Why do CPA networks start scrubbing??

14 replies
Hey warriors,
A very honest question.
I worked hard promoting an offer which pays 200 a sale at an Amazing network.
I got amazing conversion rates, 20$ epcs.
Every email Converted, in short 0 Scrub.
I asked for a paybump, got 220, and now I made 4 sales but none show and it seems I have been scrubbed.

The network is so amazing, an offer at EWA got me 0 conversions with 50 clicks.
Same offer at that network got me 12 conversions in 50 clicks.

Then why the hell did the scrubbing takes place.
The sales are yet the same legit and I should get the sales accounted.

And if such a thing happens should hard working publishers keep shut and let network have their hard earned money?

This thread should inspire all and get eveyone to think.
So what should be done?
#cpa #networks #scrubbing #start
  • Profile picture of the author PPV Affiliate
    It's not always the network that scrubs. Advertisers can set different scrub rates for different networks based on the quality of leads they're sending.

    The best thing you could do is split test the same offer on another network.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5895018].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author bqpennell
      Originally Posted by PPV Affiliate View Post

      It's not always the network that scrubs. Advertisers can set different scrub rates for different networks based on the quality of leads they're sending.

      The best thing you could do is split test the same offer on another network.

      Exactly, I ran creditreport.com with one network for months, Never had a issue

      had 100 leads with about 4300 clicks One day
      had 25 leads with over 5100 clicks 2nd day

      when i questioned them i was told experian was scrubbing since they were close to budget. At first i didn't believe them but then another network thats been trying to get me to run there offer vouched that they were doing this and i didnt run with them so no point in lying.

      Point is most of the time it is the advertiser not the network. However now if you are getting a offer from someone like say 25 and another company offers you 27 then yes i would say look at the network first as they will have to make up for the difference

      Proof tried and tested

      $27 per lead $1.24 Overall epc
      $29 per lead $0.72 overall epc

      Same offer same traffic, I would be willing to bet the network is making up for that extra $2.00

      I have 3 versions of CR 27/28/29 (well will april 1st again) And i get so many who jump right on the 29$ one. However i have always seen way better EPC with the $27 so in the end the $27 one is actually making more then the $29 one.

      Sad part is you can tell this to people 100 times and they do not care they always go for payout first when they should be more worried about epc

      Just rough estimate

      100 clicks x 3 leads x $100 per lead = 300$
      100 clicks x 16 leads x $25 per lead = 400$

      I will bet my home people see offer with $100 payout over a $25 payout they will run the $100 every time, Yet in reality it be more profitable to run the $25
      Signature
      1st Class is in search for long term partners
      Check out our offers -> Here <-
      Paying Affiliates Since 2010 & Climbing
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5895701].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author BozakAxel
        Originally Posted by bqpennell View Post

        Exactly, I ran creditreport.com with one network for months, Never had a issue

        had 100 leads with about 4300 clicks One day
        had 25 leads with over 5100 clicks 2nd day

        when i questioned them i was told experian was scrubbing since they were close to budget. At first i didn't believe them but then another network thats been trying to get me to run there offer vouched that they were doing this and i didnt run with them so no point in lying.

        Point is most of the time it is the advertiser not the network. However now if you are getting a offer from someone like say 25 and another company offers you 27 then yes i would say look at the network first as they will have to make up for the difference

        Proof tried and tested

        $27 per lead $1.24 Overall epc
        $29 per lead $0.72 overall epc

        Same offer same traffic, I would be willing to bet the network is making up for that extra $2.00

        I have 3 versions of CR 27/28/29 (well will april 1st again) And i get so many who jump right on the 29$ one. However i have always seen way better EPC with the $27 so in the end the $27 one is actually making more then the $29 one.

        Sad part is you can tell this to people 100 times and they do not care they always go for payout first when they should be more worried about epc

        Just rough estimate

        100 clicks x 3 leads x $100 per lead = 300$
        100 clicks x 16 leads x $25 per lead = 400$

        I will bet my home people see offer with $100 payout over a $25 payout they will run the $100 every time, Yet in reality it be more profitable to run the $25
        I can confirm the whole experian debacle. i didnt see any evidence of them scrubbing, but the budget talk is true. they started redirecting earlier this month.

        But FYI - 4/1 starts a new year for them and budgets and allocation should be wide open, so get on it!
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5916028].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author harrisunderwork
    On payout bump, I have seen networks start scrubbing.

    EDIT : BTW, what offer were you promoting ?
    Signature
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5895052].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author speedylikesKJ
      This post made by PPC coach will definitely help you out http://www.warriorforum.com/ad-netwo...scrub-cpa.html

      Originally Posted by PPC-Coach View Post

      A scrub means they take your info and compare it to their existing database. If the info you're giving them is already in their database, then they don't give you credit for that one. The thing that most don't know is they change the amount of time they'll go back to scrub the lead. Meaning, when starting off with your traffic, they, (they being the merchant), will take a lot more leads because they might only go back a week to find a duplicate in their system. Then they'll check to see if you're leads are converting or not. IF they're not, they will set the scrubber to look back even further into the past, (say a month or two now versus the initial week). So you can think of scrubbing as searching for duplicate leads. The reason conversions drop off usually for poor traffic is explained above, (ie they set the scrubber to go back even further in history).

      A CPA Network is not going to tell you you're getting scrubbed as they find out pretty much as you do. The merchant, (who does the scrubbing), doesn't tell you either. You'll notice it though when your conversion rate plummets.

      Now there are ways to combat this. First you can spread your traffic thinly amongst related offers to fly under the radar. (They scrub large volumes faster then small volumes of traffic). All the scrubbing talk gets very confusing when the merchant is the cpa network. There are lots of networks out there that run their own offers, dating offers are a primo example. The cpa network will set up a site to collect dating leads and sell them to 3 or 4 dating sites. So they'll pay you $10 and sell that one lead 3 or 4 times for much more then $10.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5895703].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author chintz24
    I am promoting an adult pay per sale offer which offers 200 a lead by ewhoring and PPC Coachs statement doesnt help me because I am sure all the members who I made sales to were not members of the site so duplicate leads are impossible.

    And ya I got bumped to 220 and bam no conversions!

    Its so damn frustrating.
    Signature

    12 premium domains for sale.
    Email connect@chintanshah.xyz

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5897370].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author mtmjohn
      Originally Posted by chintz24 View Post

      I am promoting an adult pay per sale offer which offers 200 a lead by ewhoring and PPC Coachs statement doesnt help me because I am sure all the members who I made sales to were not members of the site so duplicate leads are impossible.

      And ya I got bumped to 220 and bam no conversions!

      Its so damn frustrating.
      Like David said, always split test the same offer across 2 or more CPA networks. If you think they are scrubbing just move to another network.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5898415].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author harrisunderwork
      Originally Posted by chintz24 View Post

      I am promoting an adult pay per sale offer which offers 200 a lead by ewhoring and PPC Coachs statement doesnt help me because I am sure all the members who I made sales to were not members of the site so duplicate leads are impossible.

      And ya I got bumped to 220 and bam no conversions!

      Its so damn frustrating.
      This is the reason I stopped asking for payout bumps !
      Signature
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5899043].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author jacksite
    it's sad to know this info
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5899637].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Samrath Gupta
    Hi buddy....

    Are you sure they are SCRUBBING ? Sometimes Networks SHAVE as well and Many Affs gets confused between these 2 terms !!

    So, Are you sure they are SCRUBBING ??

    Regards
    ~Sam~
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5899826].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author chintz24
    Ya i talk to my AM and I Kinda trust him,
    I think the advertiser is scrubbing.
    Signature

    12 premium domains for sale.
    Email connect@chintanshah.xyz

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5905771].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Matthew NY
    The CPA networks don't scrub. The advertiser does.

    The advertiser checks out the leads that it receives from a certain publisher and gives that publisher a rating essentially. Say a publisher sends them 500 leads. Say out of the 500 leads, there is only 1 person that actually follows through to the end conversion. That publisher is sending leads not worth their money, and then they start to only pay for a fraction of the leads since they are bad quality.

    What CPA networks can do in some cases is shave leads. That is where they essentially take a bit 'off the top'. So say for every 10 conversions to have, they pay you for 8 of them, and take 2 of them for themselves. You can avoid this by split testing the same offer across different networks to see who is doing this.

    Hope this helps.
    Signature


    Want to see $500 days? Click Above!
    I will guide you the whole way there.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5906699].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author BozakAxel
    yeah, unless you're working with a real shady network, it's the advertiser that's scrubbing the leads. The network wants to get paid on as many of your leads as possible, and will often go to bat for you! but the reality is there is a lot of fraudulent leads getting submitted out there, so scrubbing is a sad reality.

    it's important to remember it hurts the network just like it hurts you. so unless you're dealing with a network that is not trustworthy, getting a paybump shouldnt effect your scrub rate. the issue I more often find there is that when a pub gets a paybump, they start ramping up their efforts to get more leads, which unfortunately can create more fraudulent leads.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5916012].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Ori1410
    Note that in many cases, it may take time for the Advertiser to approve the sale. So sometime, it can take a few days until you are rewarded with it.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[5929225].message }}

Trending Topics