Big mistake making too long domain name? HELP!

I have a domain for some years now and here is what I am worried about so I thought I would ask the forum what to do.

1) the domain name is too long.
It is ____ - _____ - ____ . com / _____
2) as you can see it is not just 3 words but it has hyphen "-" in between each word
3) it also has "/____" I am not sure what it is called when there is a forward slash after .com
So that is a total of 4 words.

Now why this mess? Well I was just starting out and I was confused with so many people saying so many things.

So I put the keyword in there with the hyphen. Just wish I hadn't gone for the dashes. I didn't know anything about buying aged domains at the time.

And the reason for the .com/___ is because of a horrible hosting company I was with. They messed up almost a year and long story short.

Now the domain _____ - _____ - ____.com just redirects to ____ - _____ - ____ . com / _____

The reason I have never started over was because it made me money many months and it has built me a list and it has good traffic despite all this confusion.

:confused:Also I have been building up solid backlinks for years to ____ - _____ - ____ . com / _____

It is all so confusing.

I have hundreds of long unique nicely written articles. I have put all my heart and soul into it. Hours upon hours. I learned all the basics through doing this site bit by bit.

What do you think I should do fellow experts? I need help.

Do I:

1) Start over. Scrap the whole thing and just start anew.

2) Save all the content and move it to a new aged domain with good PR

3) Just continue.

Or is there a better way to go about this? If it didn't make me money I would just let it expire when it expires because ultimately it is about returns. Forget all the emotional ties.

Please do let me know.