8 {{ upvoteCount | shortNum }}
8 {{ upvoteCount | shortNum }}

Usability Testing? Better than ThemeForest? NEED FEEDBACK!

by Marketer Matt
7 replies
  • WEB DESIGN
    • |
I'm doing some design work on my site and trying to give my visitors the absolute best experience possible with finding the perfect WordPress theme for their website. We've collected over 15,000 themes so far, but I think my users get overwhelmed by having to filter through so many.

Please take a look at our site: Every WordPress Theme in One Place - PressCastle

What would make it easier to find themes on the site?

Why wouldn't you use this site to find a theme?

Why use ThemeForest or TemplateMonster over this site?

Thanks in advance for the feedback!
#feedback #themeforest #usability
  • Profile picture of the author chaotic squid
    You got several issues.

    - No search box. Really? Don't know how you missed that one
    - Site looks plain, missing substance
    - Numerous design errors, elements are overlapping, looks unprofessional
    - Limited info is shown on the theme detail page
    - No social proof, looks like your going to steal my credit card if I gave it to you
    - You blog hasn't been updated in months, site looks abandon
    - Your about us page is wacky, work on a real story behind your brand
    - and more
    - and more

    Go back to the drawing board. Figure out what people really want from a WordPress theme site and don't copy Themeforest. It's not about having the most themes available (which you'll never win at) maybe focus on providing themes to a particular industry, like providing wordpress themes for restaurants, photographers, or something that you can use as your point of difference.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9752173].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author HA-Dave
      Originally Posted by chaotic squid View Post

      - No search box. Really? Don't know how you missed that one
      Def agree on this. Prob the biggest issue in terms of usability I would think. Users do need a way to search for the theme that they want, otherwise having so many themes doesn't really make sense.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9753385].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author clemrick05
    WOW, so many choices.... What does your site do that all the others don't do? Bringing EVERY theme together in one place is overwhelming. How, exactly, are you helping people make their choice?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9752659].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Spring Pham
    How about having an option for theme designer upload their theme to your site to get promote?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9753595].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author roygamlin
    your theme collection is very high you already 100 wordpress theme arrange. but what u have problem?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9753602].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author UMS
    Originally Posted by Marketer Matt View Post

    Why use ThemeForest or TemplateMonster over this site?
    Here's a few reasons why I'd use ThemeForest:

    Sorting and selection filters (which your site has none).

    On ThemeForest you can select themes by:

    Categories
    Tags
    Price
    Popularity
    Age
    Sales
    Ratings
    etc

    You also get to see a demo of each theme.

    There is a clear summary and detailed information for each theme.

    There is a rating system that lets you see which themes are popular.

    As previously mentioned, the number 1 feature your site needs is a search/selection filter.
    Signature
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9753688].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Marketer Matt
      Originally Posted by chaotic squid View Post

      You got several issues.

      - No search box. Really? Don't know how you missed that one
      - Site looks plain, missing substance
      - Numerous design errors, elements are overlapping, looks unprofessional
      - Limited info is shown on the theme detail page
      - No social proof, looks like your going to steal my credit card if I gave it to you
      - You blog hasn't been updated in months, site looks abandon
      - Your about us page is wacky, work on a real story behind your brand
      - and more
      - and more

      Go back to the drawing board. Figure out what people really want from a WordPress theme site and don't copy Themeforest. It's not about having the most themes available (which you'll never win at) maybe focus on providing themes to a particular industry, like providing wordpress themes for restaurants, photographers, or something that you can use as your point of difference.
      Thanks for the feedback. I find this stuff SUPER valuable, so thank you! You're right about missing search, plain site, limited info, blog, and the rest. I hadn't thought much about social proof, so GREAT suggestion there. I'll rework the About Us page too as you're right that it isn't great.

      If you do truly have a lot of "and more" things that could be done, I'd value anything else you can tell me that you think would help.

      Originally Posted by Spring Pham View Post

      How about having an option for theme designer upload their theme to your site to get promote?
      Had this at one point, but should add it back again. Thanks Spring! Good suggestion!

      Originally Posted by UMS View Post

      Here's a few reasons why I'd use ThemeForest:

      Sorting and selection filters (which your site has none).

      As previously mentioned, the number 1 feature your site needs is a search/selection filter.
      Thanks for the feedback UMS. I really appreciate it. Makes a lot of sense. Always intended to add filters but never quite got around to getting them working. Will definitely consider this for the new design!


      Thanks for the suggestions so far everyone. This stuff is GOLD. Harsh at times, but I don't mind. Thanks for helping me make this site better for the WordPress community.
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[9754099].message }}

Trending Topics