Blog Commenting vs Forum Posting?

Michael Coudriet

14 years ago

Originally Posted by amitkhurana1990

which one is better?

Better for what? For increasing rank, leads, sales etc.....

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6005903].message }}

IMSince2003

14 years ago

Backlink diversity means you do both. Your backlink portfolio should contain links from all over. This is why I recommend building larger sites because it can be very difficult to present yourself as an authority in 100 niches. Also very, very time consuming.

Thanks

Signature

BIG COACHING RESULTS WITHOUT THE BIG FEES! INTRODUCING FLEX-COACHING! YOU ARE IN THE DRIVER'S SEAT! GET COACHING WHEN YOU NEED IT, AS MUCH AS YOU NEED! NO LONG TERM COMMITMENTS OR SUBSCRIPTION FEES!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6005915].message }}

hilarious89

14 years ago

Both are better for link building. But Link Building through forum signatures are friendly to me.

Thanks

Signature

My Archive :- A blog where you will get everything updated !
Get Walkthrough Videos of Newly Released Games from Entertainment Discuss!!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6005935].message }}

jerrydu

14 years ago

We need to define a scale on which we can exam the blog commenting and forum posting. To get the result which is beter then other. Without your scale it is diffiuclt to judge...

As both are very effective in term of getting backlinks. Forums posting links are instant whereas blog commenting links are quickly crawl by search engine as people are interact to each other in quick time.

Thanks

Signature

Tax Attorney | Tax Lawyer

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6005945].message }}

Exel

14 years ago

This was discussed recently in this thread, you might wanna check it out:

http://www.warriorforum.com/adsense-...m-posting.html

In short, I consider them to be similar methods, taking into account both SEO and traffic.

Key is to make your posts and comments very valuable and helpful. Every post or comment
should be almost like a short article. Focus on the few forums and blogs that are of greatest
quality and bring you the best results.

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6006312].message }}

anwar001

13 years ago

Originally Posted by Exel

This was discussed recently in this thread, you might wanna check it out:

http://www.warriorforum.com/adsense-...m-posting.html

In short, I consider them to be similar methods, taking into account both SEO and traffic.

Key is to make your posts and comments very valuable and helpful. Every post or comment
should be almost like a short article. Focus on the few forums and blogs that are of greatest
quality and bring you the best results.

I agree, both are almost identical techniques. Both require you to post quality content if you want to see good results.

Thanks

Signature

Get Hundreds of Super Targeted Traffic in Any Niche from Facebook - 3 Step Organic FB Marketing

25 Guidelines For Massive Affiliate Success - Whether you are a beginner or an expert, read these principles and refer back to them many times

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7510202].message }}

socialbookmark

14 years ago

Both of them are good if you don't spam

If you want to post on forums, you should post quality threads or replies and if you want to comment on blogs you should post related comments which are not spam to be approved. No one (even a search engine) likes spamming and if you avoid them. both of them can help your ranking on search engines.

Thanks

Signature

I love warriorforum. zendegiyesabz

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6006353].message }}

JSProjects

14 years ago

Blog commenting for backlinks. Forum posting for targeted traffic. Both can take time and need to be quality over quantity, IMO.

I'd rather manually comment on a smaller number of high quality blogs vs blasting my link everywhere with automated tools. As far as forum posting, I'd rather be an active & helpful member of a handful of high traffic, niche related forums vs creating thousands of profiles.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6007216].message }}

webdevpro

14 years ago

You need to go for both as each has its own importance and also the results may vary depending on how you use them. e.g. how you use the signature links or do you post some valuable comments etc.

Thanks

Signature

80+ Free Webmaster Tools | Duplicate Content Checker | SEO Forums

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6007839].message }}

SamDermot

Banned 14 years ago

Well, according to my experience, forum works good for me....

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6007934].message }}

marketwarrior06

Banned 14 years ago

For learning Forums are the best place.
but for link building i think Blog commenting is a bit better than Forum posting. Because Blog posts get indexed quicker than Forum threads.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6008197].message }}

rankedzillaseo

14 years ago

It's good to have a variety of backlinks so I would encourage using both forum and blog commenting. Forum posting is also good for networking and learning new things.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6008510].message }}

johnben1444

14 years ago

I have to be upfront about this

Blog comment works much more better than forum post any day, any time.

You can find thousands of do follow blogs, with many high pr pages that you can leave your comment on.

Many of my site ranking high today after the blog de-index were as a result of 60% blog comment links.

Get a tool like scrape box and find high pr blogs to comment on.

The blog home page rank is not what matters but the actual page pr you will be leaving your comment. I usually stick with pr 3 and above and sometimes start from pr 2 when the high pr list is not sufficient for me.

Do not spam comments with scrapebox or otherwise it will be another waste of time like blog networks de-index.

Thanks

Signature

Grow your social media account, Spotify Streams, YT Views & IG Followers & More
Software & Mobile APP Developer
Buy Spotify, Facebook Bot & IG M/S Method

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6008834].message }}

nfp1

14 years ago

A combination of tactics is best when trying to build a strong linking campaign.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6008905].message }}

IMSince2003

14 years ago

I really like forum posting because you can actually help people solve a problem and interact with your peers. That doesn't really happen on scattered blogs. Of course, if I still had my 1,000 or so mini niche sites, well, that would have been just crazy. That's why I flipped everything on its side and went with the large site model. Every now and then I find a niche that's low comp. and over $25/click, so sometimes I can't help myself to an emd here and there

Thanks

Signature

BIG COACHING RESULTS WITHOUT THE BIG FEES! INTRODUCING FLEX-COACHING! YOU ARE IN THE DRIVER'S SEAT! GET COACHING WHEN YOU NEED IT, AS MUCH AS YOU NEED! NO LONG TERM COMMITMENTS OR SUBSCRIPTION FEES!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6009008].message }}

smileverse

14 years ago

In my view forum posting is the effective and powerful off-page SEO method because forums has more number of users from the different places and many users are participating in the forum discussion and this will keep forums to stay active 24X7 and google likes the fresh contents all the time. Lots of users is equal to lots of useful content.

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6010175].message }}

JSProjects

14 years ago

Originally Posted by smileverse

In my view forum posting is the effective and powerful off-page SEO method because forums has more number of users from the different places and many users are participating in the forum discussion and this will keep forums to stay active 24X7 and google likes the fresh contents all the time. Lots of users is equal to lots of useful content.

But purely for backlinks I'd say blog commenting. (As long as you're commenting on quality blogs.)

I do love the traffic that comes from active forums though.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6018024].message }}

lossman29

14 years ago

I'd do both simultaneously. Both are equally important and equally good at producing results.

Thanks

Signature

"There is light at the end of the tunnel. Have some faith and work hard. ALWAYS."

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6010824].message }}

footfoot

14 years ago

I think backlinking is important and should consist primarily of links that are of the backlink variety; preferably ones that link back to a site that you wish to obtain a greater number of backlinks for!

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6010885].message }}

OliviaSSLGuru

14 years ago

Both are better performer to get rank well in major search engines, but the mostly blog commenting, we prefer to get the instant boost of key phrase.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6011213].message }}

Openxcell Inc

14 years ago

I think blog commenting is better than forum posting because it is indexed very quickly in the search engines as compare to forums.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6103098].message }}

kochtgr

14 years ago

Originally Posted by amitkhurana1990

which one is better?

Well it depends...

For me overall blog commenting is better since you can build valuable links, build relations with the bloggers and their readers and get traffic...

On the other hand forums work better if you want to get just traffic and it might help you boost your reputation...

So blog commenting is better overall but it takes more time, forum posting gets less time since you have so many options to find threads where you can contribute in the discussion...

Thanks

Signature

Want to know How you Should use Guest Blogging in 2016 ?

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6103138].message }}

willirockss

14 years ago

Both are good for attracting the traffic to the website. Both are the important aspects of off line SEO in which a person can promote his website. The only fact is that in blog posting if the person finds a good community then the chances of his website promotion increases than that in the forum posting.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6103467].message }}

AnmolJ

14 years ago

Forums All The Way For Me

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6104179].message }}

Manuel Aguirre

14 years ago

Originally Posted by amitkhurana1990

which one is better?

Blog commeting is ONLY for indexing, Article Submission and Forum Posting (HIGH PR LINKS) is for ranking!!

Regards!!

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6104427].message }}

JSProjects 14 years ago

Originally Posted by Manuel Aguirre

Blog commeting is ONLY for indexing, Article Submission and Forum Posting (HIGH PR LINKS) is for ranking!!

Regards!!

That is incorrect.

A PR N/A backlink buried within thousands of other profiles is far from a high PR link. A lot of people think that domain PR is the same as the PR of the "page" your backlink is on. It's not.

Whenever I get asked this question I remind people that it's called "page"rank for a reason. Not siterank. Or domainrank.

Forum posting is great for building relationships and generating targeted traffic, though.
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6118282].message }}

sandeepkumar

14 years ago

Getting back links to your website is most important. For me Blog and forum postings both are working really well. Through these two methods I am getting huge traffic to my website.

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6118694].message }}

JSProjects

14 years ago

Originally Posted by sandeepkumar

Getting back links to your website is most important. For me Blog and forum postings both are working really well. Through these two methods I am getting huge traffic to my website.

I've found that commenting on recent posts from active, niche related blogs can bring in some decent traffic. If the blog is active it's somewhat close to the traffic that forum posting can generate. (Not quite as much. But it's also easier.)

The backlinks themselves won't be the greatest since they're coming from fresh posts that have no PR and are most likely NoFollow. But commenting on recent posts is more about traffic than backlinks.

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6125911].message }}

mrsvirtualassistant 14 years ago

Blog commenting and forum posting are some of the best ways to get relevant backlinks to your site. For direct traffic, forum posting works better. On the other hand, blog posts get high page rank easier than forum pages, which will help you with your link building campaign. You can try both methods to see which of them works best for your website.
- Thanks
Signature
-> Get Profile Backlinks here
-> #1 Virtual Assistant Service Hire Your Own Virtual Assistant To Work JUST For You
-> Ezine Articles Service Let Us Build Your Article Portfolio Today!
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6126097].message }}

delton yell

14 years ago

For SEO purposes, I think blog commenting works a little better. Search engines, particularly Google, seem to assign pagerank to blogposts a little easier than to forum topics.

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6344144].message }}

JSProjects

14 years ago

Originally Posted by delton yell

For SEO purposes, I think blog commenting works a little better. Search engines, particularly Google, seem to assign pagerank to blogposts a little easier than to forum topics.

That's mainly because people don't really link to forum threads. So the PR won't increase.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6345336].message }}

adam337

14 years ago

Its simple blog comment for PR and forum post for traffic.

Thanks

Signature

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6346679].message }}

Elfen Lied

13 years ago

Both forum posting and blog comment have their own advantages and disadvantages. One common benefit of doing both is backlink. You will get backlink from both. Generally forums have do-follow backlinks but it is not the same case with the blogs.

On the other hand forums require registration before you submit your post but blogs may or may not have the registration process.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7492890].message }}

Surminga

13 years ago

It all depends back to where those forums and blogs lie in terms of their PR. If you use both in their own advantageous ways then they can offer the same return. Dependent on your strategy will therefore pull back the positives and benefits. If you spend time looking for blogs with high PR and spend time commenting with great value this will pull back quality returns in a ways of PR, juice, traffic etc etc.

You need to work on either one to reap the benefits - but both can be highly rewarding if you have a straight and worthy strategy.

Thanks

Signature

Surminga.com - SEO and Digital Marketing Agency

Here are a few of our Blog's : Social Media Marketing Guide
Or if you Fancy a Holiday? - Holiday Guide

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7492962].message }}

jsjullia

Banned 13 years ago

[DELETED]

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7493052].message }}

connorbringas 13 years ago

Both are good in moderation. Dont look spammy and you're fine. Contrary to most, forum posting does give you decent backlinks.
- Thanks
- 1 reply
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7493090].message }}
- JSProjects 13 years ago
  
  Originally Posted by connorbringas
  
  Both are good in moderation. Dont look spammy and you're fine. Contrary to most, forum posting does give you decent backlinks.
  
  Forum posting have never really done much for me in terms of ranking. Traffic, though? Different story.
  
  Thanks
  
  {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7503921].message }}

gearmonkey

13 years ago

I get more user click thrus on forum signatures. I'm not a fan of blog commenting unless it is on a blog that is moderated by webmasters and don't allow any spam what-so-ever.

Thanks

Signature

My Guitar Website | My SEO Blog - Advertising spots available.

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7493347].message }}

mrswagset

13 years ago

Its all about quality rather than the quantity. Do both to diversify your backlinks.
Forums = Traffic
Blogs = Backlinks

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7509112].message }}

Demetrius

13 years ago

Blog commenting is the easiest way to get high PR backlinks for your site. Blog pages gets page rank very soon and when you leave a comment on that blog, you are getting a high PR backlink for your site.

Spamming in the forums are not going to work now a days. It is very important to build a relationship with the fellow forum members to get quality traffic to your site.

All it works very well if you use it well.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7510114].message }}

Regina W

13 years ago

For backlinks? Stay away from both and if, do REAL manual blog commenting on blogs you follow. But in general neither of them are good.

For traffic and leads? The right forum will work!

Thanks

Signature

My WSO launched 21 December 2012:

Not sure what keywords to use for your website?
Get over 8,000 low competition and high CPC AdSense keywords for $7

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7510124].message }}

scanningindex

13 years ago

Forum posting is the beat way to get good visibility

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7510798].message }}

Moreirra

13 years ago

Forum posting better and more effective..

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7511469].message }}

strategic seo services

13 years ago

Both are good for SEO purposes, especially when you're able to obtain relevant, dofollow backlinks through the comments/postings.

Thanks

Signature

Click Here â–º $15 NEW! Backlink Packages Added! Special Discounts. High DA, PA Relevant, Contextual, DoFollow Backlinks. Rank Your Site on Page 1 of Google! â—„Click Here to find out how

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7512566].message }}

mikasse

13 years ago

whit my experience ^^ Forum Posting is good to make more Traffic your website and good place in Alexa and good page rank in google ...and GOOD HIGH BACKLINK

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

Free Kik messeneger Hack 2015 :
http://kik-messenger-hack.blogspot.com
Amazing tool to spy on conversations

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7514053].message }}

manish123 13 years ago

Blog commenting for backlinks is a weird idea! You will probably be wasting your time . Getting backlinks from good blog is kind of impossible if you are posting for link sake.

Here are few comments which any established blogger wont accept EVER:

"You recognize therefore significantly when it comes to this topic, made me individually consider it from numerous numerous angles. Its like women and men don't seem to be fascinated until it's something to do with Lady gaga! Your own stuffs excellent. All the time take care of it up!"

Here's a funny one:

"Simply wish to say your article is as amazing. The clarity to your submit is simply nice and i could think you're knowledgeable on this subject. Well together with your permission allow me to grasp your feed to stay up to date with forthcoming post. Thanks one million and please continue the enjoyable work."

These comments doesn't make any sense and waste of time of Bandwidth submitting these comments!

Forums are great source of traffic from signature link but make sure you are not spamming the thread!

I see people often posting content like

"I find it very useful, never crossed my mind"
"oohhh...that's an awesome answer"

and keeps on building link and therefore kicked out of the forum by the moderator!

What I would suggest is to Genuinely participate in Blogs and forums and stay on the topic & share your knowledge with others!
- Thanks
Signature

Voxturr - Innovative Growth and Digital Marketing Agency to Grow Digital Businesses

Digital Transformation Agency | SaaS Marketing Agency | Healthcare Marketing
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7514326].message }}

Jabapo

13 years ago

For me 1st in Blog Commenting... best link building results so far.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7514313].message }}

frankierusso3

13 years ago

I prefer forum posting.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7514815].message }}

ram930krishna

13 years ago

Forum posting is good for traffic generation as well as backlinks

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7515054].message }}

seophalanx

13 years ago

You can get forums links quite easily and quickly, but for blog links it's rather difficult. By the way both link building techniques are essential for any website off page optimization and I give same preference to both kind of links.

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

Organic SEO Services India

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7551854].message }}

JSProjects

13 years ago

Originally Posted by seophalanx

You can get forums links quite easily and quickly, but for blog links it’s rather difficult. By the way both link building techniques are essential for any website off page optimization and I give same preference to both kind of links.

I wouldn't say it's THAT difficult, if you know what you're doing. (Don't just blindly comment on posts that you come across in Google searches.)

My general rule is to first ensure that the blog is still being actively updated by checking the main page. If there's any posts from the past few weeks or so then I consider it to be active.

Once I've done that I'll leave a quick comment on one of the newer posts. Comments on newer posts tend to get approved more than random comments on aged posts. (At least in my experience.) If my comment is approved in a reasonable amount of time I'll THEN go back and leave another on an aged post, preferably with PR.

Your approval rate should skyrocket at this point since:

1. You've verified that the blog is actively being updated and moderated.

2. You've shown that you're a legitimate commenter and not just a spammer looking to drop a link.

Sure, it's a little extra work. But it's still one of the easier ways to get backlinks with PR.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7570960].message }}

jipolis7

13 years ago

Both blog commenting and forum posting is good for SEO and both links back to your site from other authority sites. I cannot compare one with the other. Both of them should have to maintain quality rather than quantity and bring traffic slowly but steadily. But, I prefer forum posting more than blog commenting. Now choice is yours. You can check out some reasons behind this from here -

Importance of Forum Posting in SEO | Techblaster.NET

By forum posting you can easily crarwled by google time to time and your post can be on the search engine ranking very easy compared to the blog commenting.

[ 1 ] Thanks

Signature

Make Your Blog A Traffic & Sales Magnet Worth $20 Now Free for Warriors!
= = = > CLICK HERE < = = =

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7515849].message }}

jclindayag

13 years ago

Hi amitkhurana1990

Assuming that your question is for SEO purposes, I think it depends which is better. You cannot directly tell one can give you good results than the other. Take note that the quality of your backlinks depend on the quality of your posts. So it really depends upon the user itself.

If you are referring to the best place to share thoughts. I think forum posting are more realistic and interactive when it comes to discussing matters and opinions. So if you want to gain more knowledge, I suggest you go for forum posting.

Thanks

Signature

Free Twitter Drip-Feed Tool Saves Time, Increases Market Awareness and Drives Traffic. Grab Your Free Account Today: http://www.Feed140.com

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7517411].message }}

pinkhand

13 years ago

Through my experience blog posting helps more because we can comment on high pr blogs and which are dofollow also.The chance of getting out link clicked is more on blogs.

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7517412].message }}

W.P. Allen 13 years ago

It's best to diversify your traffic sources. Don't just do one or the other. You should be writing articles, creating videos, blog commenting, guest posting, social media, etc. This will help boost your search engine rankings AND shield you from any possible Google penalties.

NEVER, EVER rely on ONE traffic source. At the very least master 2 or 3.
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7518456].message }}

coolmanish

13 years ago

I think both are best but Forum Posting is good to make more Traffic your website and good place in Alexa and good page rank in Google.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7519969].message }}

ProSence

13 years ago

I prefer forum posting because I get good number of visitors compared to blog commenting.

Thanks

Signature

three great FREE tools - www.sitebeak.com, www.GAtective.com and www.impersonal.me

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7520492].message }}

arsalan1101

13 years ago

Both are better but i think forum posting very best method.

Thanks

Signature

make money online
earn money online
how to make money online
making money online

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7522053].message }}

GrowMyForumCommunity

13 years ago

If you have a blog, then blog commenting will be very useful. But for those who do not have blogs of their own and for those who do not feel like making their own blogs, then forum posting is the best option. Anyway, both of them are good when you plan to increase traffic to your page. You just need to know the dos and the don'ts when doing the said methods for you to have favorable results.

Thanks

Signature

Success doesn't come in an instant, just like Rome wasn't built in a day.
Want to grow your forum? Get help from GrowMyForumCommunity.com
Order your Free Forum Evaluation Report today.
Use 10% discount code: Z6L9UTJP8J. With 100% Money Back Guarantee!

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7522087].message }}

kumarvijay

13 years ago

Both are good techniques for off page seo , but more reliable is forum posting as far as talking about back links, so one can use both techniques for his seo purpose .

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7522182].message }}

JSProjects

13 years ago

Originally Posted by mfred90

Both are good. But forum posting is more better than blog commenting.

For what? Traffic? Sure. Backlinks? No.

Both have their own benefits. Forum commenting can generally bring in a larger amount of traffic, while blog comments (if done correctly) are a lot better for backlinks.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[7549007].message }}

Blog Commenting vs Forum Posting?

Trending Topics

I have an app - now what?

Page B ranking for my target keyword instead of Page A

How long do you test a method before dropping it?

Anyone watching the Super Bowl Sunday?

Hi to everyone!