOTHING...I repeat NOTHING, worth saving from that schlock.
      Thanks for the thought provoking critique.

      Originally Posted by Ross Bowring View Post

      You need an overhaul... and that should definitely include the statistical laundry list about "drowsy driving" and the accompanying video of the guy in the car accident.

      You're best to refer (quickly) to studies that show how a lack of sleep can contribute to serious on-going health problems, mood issues and aches and pains.

      Plus... is there a special technological breakthrough associated with the mattress products you're selling? If there is, why aren't you making it a big deal in your copy?

      --- Ross
      Scientific findings and copy don't work very well, do they? I'm going to redo this and take out probably 98% of the science/statistics stuff.

      Thanks for the suggestions, Ross.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5490478].message }}

Trending Topics