Wordpress as CMS: Pages vs. Posts for SEO

by nplatt
10 replies
I've used WordPress for blogs but I want to use it more as a content management system for a couple new authority sites that will grow to 50 or more pages.

I'm considering laying out the sites using pages rather than posts. The parent-child relationship of pages seems like it is a good way to manage page heirarchy, and I like that pages are more 'timeless' than posts.

But pages also seem to be less manipulable than posts. For example, posts can be categorized for page heirarchy, and WordPress has lots of category widgets and plugins. Pages can't be categorized, but they can be somewhat set for heirarchy like subfolders of a traditional site. Also, post URLs are more tweakable than pages. Overall it seems like there are fewer WordPress add-ons and options for pages than for posts.

For warriors experienced with WordPress, particularly as a CMS rather than a traditional blog, what's your opinion on using pages rather than posts to manage content?
#cms #pages #posts #seo #wordpress
  • Profile picture of the author jonbeebe
    As far as SEO goes, there's really no added benefit because you can easily change the permalink structure for posts to look exactly like pages (as I do on my blog).

    If you're using a theme such as Headway or Thesis, there are plenty of SEO options already included, otherwise, use a free plugin like All-in-One SEO.

    You can opt to use pages instead of posts, but personally, I recommend using POSTS because you can better manage them with categories and such when you've got a lot, and posts work better with archives plugins and things like that.

    However, if you do use posts, the best way to get them to "behave" more like pages is to do the following:

    - Change the permalink structure to /%postname%/ or /%category%/%postname%/ (if you want a hierarchy)

    - Edit your theme and remove (or comment out) where it shows post meta data (such as date/time, categories, etc).

    - Disable comments by default, then go into your individual posts and make sure comments are disabled.

    You can even take it a step further (depending on your theme) and edit your theme to remove the 'Comments are disabled' message at the bottom of the post.

    Hope that helps!

    Jonathan Beebe
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2171823].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Louise Green
    Comments can improve SEO because it's UGC.. which Google does consider.

    At the same time, it could throw-out your keyword density so it might be a choice between that and UGC.. personally I'd go for UGC so the search bots have something to come back and crawl.
    Signature
    IMPORTANT MESSAGE: I'm currently on vacation & will answer all messages when I return - Happy Holidays!!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2171861].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author jasonmorgan
    he parent-child relationship of pages seems like it is a good way to manage page heirarchy
    You can have category parent-child relationships as well that will work in a similar way to what you looking for.

    Look more into query_posts and how you can use it to really customize how wordpress displays content.

    There isn't much you can't do with wordpress if you know a little php and understand how wordpress functions beneath the hood. It's extremely flexible.

    And back to your question, I use posts for just about everything except stand alone pages like 'about us' 'contact' etc...

    Keep in mind, you can have custom category pages, custom archive pages and whatever else you want to dream up to deliver your content any way you want.

    I'm a complete wordpress fanboy.
    Signature

    I'm all about that bass.

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2171892].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author bgmacaw
    I almost always go with posts rather than pages since that tends to work better with the overall internal design of WordPress and how most plugins work. If you're managing a lot of sites, keeping things simple and standardized is important. If you're building a single site, then you probably won't be as concerned about going with the flow.

    For SEO purposes, it doesn't matter a whole lot unless you're wanting to go for a silo-ish design. In that case, the category/post option will work better for you.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2171912].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author nplatt
      Louise, thanks for the heads up on UGC. I don't put much stock in laser targeting keyword density. Writing naturally and making sure the right keywords are there is enough for me. Comments are always good for interacting with users.

      John, you hit on exactly what I've been thinking with using posts, tweaking the code to exclude timestamps to make the pages look more timeless.

      Jason, I know enough php to be dangerous. I can't write or modify code more than changing a spacing number to move something here and there or commenting things out, etc. I'm glad you mentioned custom pages though...I think I'll use pages for specific content that I want visitors to see, as well as the usual terms and contact pages.

      Originally Posted by bgmacaw View Post

      If you're managing a lot of sites, keeping things simple and standardized is important.
      That's good advice, I think I'll take it.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[2171997].message }}
  • {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5432390].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author camay123
    This is an interestting thread on using wordpress!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5432470].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author FivestarHB
    I ve always wondered about the relative benefits of posts or pages, and I think Jon described some good benefits of posts over pages. I tend to have a main page as landing page, with high word count, high keyword targeted, and with posts as supporting docs pointing back to main keyword page. Many rank in their own right of course if well constructed.
    Signature
    I have Found the Ultimate IM Retirement Plan
    Done for you Marketing System
    17 Year old Company Recurring Income
    It is the Perfect Home Business!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5432556].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Davy44
    If you are planning to build an authority site with many pages, I'd go for CMS rather than blog. Sure, UGC is useful in that it helps generate fresh content. But, Google is placing less and less value on UGC. If you recall, last year or so, Google downgraded many UGC websites like ezinearticles, hubpages and so on.

    I personally prefer pages because I like to create large sites with pages in the hundreds. It usually takes about 15 months to complete each site. I also do the page optimization and link building as I build each page.

    By the end of the 15 month-period, many of my pages will be ranking in the top 30 sites in Google search result. So, pages do work for me.
    Signature
    PAYDAY LOANS- cash on demand!
    PAYDAY LENDERS You can trust!
    CHECK LOANS for unexpected expenses
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5432651].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author bougatsa
      In my experience Wordpress Sites build using Posts rather Pages get more traffic.

      I've build a number of similar sites with the roughly the same amount of content, SEO and backlinks using both just Posts and just Pages. For some reason(s) the sites build using just posts always seem to get more traffic.

      There's tons of debate for just posts and just as much debate for just pages BUT in my experience posts are better.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5628233].message }}

Trending Topics