Seth Stewart

I got an invitation for Spin Rewriter, which is supposed to be a drastic improvement in article readability/understandability over TBS, and the demo video looks quite impressive.

Apparently it understands your whole article so it doesn't allow wrong grammar and poor syntax the way TBS will. So the articles come out good enough even for your money pages.

Anybody actually using it and can comment on it vs. TBS? Thanks

xxxJamesxxx

I haven't used it personally but I do own The Best Spinner and I'm very happy with it.

If you do get it though, keep us posted though. I would be very interested to see how it performs.

James Scholes

Seth Stewart

Yeah I'm kinda surprised there isn't more scuttlebutt about this. Everyone loves & uses TBS (me included,) but the one ongoing gripe is that the spun articles are usually terrible reading, unless you spend about as much time tweaking as you would writing a new article.

Spin Rewriter claims to change all that and result in articles that read perfectly, good enough for money home pages. I'm surprised more people aren't jumping on that, especially considering its low price and cross platform capability (Windows - Mac - Linux.)

I was hoping to see some reviews here before purchasing, but if no one else gets it, I'll just have to be the guinea pig this time, oink

golf69

Im looking foward to hearing how it goes Seth...TBS has worked well but it would be great to have a better option.

JimmyR

Creating that buzz is pretty difficult. We've been doing contextual awareness in spinning since March and it's only just getting talked about now. Generally people are pretty change averse, and tend to stick to what they know - that's why new technologies can be hard to 'get out there'

crystal2

thebestspinner is really great to use. have been using it for 4-5 months and never disappointed with it.

Affillionaire

Ok here is my personal take on the two.

I have decided to show you exactly what each of the spinners do. To show you I am going to do a 1-click spin with TBS and Spin Rewriter of the same FREE article, but instead of the whole article I am just using the 1st paragraph. (So you don't have to compare the whole thing) Here it goes:

Original Paragraph:

"The back is a complicated structure of vertebrae separated by discs, held together by ligaments and muscles. It must be flexible enough to provide a wide range of movements and yet strong enough to protect the spinal cord and the delicate nerve fibers which exit between each vertebrae. The proximity of the spinal cord and spinal nerve roots to the muscles and joints of the back is what makes a "bad back" so painful and so debilitating. The spine functions as a whole, so if we have mechanical disturbances in one part of the spine, even as far away from the low back as the neck, it can influence conditions in another area of the spine. Imbalances in the pelvis, problems in the sacroiliac joints, facet fixations, as well as joint restrictions in the mid-back and the neck, can contribute to the process of disc degeneration, weakening the joint and making it susceptible to injury. Back pain can be caused by any combination of sprained ligaments, strained muscles, herniated discs, and pinched nerves, any or all of which can lead to back pain."

Now Spin Rewriter's 1-Click Rewrite:
Uniqueness Stats: billions of possible versions (99% unique on average)

"The back is a challenging framework of vertebrae separated by discs, held together by ligaments and muscles. It must be pliable sufficient to provide a wide variety of actions and but strong enough to shield the spinal cord and the delicate nerve fibers which exit between each vertebrae. The proximity of the spinal cord as well as spinal nerve roots to the muscles as well as joints of the back is what makes a "bad back" so unpleasant as well as so debilitating. The spinal column functions as a whole, so if we have physical disruptions in one part of the spine, also as far away from the inexpensive back as the neck, it can easily influence conditions in yet another area of the back. Imbalances in the pelvis, issues in the sacroiliac joints, aspect fixations, as well as joint limitations in the mid-back and the neck, can add to the process of disc deterioration, weakening the joint and making it at risk to trauma. Back pain can easily be created by any combination of sprained ligaments, strained muscles, herniated discs, and pinched nerves, any or all of which can easily lead to back discomfort."

Now TBS Version:
3% Unique

"The back is really acomplicated structure of vertebrae separated by discs, held together by ligaments and muscles. It should be flexible enough to provide a wide range of movements and butpowerfulenough to protect the spinal cord and also the delicate nerve fibers which exit in betweenevery vertebrae. The proximity in the spinal cord and spinal nerve roots to the muscles and joints in the back is what makes a "bad back" so painful and so debilitating. The spine functions as a whole, so if we have mechanical disturbances in onecomponentof the spine, even as far away from the low back because the neck, it can influence conditions in an additionalareaof the spine. Imbalances in the pelvis, problemswithin the sacroiliac joints, facet fixations, as well as joint restrictions within the mid-back and the neck, can contribute to theprocess of disc degeneration, weakening the joint and creating it susceptible to injury. Back painmay becaused by any combination of sprained ligaments, strained muscles, herniated discs, and pinched nerves, any or all of which can result in back discomfort."

It's important to know that I used the "Low Risk" option in Spin Rewriter to make sure it ONLY used words that it thought would make the most sense, which should provide the BEST rewritten article it could. I also spun the article in TBS using the "Everyones Favorites" button with ONLY BEST possible synonyms, So this should be the BEST possible 1-click option from TBS.

No it shows a major difference in uniqueness ratings for both and obviously the difference shows in the value of the paragraph as TBS is easier to read and understand while Spin Rewriter has a little more mistakes.

But overall for the uniqueness of the paragraph and a few tweaks here and there, Spin Rewriter would be easier to make it more understandable and to be accepted into article directories or even some Web 2.0 properties, Than trying to bring the TBS paragraph up to a 40-60% uniqueness rate.

Now one more final test.....I decided to do a compare articles test in TBS with both rewritten articles compared to the original article:

Here is the Results for the Spin Rewriter:

Spin Rewriter Comparison.jpg

Here are the results from TBS:

TBS Comparison.jpg

Now you may notice a difference in uniqueness stats: I would trust these more the original stats. But as you can tell they are almost the same and it also shows that TBS is more unique.

So overall I have tested a few articles for not just uniqueness but readability and found them to be almost the same. So basically I find the two softwares to boil down to just 2 things, userbility, and options. I also believe that OVERALL, TBS is easier to use(even though it has more options if you compare what Spin Rewriter can do and compare the same thing to TBS I think TBS is better.

I also think TBS is better because of its options, you can do a lot more and get more out of the software. So my suggestion is to wait untill Spin Rewriter can show us a video on how well it rewrites a whole article correctly before it tries to compete with TBS and make it easier to spin(I mean having to push SHIFT +S is kind of ridiculous to switch between words) I like TBS TAB function.

Anyways I know I could of done a more thorough test but this became long enough. So if you still want to try it out there is a 5 day free trial(They don't charge you anything for 5 days) so try it out. Then come back and leave some feedback.

Hope this helps anyone in their decision.

Attached Thumbnails

   

matthewfermin

I haven't tried it yet and I'm happy using TBS. It's really great to use!

kulonuwun

well.... honestly i dont like monthly payment for spinner software. So why dont you try one time fee for spinner software and has lifetime update like spinnerchief?

lordkensal

I have used Spin Rewriter - and found it quite good. It doesn't have as many features as TBS, but it does seem to produce more intelligible spun articles. Plus, you can try it out for a little while first.

Seth Stewart

Thanks Affilionaire, for that great test & report. Sounds like in the end, Spin Rewriter, isn't as much of an improvement over TBS as they touted it to be, and that the spun article readability & uniqueness are coming out about the same. I just bought it, so I'll give it my own trial on a few articles and report back here.

jchengery

Hello everyone,

I was wondering if Spin Rewriter has improved since Nov. 2011? Is its one-click rewrite able to produce articles without any further modifications or do you still need to refine it before having them ready for use? I'd greatly appreciate any information you can provide - thank you.

Please take care and have a great day!

Joe Chengery III

outwest

Whoever said this was FREE, in this or another thread, is, well its not freee