Critique My Squeeze Page?

by Asher
22 replies
Hey guys...

I'm currently slamming lots of solos for my squeeze
pages and according to Google's Website Optimizer,
I'm converting on average of 23.47%

1st version: 21.8% (onlineincomecash.com)
2nd version: 25.2% (onlineincomecash.com/v2)

I've tested with different headlines but I can't seem
to beat myself. Any suggestions/recommendations
on the copy alone?

I'm not sure how I can reciprocate for you but if
there's anyway I can do something to reciprocate
in future... I will.

I can probably send a solo to the list I've built up to
hire you as a copywriter since you've helped me with
converting my copy.

Asher
#critique #page #squeeze
  • Profile picture of the author davemiz
    24% isn't bad... you have no idea where the traffic is really coming from...

    hard to critique it without a link :-)
    Signature

    “Judge your success by what you had to give up in order to get it.”
    ― Dalai Lama XIV

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6021306].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author KirkB
    Both version 1 and version 2 are exactly the same...
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6022674].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Adrian Int
      Originally Posted by KirkB View Post

      Both version 1 and version 2 are exactly the same...
      The raw link to the website redirects to /v2/.


      I'm not a copywriter, but here's what I noticed...

      I like that the eye path is straight, but perhaps rather than one big headline lasting 3 lines (honestly, I was reluctant to read it) you'd do better breaking it into headline + pre or sub-headline.

      Do you need the subscriber's name? If not, you might be able to improve your results simply by removing that. How many folks are signing up with "billybobmcgee" or "dfjkla" as their name anyway? :p

      Have you tried any other colours for the page?
      ie: Changing the colour of the headline


      Cheers,
      -Adrian
      Signature
      ATTENTION: Improve your list building. Free report and mp3
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6023142].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Asher
        Originally Posted by Adrian Int View Post

        The raw link to the website redirects to /v2/.


        I'm not a copywriter, but here's what I noticed...

        I like that the eye path is straight, but perhaps rather than one big headline lasting 3 lines (honestly, I was reluctant to read it) you'd do better breaking it into headline + pre or sub-headline.

        Do you need the subscriber's name? If not, you might be able to improve your results simply by removing that. How many folks are signing up with "billybobmcgee" or "dfjkla" as their name anyway? :p

        Have you tried any other colours for the page?
        ie: Changing the colour of the headline


        Cheers,
        -Adrian
        Hi Adrian,

        Good points. I'll consider chopping it up into pre and sub
        heads. A previous one I did showed that one overwhelming
        big fat headline outconverted ones with pre and sub heads.

        That's why they are what they are now.

        I have considered taking out the subscriber's name but
        that isn't available with the theme I'm using (ProfitsTheme).

        So I'm leaving it as it is - not an issue with bogus
        names, I rarely use the firstname tags in my emails.

        I haven't tested other colors - for the I.M. market, red
        seems to be the way to go. Even with all the copy tips and
        courses I've gone through. So I probably won't waste
        valuable dollars proving them right =)

        Asher
        Signature
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6025883].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Asher
      Originally Posted by KirkB View Post

      Both version 1 and version 2 are exactly the same...
      They're not... you're probably seeing the same
      since Google's Website Optimizer is sending
      you back to the same place.

      Here are some screen shots...

      Version 1:


      Version 2:


      I'm only testing the headlines for now.

      Asher
      Signature
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6025855].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Bobdarko
    The four lines of big red test at the top is too much. I immediately skipped reading it and scrolled down. Limit the amount of red text to 2 lines. See if this changes conversions.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6023171].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Asher
      Originally Posted by Bobdarko View Post

      The four lines of big red test at the top is too much. I immediately skipped reading it and scrolled down. Limit the amount of red text to 2 lines. See if this changes conversions.
      The headline contains the biggest firepower of my
      message - I could probably bring it down to 3 lines
      max but I want my message coming across more.

      So if I have people skipping it and scrolling down, no
      worries - I got the lower half to grab their attention.

      And if that doesn't work, well... I guess my offer and
      messages weren't suitable in the first place.

      Asher
      Signature
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6025897].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author ASCW
    I'd suggest getting bullets and opt in above the fold.
    Signature

    Site being revamped.

    If you want help with copy stuff, pm me.

    Cool.

    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6023359].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Shadowflux
      Hi Asher,

      Here are a couple of suggestions:

      As a member of O.I.C., you'll get full/complete access to the "$1,000 Blueprint" (valued at $47).
      Change O.I.C. to Online Income Cash. It's in the beginning and you haven't established what it means yet. It took me a second to figure it out and I'd like to think I'm a fairly smart guy.

      I would personally get rid of the "Lesson 2" "Lesson 3" stuff and just use the title of the lesson. Like this:

      Products Prospects Crave!
      Discover how to identify profitable products your subscribers will buy over & over again.

      I also felt that alternating between bolded and regular text was distracting and seemed to de-emphasize the regular text.

      Lesson 7, 8 & 9: The 1 thing you must have to have ANY CHANCE of continued income and success
      I'd change it to "The ONE thing you need for continued income and success." Basically, I don't like the "have to have".

      Those are just a few of my suggestions, take 'em or leave 'em. I like the overall page. I particularly like that it's short.
      Signature
      Native Advertising Specialist
      Dangerously Effective
      Always Discreet
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6024041].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author Asher
        Originally Posted by Shadowflux View Post

        Hi Asher,

        Here are a couple of suggestions:



        Change O.I.C. to Online Income Cash. It's in the beginning and you haven't established what it means yet. It took me a second to figure it out and I'd like to think I'm a fairly smart guy.

        I would personally get rid of the "Lesson 2" "Lesson 3" stuff and just use the title of the lesson. Like this:

        Products Prospects Crave!
        Discover how to identify profitable products your subscribers will buy over & over again.

        I also felt that alternating between bolded and regular text was distracting and seemed to de-emphasize the regular text.



        I'd change it to "The ONE thing you need for continued income and success." Basically, I don't like the "have to have".

        Those are just a few of my suggestions, take 'em or leave 'em. I like the overall page. I particularly like that it's short.
        Hi Shadowflux,

        Good point... I'll modify it to show OnlineIncomeCash (O.I.C.)
        instead and the "have to have" thing =)

        You're looking at the bottom part of the copy which has actually
        almost double my conversions. I'll tweak it but will first focus
        on the headline.

        I had the text non-alternating between bold and regular but it
        wasn't visually appealing (at least to me).

        And as for the lessons... I tested it without the "Lessons 2"
        etc... so far - not much of a difference. I like it right now
        because it's specific. That's something I like to see when I
        come across bullets in sales letters so I figure I can apply it
        here.

        Asher
        Signature
        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6025936].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Asher
      Originally Posted by ASCW View Post

      I'd suggest getting bullets and opt in above the fold.
      The optin is above the fold.

      I might test optins on the side another
      time since that will allow bullets also in
      the fold.

      This time - I'm testing zigging (only headline
      then optin) instead of my usual zagging
      (headline, bullets, optin on right side).

      Asher
      Signature
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6025905].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Exel
    Four-lines headline is a bit overkill, go with the shorter one.

    Also, I'd suggest pushing opt-in form to the right and bullet points above the fold on the left.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6024707].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Asher
      Originally Posted by davemiz View Post

      24% isn't bad... you have no idea where the traffic is really coming from...

      hard to critique it without a link :-)
      The traffic is coming from solo ads.

      Links (version 1): Online Income Cash
      Links (version 2): Claim Your $1,000 Blueprint | Online Income Cash

      Asher
      Signature
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6025821].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Asher
      Originally Posted by Exel View Post

      Four-lines headline is a bit overkill, go with the shorter one.

      Also, I'd suggest pushing opt-in form to the right and bullet points above the fold on the left.
      So far, the results are showing that the 2nd one is
      better (3 lines). I'd probably use the optin form on
      right and bullets on left on my next split test.

      Asher
      Signature
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6026002].message }}
      • Profile picture of the author ChloeCKimberley
        Here are a few tips...

        Reason why.

        Why are you giving this free? Marketing test? Demand test? Because it was your birthday yesterday? In exchange for your subscription? Become a fan? (Even simple reasons work better than none.)

        Urgency.

        You don't point out any form of urgency/scarcity for people to opt-in. Opting in is almost a "seconds" thing. You want to give them a secondary reason to opt in NOW instead of later.

        Bullets... can be improved a LOT.

        If you can shorten them, shorten them to their best benefit. If you can write amazing bullets, then pull out the transition from features to dimensional to emotional.

        Headline.

        Too commonplace in this market. I'm wondering what kind of traffic you're sending over... But you need to inject a form of "reason" for people to continue over to your optin page.

        Shock them out of their zombie states and send their brains chugging with curiosity. Make them think you're a real human behind.

        PS's

        No PS's? 1 or 3 is fine. Don't opt for two, if you're adding them.

        No objections?

        Uhh.. people are going to ask... "Is this system for everyone? Is it for ME? Am i experienced enough? I haven't done internet marketing before... could I do it? Could i do it if I am not technically savvy?"

        Design

        Frankly, I'm not too sure about the design. If you want, you can find Mr Subtle - he's supposedly the better copy designer in the WF. But i've seen squeeze pages with bullets at the side of the opt in form. Also, your font is too light - fonts with less contrast to the background have far lower readership than you'd think.


        MM.. yeah. I've seen squeeze pages go up to 50-60%, but it usually depends on the traffic as well. If you're using solo ads, it might be the "email copy" that gets them to click on your link which is not preselling you enough.
        Signature

        Signed, Chloe C Kimberley
        copywriter,designer,marketer

        "If you're making good money with SEO/PPC/product creation, I'll be willing to offer copywriting assistance to you so that I can learn from you."

        {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6026146].message }}
        • Profile picture of the author Asher
          Originally Posted by ChloeCKimberley View Post

          Here are a few tips...

          Reason why.

          Why are you giving this free? Marketing test? Demand test? Because it was your birthday yesterday? In exchange for your subscription? Become a fan? (Even simple reasons work better than none.)

          Urgency.

          You don't point out any form of urgency/scarcity for people to opt-in. Opting in is almost a "seconds" thing. You want to give them a secondary reason to opt in NOW instead of later.

          Bullets... can be improved a LOT.

          If you can shorten them, shorten them to their best benefit. If you can write amazing bullets, then pull out the transition from features to dimensional to emotional.

          Headline.

          Too commonplace in this market. I'm wondering what kind of traffic you're sending over... But you need to inject a form of "reason" for people to continue over to your optin page.

          Shock them out of their zombie states and send their brains chugging with curiosity. Make them think you're a real human behind.

          PS's

          No PS's? 1 or 3 is fine. Don't opt for two, if you're adding them.

          No objections?

          Uhh.. people are going to ask... "Is this system for everyone? Is it for ME? Am i experienced enough? I haven't done internet marketing before... could I do it? Could i do it if I am not technically savvy?"

          Design

          Frankly, I'm not too sure about the design. If you want, you can find Mr Subtle - he's supposedly the better copy designer in the WF. But i've seen squeeze pages with bullets at the side of the opt in form. Also, your font is too light - fonts with less contrast to the background have far lower readership than you'd think.


          MM.. yeah. I've seen squeeze pages go up to 50-60%, but it usually depends on the traffic as well. If you're using solo ads, it might be the "email copy" that gets them to click on your link which is not preselling you enough.
          Hi ChloeCKimberley,

          Thanks for the pointers. Well noted.

          I've edited the copy and added reason why's, some
          kind of urgency and updated the bullets a little bit.

          No PS and objection handling just yet. Will get to those
          soon.

          Thanks for pointing it out - you've given me quite a bit
          of stuff to work on. =)

          Asher
          Signature
          {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6030337].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Asher
    Alright... here's a quick update - I've now modified the
    copy to the better converting one (version 2) on both of
    them.

    And as ASCW (Andy Wilson), Exel (Zak Exel) and
    ChloeCKimberley stated, I've placed the bullets on the side
    of the optin instead.

    That is now version 1.

    Version 2 is now the control to beat.

    Let's see how this plays out!

    Asher
    Signature
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6030362].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Manoj V
    You can improve on it by comparing it to the squeeze page at the link below:

    http://emailmarketingmaverick.com/wp...age-design.png

    The first one is well suited for your purpose since the visitor does not have to scroll down. There could be more contrast on the page. A one-line headline as in the example is more readable. Lastly a few changes in the text to give the visitor more reason to go ahead with the opt-in.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6030894].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author Asher
      Originally Posted by Max P View Post

      You can improve on it by comparing it to the squeeze page at the link below:

      http://emailmarketingmaverick.com/wp...age-design.png

      The first one is well suited for your purpose since the visitor does not have to scroll down. There could be more contrast on the page. A one-line headline as in the example is more readable. Lastly a few changes in the text to give the visitor more reason to go ahead with the opt-in.
      Thanks for showing me that - it looks nice.



      Quite a few things on it that corresponded to
      what Chloe mentioned earlier.

      Asher
      Signature
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6034484].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author boostmg
    cool, hae you thought of using a video squeeze page?
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6037277].message }}
  • Profile picture of the author Acquinity
    I'm looking at both versions of the squeeze page and one thing comes to mind when i look at the top header..You mentioned this is the most powerful firepower you have regarding your sales pitch...

    The "$1,000 Blue Print" headline...does this mean this program usually costs $1,000 and your audiance is recieving a discount? Will i earn a $1,000? If so, over what time period?

    I relize this is the name of the E-Book you're promoting but consumers may not...

    I think you need to convey what consumers will get out of this in the top header, clearly....

    One of the screen shots you posted, the copy lists the daily revenue one can generate from this...i think that should be used. You should also split test the daily revenue vs. annual revenue - around $44k based on the daily revenue you list on the page...

    $122 may not get people to move down on the page, $44k may though...

    Best of luck to you.
    {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6038445].message }}
    • Profile picture of the author valuecreator
      I've been testing a lot of squeeze pages lately, and i have to say: I see that people are starting to get tired of Optimize Press looking template and the same hypey pitch. They just don't have the time for that.

      also, the less you say, the more you convert for opt-in...

      example: I can't post links yet, so google "paypal redemption codes by discountduo.com" (including quotes)
      (this SP converts at around 45%)

      Before that i had something similar to yours and it was more 15-20%

      so here's what I suggest if you want to push 50% (try it, because it works for me!)

      - i would put your headline in black or blue..

      - don't ask for names and you'll get and extra 5-10%

      - For headline, I would try something like:

      DO NOT start a Business !

      or

      KILL your blog !

      (you're supposed to get people's attention, not lose them!)

      sub-headline:

      Here's how YOU GET $1000 in Passive Income (it's automatic).

      Your picth should be:

      What is this? : BAM! One line
      What it's gonna do for ya: BAM! one line
      What I want you to do Now: BOOM! one line.

      Keep it short and direct, no hype, so they get it in less than 10 sec.

      First impression is the most important. My first impression with your page is "OMG another f@@@@ scam!)

      Add a picture of you (or somebody looking like your Bob). Also, put your product picture in a "youtube looking frame" with a play button on it (nothing plays, but you'll get another 10% righth there. Of course, you need at least a little video on the other side!!!)

      stay solid!

      Seb

      p.s. I have another trick that I found last week, and it's an extra 10-20%. PM me for that, I don't want it all over the net in a month's time...
      {{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6039755].message }}

Trending Topics