29 replies
Hi I didnt know were to put this in ppc or offline.

Is ppc on Bing/Yahoo worth the trouble is there any local traffic ,the only reason I ask is I have a local clients site ranking on top of Bing search It doesnt seem to get any traffic .I was wondering if the ppc was any better.and cheaper than google.
#client #local #ppc
  • Profile picture of the author Mekanism
    it is cheaper for a lot of keywords, as there is less competition.

    but hey, its PPC. so if it doesn't get clicks you'll know right away and you didn't waste money (maybe some time)
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6764808].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author kebertt
      Originally Posted by Mekanism View Post

      it is cheaper for a lot of keywords, as there is less competition.

      but hey, its PPC. so if it doesn't get clicks you'll know right away and you didn't waste money (maybe some time)
      Compare your keyword cost with both, if your clients have a large budget then Bing might not be able to handle the quantity of searches they're looking for.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6770170].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Blase
        I use both Adwords and Bing/Yahoo.

        I run around 6,000 keywords on each.

        Bing/Yahoo doesn't get anywhere near the
        CTR that Google does.

        Because of the maintance for both I'm thinking
        about closing the Bing/Yahoo account.

        But, it is a lot cheaper more than half
        in most cases.
        Signature
        "Nothing Happens Until Something Is Sold"
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6770563].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author Mekanism
          Originally Posted by Blase View Post

          I use both Adwords and Bing/Yahoo.

          I run around 6,000 keywords on each.

          Bing/Yahoo doesn't get anywhere near the
          CTR that Google does.

          Because of the maintance for both I'm thinking
          about closing the Bing/Yahoo account.

          But, it is a lot cheaper more than half
          in most cases.
          I agree with your assessment. Would you agree that he should at least test it before he completely rejects the idea?
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6770760].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author Blase
            Originally Posted by Mekanism View Post

            I agree with your assessment. Would you agree that he should at least test it before he completely rejects the idea?
            I would test it for sure.

            It really depends on the market you are after,
            your cost of conversion and your margins on what you are
            selling.

            If you can not make money with "G" but you can with ad center
            there you go, even if it is less traffic.
            Signature
            "Nothing Happens Until Something Is Sold"
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6771530].message }}
            • Profile picture of the author Mekanism
              Originally Posted by Blase View Post

              If you can not make money with "G" but you can with ad center
              there you go, even if it is less traffic.
              Theres also facebook ads. they can work locally.
              {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6771553].message }}
              • Profile picture of the author Blase
                Originally Posted by Mekanism View Post

                Theres also facebook ads. they can work locally.
                I've never dond FB ads.

                What I sell is very niche and very targeted
                I've never found the demographics on FB that I need.

                From what I understand, if you know how to make FB work
                it can be good.

                I read an article from Shoemoney onetime he said
                his trick was to put up a girl in a tight sweater for the graphic
                and you will get tons of clicks. I would think you'd better
                have a very generic product to convert those clicks.
                Signature
                "Nothing Happens Until Something Is Sold"
                {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6771584].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Mekanism
    its really the same as Google adwords, except you need to include demographics in your testing. so you test pictures, words and demographics to yield the best results. sometimes you can achieve as little as 10 to 15 cents per click.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6788650].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Blase
      Originally Posted by Mekanism View Post

      sometimes you can achieve as little as 10 to 15 cents per click.
      I remember when Adwords was that cheap and cheaper.
      AAHHH, the good old days.

      All of my competitors where bidding on the wrong keywords
      until my ads stating showing up.

      Now they all copy me and keep driving up the price.

      I had a subscription to SpyFu for awhile and was watching
      the competition every ad that my competition was running
      was one that I wrote!

      It's really frustrating.
      Signature
      "Nothing Happens Until Something Is Sold"
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6788732].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author iAmNameLess
        Originally Posted by Blase View Post

        I remember when Adwords was that cheap and cheaper.
        AAHHH, the good old days.

        All of my competitors where bidding on the wrong keywords
        until my ads stating showing up.

        Now they all copy me and keep driving up the price.

        I had a subscription to SpyFu for awhile and was watching
        the competition every ad that my competition was running
        was one that I wrote!

        It's really frustrating.
        I still have pretty good CPC for all our campaigns... We reduced a $15CPC to $1 and this year have got it down to 25 cents a click.

        I also love bing/yahoo PPC... definitely much lower starting CPC and certain keywords convert BETTER on bing than they do on Google. I'm a believer also, that those who click on bing ads are more likely to buy. Almost all keywords convert higher with bing than Google in our testing. Anyway, that's still a debatable subject.

        The reason people do PPC on many platforms is to increase their branding, and their overall reach. Once someone finds a great keyword and copy that works for them, they want to expand the overall reach by going to new platforms.

        Majority of the traffic is with Google obviously, but that doesn't mean to ignore others!
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6788925].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author socialbacklink
          Originally Posted by iAmNameLess View Post

          I still have pretty good CPC for all our campaigns... We reduced a $15CPC to $1 and this year have got it down to 25 cents a click.

          I also love bing/yahoo PPC... definitely much lower starting CPC and certain keywords convert BETTER on bing than they do on Google. I'm a believer also, that those who click on bing ads are more likely to buy. Almost all keywords convert higher with bing than Google in our testing. Anyway, that's still a debatable subject.

          The reason people do PPC on many platforms is to increase their branding, and their overall reach. Once someone finds a great keyword and copy that works for them, they want to expand the overall reach by going to new platforms.

          Majority of the traffic is with Google obviously, but that doesn't mean to ignore others!
          Good points. (You are a busy guy. ) I had a campaign that I ran for a client not too long ago and Bing/Yahoo converted like crazy. Just couldn't get enough volume out of it. (I had a budget of $350k per month for this client.) I was still able to spend about $1000 per day on Bing and about $2500 per day on yahoo with a 150-200% ROI overall. The rest went toward Google. We were spending nearly $12k per day and pulling in $30-$35k in revenue per day. So, that's what I mean by not enough volume. The reason I found for the higher conversion rates on Yahoo and Bing was that the demographic is older and had more money to spend than on Google for that particular product. I've tested a few products and it really depends on the way you market the product along with the product itself as to the results. Definitely some good money to be made over there though.

          The key to doing local is just being as targeted as possible.(That's the key for any ppc though. But, with local I go even further.) I normally use the dynamic keyword insertion tag for the headline. {KeyWord:Here is my stock headline} That gets me the highest CTR every time. I've managed as many as 450 local business account with adwords at one time. I used automation and figured out a few key things to look for. (This wasn't in one location. They were spread over 3 countries) There is really good money in managing local ppc. I'm actually working on a training site right now to teach people how to do it. If anyone has any questions fire away.
          Signature
          Get The Best In Paid Traffic Training - PPC Superstar!
          17 Years Experience As A Professional Internet Marketer
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6789284].message }}
          • Profile picture of the author Blase
            Originally Posted by socialbacklink View Post

            Good points. (You are a busy guy. ) I had a campaign that I ran for a client not too long ago and Bing/Yahoo converted like crazy. Just couldn't get enough volume out of it. (I had a budget of $350k per month for this client.) I was still able to spend about $1000 per day on Bing and about $2500 per day on yahoo with a 150-200% ROI overall.
            One of us is confused.

            I don't get a seprate bill from Yahoo and Bing.
            I get a bill from the Mircosoft Adcenter.

            Yahoo/Bing merged in mid 2009, so it's been longer than
            "... a campaign that I ran for a client not to long ago"
            Signature
            "Nothing Happens Until Something Is Sold"
            {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6790668].message }}
            • Profile picture of the author socialbacklink
              Originally Posted by Blase View Post

              One of us is confused.

              I don't get a seprate bill from Yahoo and Bing.
              I get a bill from the Mircosoft Adcenter.

              Yahoo/Bing merged in mid 2009, so it's been longer than
              "... a campaign that I ran for a client not to long ago"
              It's because I've been doing PPC for 8-9 years now, SEO for about 14 years, and web design for about 16 years. So, for me 3 years ago is not really so long ago. Actually on this particular campaign I started work on it 5 years ago and was still on it as recent as 2 years ago not long after the merger. I'm new to WF. Not new to IM. I've been doing this for a living for a very very long time.

              If you want to get down to brass tacks it was actually MSN adcenter and Yahoo at the time. I said Bing because a lot of the ones that are new to this might not know what I'm talking about.
              Signature
              Get The Best In Paid Traffic Training - PPC Superstar!
              17 Years Experience As A Professional Internet Marketer
              {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6790747].message }}
              • Profile picture of the author Blase
                Originally Posted by socialbacklink View Post

                Maybe it's because I've been doing PPC for 8-9 years now, SEO for about 14 years, and web design for about 16 years. So, for me 3 years ago is not really so long ago. Actually on this particular campaign I started work on it 5 years ago and was still on it as recent as 2 years ago not long after the merger. I'm new to WF. Not new to IM. I've been doing this for a living for a very very long time.

                If you want to get down to brass tacks it was actually MSN adcenter and Yahoo at the time. I said Bing because a lot of the ones that are new to this might not know what I'm talking about.
                That's why I brought it up.

                If a newbie read that you work them seprately he would be
                very confused.

                So this begs the next question, I'm here because I'm semi retired.
                Why is a guy that manages $350,000 per month campaigns on the Warrior Forum? :confused:
                Signature
                "Nothing Happens Until Something Is Sold"
                {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6790768].message }}
                • Profile picture of the author socialbacklink
                  Originally Posted by Blase View Post

                  That's why I brought it up.

                  If a newbie read that yoou work them sepratly he would be
                  very confused.

                  So this begs the next question, I'm here because I'm semi retired.
                  Why is a guy that manges $350,000 per month campaigns on the Warrior Forum? :confused:
                  That's actually a good question. I've spent the last few years running the marketing side of a couple of internet marketing companies that have multi million dollar info products. I'm no longer doing any of that. I've finally decided to go on my own. Do my own thing.

                  The long answer. Over the past few years building up marketing departments I did a bunch of training. If they were going to work for me they were going to do it right. I had a blast! Loved it.

                  I had so much fun doing it that I wanted to start my own real world training program. I know there are a bunch of them out there. Not a get rich quick scheme or anything like that. No silver bullets. There is no such thing. It will work for affiliate marketing but really cater toward corporations that want to run their own campaigns in house. Also, for small businesses that want to manage ppc for their clients. I just starting the research phase of it. So, I'm trying to offer real advice, help people with questions and stuff like that. Meanwhile I take notes for my training center. What type of materials will I need to provide, etc.

                  Along with research for that and writing materials I'm currently working on a service industry company. Doing a bunch of CL stuff right now and looking for a call center to take over sales. So, I've gotten some great advice on here lately with guys like Iamnameless with the whole CL angle. Going good so far. Just building it up.
                  Signature
                  Get The Best In Paid Traffic Training - PPC Superstar!
                  17 Years Experience As A Professional Internet Marketer
                  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6790932].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author sadneck
    Originally Posted by billuk3 View Post

    Hi I didnt know were to put this in ppc or offline.

    Is ppc on Bing/Yahoo worth the trouble is there any local traffic ,the only reason I ask is I have a local clients site ranking on top of Bing search It doesnt seem to get any traffic .I was wondering if the ppc was any better.and cheaper than google.
    Hi billuk,
    I have tried ppc on Bing, Yahoo, Facebook, and Google. Google was good to me for a while, (every $10 I put in I would get $100 out,) but then one day the competition jumped in and the keywords I was making bank on got tooo expensive... lol.

    Bing and Yahoo are much cheaper for the keywords I am going for, so I do prefer them. Google will chew you up quickly and spit you right back out. It will then hold out its hand, and if you refuse, it may go as far as grabbing a bat and threatening you to give it your bank account information. And if you do that? Wow, in one night with the wrong settings Google owns your house...

    Facebook is baaaad. No conversions there, everyone just wants to play those cheap free games. Do not recommend them.

    Andrew
    Signature
    THE BITCOIN BOSS WSO PACKAGE
    Special Launch Price!
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6788980].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author luke1213
      Originally Posted by sadneck View Post

      Hi billuk,

      Facebook is baaaad. No conversions there, everyone just wants to play those cheap free games. Do not recommend them.

      Andrew
      I used facebook PPC for about a month earlier this year to test the waters of PPC. I spent around $175 for my campaign. I didn't have a great conversion, but one sale generated me $700 in revenue so I had a helluva return.

      I guess the niche determines your conversions
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6816742].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author bsbear
    Just split-test like always and make sure you know what works before you invest a ton of your money.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6790831].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author billuk3
    Thanks for all your advice guys

    socialbacklink when will your training site be ready? is it paid ? do you need beta testers?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6816559].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author socialbacklink
      Originally Posted by billuk3 View Post

      Thanks for all your advice guys

      socialbacklink when will your training site be ready? is it paid ? do you need beta testers?
      It's going to be paid. I'm currently working on the videos at the moment. I should have a release date set by the end of next week. I am planning on getting a few people to test it out for me before releasing. Thanks for the interest. Send me your email and I'll put you on the beta test list. I'm going to have 5 beta testers.
      Signature
      Get The Best In Paid Traffic Training - PPC Superstar!
      17 Years Experience As A Professional Internet Marketer
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6816825].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author btyiw
        Originally Posted by socialbacklink View Post

        It's going to be paid. I'm currently working on the videos at the moment. I should have a release date set by the end of next week. I am planning on getting a few people to test it out for me before releasing. Thanks for the interest. Send me your email and I'll put you on the beta test list. I'm going to have 5 beta testers.
        Can you PM me your email? I have a few questions regarding local PPC. Thank you.
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6819203].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author cdl512
    the biggest thing to think about that has been missed for local is how large is your city? Bing/Yahoo get between 35 and 40% search market share. My clients are in the same niche, different cities. In LA Bing/Yahoo is great. In Austin it is about 15% of paid traffic. Is it still worth it at 15%? Hell yes, because I am a performance marketer. I don't get paid if I don't produce results. If you are in the business of helping your clients and you can convert the traffic into business then you should do it.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6816664].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Adwizard
    I am very interested in learning about PPC advertising. I am planning on getting Google certified like some of the suggestions on here but I haven't seen much else for resources as far as learning it goes. I understand and am real big on the testing thing... most of my marketing career has been devoted to direct mail before people had much in the way of computers, and it's the same there just much faster now.

    Anymore suggestions now from anyone on where a person should or could learn PPC? I don't mind buying a WSO that is packed full of info. I know most people talk about being able to get the same info on here for free (which I agree is true for the most part) but you have to sift through too much crap to find it most of the time. Paying less than a $20. bill to have all the info accumulated in one spot and save hours of time is well worth it to me.

    Question: Is the demographics of users from Bing or Yahoo really different than users of Google that they would have different click thru ratios and stuff? I would have guessed that running the exact same ad would have produced the exact same results except volume of course.
    Signature
    Building Businesses Beyond their Four Walls by
    Thinking Outside the Box... since 1993.
    Is anyone capable of designing a mobile site for
    this e-commerce site for a fee:
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6817330].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author socialbacklink
      Originally Posted by Adwizard View Post

      Question: Is the demographics of users from Bing or Yahoo really different than users of Google that they would have different click thru ratios and stuff? I would have guessed that running the exact same ad would have produced the exact same results except volume of course.
      Bing/Yahoo visitors are way different than Google. First of all the amount of traffic Google gets is way higher. The Bing/Yahoo crowd is a bit older for the most part from my findings which drastically changes the whole conversion rate and ctr (click through rate). You can still make some really good money though from Yahoo/Bing. Just not near as much traffic. Definitely worth a good test though. I got your pm and I'll send something over to you.
      Signature
      Get The Best In Paid Traffic Training - PPC Superstar!
      17 Years Experience As A Professional Internet Marketer
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6817452].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author thomasmps
    I am not great at ppc so I'm wondering if it safer to build a landing page and just target the highest searched for local keyword and bid on the exact match?

    Thomas
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6824725].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author socialbacklink
      Originally Posted by thomasmps View Post

      I am not great at ppc so I'm wondering if it safer to build a landing page and just target the highest searched for local keyword and bid on the exact match?

      Thomas
      I always recommend when people are learning to go exact match targeted locally. Very targeted ads with matching pages. Highest searched doesn't always mean anything. It's more about buyer keywords.
      Signature
      Get The Best In Paid Traffic Training - PPC Superstar!
      17 Years Experience As A Professional Internet Marketer
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6853014].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Chris Beatty
    I'd say that Google is where you need to focus your efforts. Yes, you'll get a little traffic from Bing but I personally don't think it's worth the amount of time it will take you to manage that account. Just get REALLY good with Google and you'll be golden!
    Signature
    How I Generated 217 INBOUND Phone Calls For My Marketing Agency <------- Scripts Are Included
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6852788].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author wordsofmagic
    Bing can be a very effective marketing vehicle like google for testing out new product ideas and services which I recommend, especially if your trying to generate leads or brand awareness for your new business. If the results obtained from this strategy is successful you are then in a position to apply a similar message to other online and offline marketing vehicles.

    I agree with Iamnameless, the traffic may be less compared to google but the starting CPC is lot cheaper and affordable.

    Hope this helps,

    Paul

    Originally Posted by billuk3 View Post

    Hi I didnt know were to put this in ppc or offline.

    Is ppc on Bing/Yahoo worth the trouble is there any local traffic ,the only reason I ask is I have a local clients site ranking on top of Bing search It doesnt seem to get any traffic .I was wondering if the ppc was any better.and cheaper than google.
    Signature

    Paul Smith
    Start Up PPC Business Coach

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6854932].message }}

Trending Topics