What's Better for this - App or Mobile Site?

bryson · 23rd Nov 2011, 07:46 PM

I am putting together a mobile package for car dealerships and was wondering what is better to list their inventory a mobile site or an app?

Also what do you think is a reasonable fee for updates as I expect there will at least a few per week from larger dealers?

Thanks in advance for your advice.

TJ Rose · 23rd Nov 2011, 11:52 PM

I would say a mobile site because an app is just another barrier to entry for people to get over to get the info they want.

As far as fee for updates why don't you just include X amount of updates in the package and any more over set a fee for that?

rogerfung · 24th Nov 2011, 01:15 AM

Think about this from a buyer's perspective. Suppose a car dealer was able to convince me to download their app, how many cars am I going to buy? Once I buy, why would I keep the app, and clutter my phone

Definitely a mobile site

ElenaEn · 24th Nov 2011, 01:22 AM

Sounds like a mobile site:
-- cheaper to develop
-- doesn't send you or the visitor through the hoops of the app stores
-- can still be saved as an icon to the phone's home screen (works just like an app in that regard)

bryson · 24th Nov 2011, 06:59 PM

@ TJ, rogerfung, elenaen - Thank you for your responses. I was thinking more towards a mobile site for the reason you all outlined. The rerason I posted the question is that I read a case study where an app did very well for Volvo but it was more of a banding tool for a new model.

So here is my overall plan: offer an sms system to capture after hour leads and combine this with a QR code for smart phone users and have it tied to a mobile site that lists their car inventory.

I am going to request $30 to $40 per lead (I will decide once I get more info on there sales volume) for the sms lead generation. I am going to build the mobile site and host it. I am thinking $247 to build the main site up to 5 pages and $20 per page for each extra page. To do updates up to 3 pages per week I will include this in the hosting for $100 per month.

What do you think?

alexmobile · 24th Nov 2011, 08:51 PM

my vote is for mobile website.

- coded once, will work in all mobile browsers / iOS / Android
- will naturally integrate into their main website (i.e. main website will automatically redirect to mobile site when mobile device detected)
- I see no compelling reasons to have this packaged as an app really

Randohm · 25th Nov 2011, 07:57 PM

Use the mobile site. It will be more convenient for the client which will make things more convenient for you.

ElenaEn · 26th Nov 2011, 02:02 AM

The rerason I posted the question is that I read a case study where an app did very well for Volvo but it was more of a banding tool for a new model.

The way this works is: you market the "app" somewhere and then send them to the app store. Why not just send the visitors to the web app directly? The website can still be saved to the phone, so there is zero difference to the user.
in fact, a no-app version is better, since they don't have to log into any app stores to get it.

I am going to request $30 to $40 per lead (I will decide once I get more info on there sales volume) for the sms lead generation. I am going to build the mobile site and host it. I am thinking $247 to build the main site up to 5 pages and $20 per page for each extra page. To do updates up to 3 pages per week I will include this in the hosting for $100 per month.

I would make it simple for the client and charge for the initial web app setup plus per leads, or something they understand. They don't care about nor understand pages. I'd base my pricing on the initial site built based on the # of listings, and just mention the updates to the X # of listings per week (again, something they can relate to better).

ElenaEn · 26th Nov 2011, 02:06 AM

To do updates up to 3 pages per week I will include this in the hosting for $100 per month.

Just to clarify: I'd offer a package of, say, $600 a quarter for hosting and up to X listings updates (includes picture updates, text or prices changes, new listing additions, or deletions). "Please send me your updates by Monday to see them live by Wednesday" (so that you can do them all in bulk in <1 hour on Tuesday).

bryson · 27th Nov 2011, 02:13 AM

Originally Posted by ElenaEn

Just to clarify: I'd offer a package of, say, $600 a quarter for hosting and up to X listings updates (includes picture updates, text or prices changes, new listing additions, or deletions). "Please send me your updates by Monday to see them live by Wednesday" (so that you can do them all in bulk in <1 hour on Tuesday).

Thanks Elena, solid advice. BTW have you done something like this already?

PinkSpectacles · 29th Nov 2011, 02:43 AM

I would absolutely agree that a mobile site is better than an app. Not only is it easier for the user, but apps (as amazing as they are) alienate a lot of people. With a mobisite you can also design it with an "app" look and feel, so that those with feature phones can also gain access and get the information quickly and easily.

Freshmorning · 29th Nov 2011, 05:13 AM

Hello Bryson,
I would like to say that a mobile site is better than an app.It would be more convenient for the people to get the updated information they want.

mezner · 29th Nov 2011, 07:55 AM

You need to ask yourself why someone would download an app for a car dealership (very few actually would. It's too inconvenient and that alone will lose customers). If your client was cars.com or autotrader.com (huge car search engines), then that might be different.

23rd Nov 2011, 07:46 PM	#1
bryson HyperActive Warrior War Room Member Join Date: 2010 Posts: 216 Thanks: 77 Thanked 33 Times in 24 Posts	What's Better for this - App or Mobile Site? Share on: I am putting together a mobile package for car dealerships and was wondering what is better to list their inventory a mobile site or an app? Also what do you think is a reasonable fee for updates as I expect there will at least a few per week from larger dealers? Thanks in advance for your advice.
	Do You Do Local Lead Gen? Hate Cold Calling for New Clients? We Have the Solution.. Get Hot Offline Leads Today... These Leads WANT to hear from YOU! Sign Up Today and Get Clients!Local Lead Gen Leads

23rd Nov 2011, 11:52 PM	#2
TJ Rose Active Warrior Join Date: 2011 Posts: 87 Thanks: 10 Thanked 14 Times in 12 Posts	Re: What's Better for this - App or Mobile Site? Share on: I would say a mobile site because an app is just another barrier to entry for people to get over to get the info they want. As far as fee for updates why don't you just include X amount of updates in the package and any more over set a fee for that?
	FREE "21 Step Report To Position Yourself As An Expert to Offline Clients" -------->>>>http://goo.gl/gojkt

24th Nov 2011, 01:15 AM	#3
rogerfung HyperActive Warrior War Room Member Join Date: 2010 Posts: 115 Thanks: 36 Thanked 68 Times in 62 Posts	Re: What's Better for this - App or Mobile Site? Share on: Think about this from a buyer's perspective. Suppose a car dealer was able to convince me to download their app, how many cars am I going to buy? Once I buy, why would I keep the app, and clutter my phone Definitely a mobile site

24th Nov 2011, 01:22 AM	#4
ElenaEn Active Warrior Join Date: 2011 Posts: 50 Thanks: 0 Thanked 28 Times in 13 Posts	Re: What's Better for this - App or Mobile Site? Share on: Sounds like a mobile site: -- cheaper to develop -- doesn't send you or the visitor through the hoops of the app stores -- can still be saved as an icon to the phone's home screen (works just like an app in that regard)

24th Nov 2011, 06:59 PM	#5
bryson HyperActive Warrior War Room Member Join Date: 2010 Posts: 216 Thanks: 77 Thanked 33 Times in 24 Posts	Re: What's Better for this - App or Mobile Site? Share on: @ TJ, rogerfung, elenaen - Thank you for your responses. I was thinking more towards a mobile site for the reason you all outlined. The rerason I posted the question is that I read a case study where an app did very well for Volvo but it was more of a banding tool for a new model. So here is my overall plan: offer an sms system to capture after hour leads and combine this with a QR code for smart phone users and have it tied to a mobile site that lists their car inventory. I am going to request $30 to $40 per lead (I will decide once I get more info on there sales volume) for the sms lead generation. I am going to build the mobile site and host it. I am thinking $247 to build the main site up to 5 pages and $20 per page for each extra page. To do updates up to 3 pages per week I will include this in the hosting for $100 per month. What do you think?
	Do You Do Local Lead Gen? Hate Cold Calling for New Clients? We Have the Solution.. Get Hot Offline Leads Today... These Leads WANT to hear from YOU! Sign Up Today and Get Clients!Local Lead Gen Leads

24th Nov 2011, 08:51 PM	#6
alexmobile Active Warrior Join Date: 2011 Location: Toronto, Canada Posts: 61 Thanks: 9 Thanked 25 Times in 10 Posts	Re: What's Better for this - App or Mobile Site? Share on: my vote is for mobile website. - coded once, will work in all mobile browsers / iOS / Android - will naturally integrate into their main website (i.e. main website will automatically redirect to mobile site when mobile device detected) - I see no compelling reasons to have this packaged as an app really
	QRID.com - login to websites by scanning QR code on your monitor! No Passwords!

25th Nov 2011, 07:57 PM	#7
Randohm Active Warrior War Room Member Join Date: 2009 Location: Saint Paul, MN Posts: 50 Thanks: 24 Thanked 25 Times in 20 Posts	Re: What's Better for this - App or Mobile Site? Share on: Use the mobile site. It will be more convenient for the client which will make things more convenient for you.

29th Nov 2011, 02:43 AM	#11
PinkSpectacles Warrior Member Join Date: 2011 Posts: 2 Thanks: 0 Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts	Re: What's Better for this - App or Mobile Site? Share on: I would absolutely agree that a mobile site is better than an app. Not only is it easier for the user, but apps (as amazing as they are) alienate a lot of people. With a mobisite you can also design it with an "app" look and feel, so that those with feature phones can also gain access and get the information quickly and easily.

29th Nov 2011, 05:13 AM	#12
Freshmorning -Elite Warrior- Join Date: 2011 Location: UK / Manhattan NY Posts: 144 Thanks: 33 Thanked 11 Times in 11 Posts	Re: What's Better for this - App or Mobile Site? Share on: Hello Bryson, I would like to say that a mobile site is better than an app.It would be more convenient for the people to get the updated information they want.

29th Nov 2011, 07:55 AM	#13
mezner Active Warrior War Room Member Join Date: 2010 Location: Minneapolis Posts: 67 Thanks: 3 Thanked 4 Times in 3 Posts	Re: What's Better for this - App or Mobile Site? Share on: You need to ask yourself why someone would download an app for a car dealership (very few actually would. It's too inconvenient and that alone will lose customers). If your client was cars.com or autotrader.com (huge car search engines), then that might be different.