how powerful is a pr7 blog comment link?

14 years ago

The best solution in times like this is to continue building back links instead of lamenting, there are a number of things that can make a site disappear from the radar. How sure are you the few comment you made is responsible for it.

Even if it is, since you can not reverse the situation, the only option left is to focus on building more quality links.......

Thanks

Signature

Grow your social media account, Spotify Streams, YT Views & IG Followers & More
Software & Mobile APP Developer
Buy Spotify, Facebook Bot & IG M/S Method

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6194714].message }}

allsystems

14 years ago

Im not sure at all. I am worried because I am thinking that I have overdone it. I have done 100 manual PR2-PR7 blog comments in last 2 days. I think I have to just continue building the links now

Thanks
4 replies

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6194732].message }}

Ashera

14 years ago

Originally Posted by allsystems

Im not sure at all. I am worried because I am thinking that I have overdone it. I have done 100 manual PR2-PR7 blog comments in last 2 days. I think I have to just continue building the links now

If you did this in the last 2 days probably less than 10 percent of them are indexed as of right now. How old is your site?

Thanks

Signature

If you don't change direction, you'll end up where you're going.

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6194738].message }}

glock67

14 years ago

Originally Posted by allsystems

Im not sure at all. I am worried because I am thinking that I have overdone it. I have done 100 manual PR2-PR7 blog comments in last 2 days. I think I have to just continue building the links now

you should slow down so the links will appear natural to google

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

reliable cars

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6194781].message }}

JSProjects 14 years ago

Originally Posted by glock67

you should slow down so the links will appear natural to google

100 links is nothing to worry about since they'll be indexed over time and not all at once. Even then, 100 is minuscule when you think about other sites getting thousands of links a day without any issues.

The only thing to worry about is if there's a lot of spammy links on the same page. I wouldn't want to be sharing link juice with "questionable at best" sites.
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6200782].message }}

jhonybravo222 14 years ago

Yeah you have overdone secondly you build the link in PR 2 and PR 7 sites but there should be variation in the PR of sites with whom you are going to build the links.
- Thanks
Signature

online shopping for panel screen divider and shoji screen divider for your rooms at legacydecors.com
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6218074].message }}

sovereignn

14 years ago

Originally Posted by allsystems

Im not sure at all. I am worried because I am thinking that I have overdone it. I have done 100 manual PR2-PR7 blog comments in last 2 days. I think I have to just continue building the links now

Haha I do this everyday trust me you didn't over do it

Thanks

Signature

Get Page 1 Rankings With ZERO Work

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6237529].message }}

allsystems

14 years ago

1 1/2 years old. Position 27 in google.co.uk before it vanished. Did some major jumps after penguin, 62,90,43,65,32,29,27 vanished

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6194787].message }}

JKflipflop

14 years ago

Please cut down your pace first - So many High PR links and that too in such a small time frame, just at the outset of a recent Google update - you're calling for trouble!

Thanks

Signature

ABSOLUTELY FREE - COPY MY EXACT STEP-BY-STEP BLUEPRINT TO FIND THE MOST PROFITABLE AFFILIATE OFFERS

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6199473].message }}

SarahMcCrary

14 years ago

What's the age of your domain? Google dance depends on the age of domain. If your domain is older then 6 months, you need to start worrying.

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6199616].message }}

paulgl

14 years ago

Is the comment page really PR7? Or just the main index page?
Rarely does a comment page like that get anything.

If that comment page really is PR7, with 60 links, outbound
does not matter, the PR is theoretically divided by 60.
If PR juice is what you are after, you get more juice by
being the only link on a PR1.

60 outbound links on a comment page is a spammed-to-death-page.

Google has already made their thoughts very clear on comment
pages.

Yes, authority is a different matter. A sig link at the WF, even with
a zillion, does get a little authority. A PR7 page can have zero
authority.

I would skip the comment page, unless you just want to entertain
yourself.

Paul

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

If you were disappointed in your results today, lower your standards tomorrow.

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6199654].message }}

allsystems

14 years ago

Originally Posted by paulgl

Is the comment page really PR7? Or just the main index page?
Rarely does a comment page like that get anything.

If that comment page really is PR7, with 60 links, outbound
does not matter, the PR is theoretically divided by 60.
If PR juice is what you are after, you get more juice by
being the only link on a PR1.

60 outbound links on a comment page is a spammed-to-death-page.

Google has already made their thoughts very clear on comment
pages.

Yes, authority is a different matter. A sig link at the WF, even with
a zillion, does get a little authority. A PR7 page can have zero
authority.

I would skip the comment page, unless you just want to entertain
yourself.

Paul

Its a real PR7 with a nofollow where my link is on. There are 63 links on the comments today. Is the OBL really that important? 60 dosent sounds that spammed to me. I have seen a blog with 30k comments before. If everyone is so picky about OBL how do you find any links? It would take weeks just to find 100 high PR links

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6199695].message }}

allsystems

14 years ago

Oh yeh and I just want an increase in SERPS

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6199698].message }}

27coupons

14 years ago

Originally Posted by allsystems

I have found two PR7 AA blog comment links with OBL of 60 on the page. Now I placed two links on each of these something like "keyword" and "click to buy "keyword". 4 links ttoal. Firstly the sites moved afew spots higher overnight and now this morning it has totally vanished from the SERPS. I have heard of a google dance but this is worrying me. Any suggestions guys?

Stay away from page where OBL is higher you never get anything out of it in long term.

Thanks

Signature

Deals and Discounts
Broadband Plans

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6199923].message }}

allsystems

14 years ago

I dont know if I agree. Before I learnt scrapebox I got a quote from a member on here for high pr blog comments. He said 3 PR7, 30 PR6, 100 each of PR5,4,3 and 2 would cost me $500. He also said it would be mixture of nofollow/dofollow and the higher PR would likely be nofollow. The PR7 had an average of over 1k links. I dont know who to believe. ANyone done any experiment on this or any detailed thread showing that linkjuice gets diluted with more links on page?

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6200002].message }}

allsystems

14 years ago

Also for anyone interested my site is moving upwards slowly. In SERPS checker it is showing as 48 but it came back as 26 in manual check and now vanished again. Iv done nothing but nofollow high pr links so Im not too sure about the whole "nofollow dont help serps" argument. I hope someone shows me a thread with some research or an experiemnt of some sort to prove otherwise

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6200021].message }}

Manuel Aguirre

14 years ago

dont worry buddy is the google dance, just continue building more high PR links to your page!!

regards

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6200071].message }}

allsystems

14 years ago

Have begun looking at internal site structure as I want to redesign this website and I have realised that linkjuice is diluted i.e PR of page / number of external links to other sites. So the theory that higher OBL sites will harm you really isnt that true. The "linkjuice" will just be diluted with everyone else. Having said that, there no way I would ever comment on anything with more then 500 OBL to my money site and I try to keep it at 100 to make sure I get good quality link juice. Regards to other people on the blog who comment "buy porn" "buy viagra" etc I dont know if that is crucuail. The reason I say this is because I could leave a comment at comment number 21 and then someone next week leaves a comment at number 43 with "porn". I have no control over that. I am also experimenting with links towards the top op blog comments. I dont know if its the link juice or simply because the comment is placed higher towards the page that causes a higher increase in SERPS

Thanks
2 replies

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6200994].message }}

JSProjects

14 years ago

Originally Posted by allsystems

Have begun looking at internal site structure as I want to redesign this website and I have realised that linkjuice is diluted i.e PR of page / number of external links to other sites. So the theory that higher OBL sites will harm you really isnt that true. The "linkjuice" will just be diluted with everyone else. Having said that, there no way I would ever comment on anything with more then 500 OBL to my money site and I try to keep it at 100 to make sure I get good quality link juice. Regards to other people on the blog who comment "buy porn" "buy viagra" etc I dont know if that is crucuail. The reason I say this is because I could leave a comment at comment number 21 and then someone next week leaves a comment at number 43 with "porn". I have no control over that. I am also experimenting with links towards the top op blog comments. I dont know if its the link juice or simply because the comment is placed higher towards the page that causes a higher increase in SERPS

You have some control if the comments pointing directly at your site are from moderated blogs. As long as it's an active blog and you're leaving good comments you'll get plenty of them approved.

I know a lot of people avoid moderated blogs but I personally prefer them since there's usually a very low amount of outbound links.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6201178].message }}

ThatAblaze

14 years ago

Originally Posted by allsystems

Have begun looking at internal site structure as I want to redesign this website and I have realised that linkjuice is diluted i.e PR of page / number of external links to other sites. So the theory that higher OBL sites will harm you really isnt that true. The "linkjuice" will just be diluted with everyone else.

What you are talking about here is the simple, overarching picture. However, Big G is anything but simple when it comes to their method for determining the rank of a site. There is a part of the equation looking for "spammy" link sources, and comment pages with lots of comments and OBL are spammy.

Big G can tell it's a comment page, Big G can tell there are lots of other links, Big G can and will slap your site if you continue to use these sources. Big G doesn't want you to think of ways to send out higher quality spam, it wants you to think of ways to attract visitors.

If you had found that a real person clicked on one of these links, would you be surprised? If so then you are setting yourself up for a fall. I would be surprised if any real person ever clicked on link #27/100 that said "try my product" on a random blog.

Blog commenting is not what people mean when they talk about "high quality links."

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6203799].message }}

JSProjects

14 years ago

Originally Posted by ThatAblaze

What you are talking about here is the simple, overarching picture. However, Big G is anything but simple when it comes to their method for determining the rank of a site. There is a part of the equation looking for "spammy" link sources, and comment pages with lots of comments and OBL are spammy.

Big G can tell it's a comment page, Big G can tell there are lots of other links, Big G can and will slap your site if you continue to use these sources. Big G doesn't want you to think of ways to send out higher quality spam, it wants you to think of ways to attract visitors.

If you had found that a real person clicked on one of these links, would you be surprised? If so then you are setting yourself up for a fall. I would be surprised if any real person ever clicked on link #27/100 that said "try my product" on a random blog.

Blog commenting is not what people mean when they talk about "high quality links."

I've seen plenty of traffic generated from comments. However, these comments AREN'T on pages with tons of other comments.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6210020].message }}

allsystems

14 years ago

Thanks for the support guys. Site has totally vanished again. Im not too worried it keeps popping in and out of google and it hasnt been deindexed or anything. Just built a few (10 or so) high pr links today. Make it look more natural than bombarding 100 everyday

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6201689].message }}

JSProjects

14 years ago

Originally Posted by allsystems

Thanks for the support guys. Site has totally vanished again. Im not too worried it keeps popping in and out of google and it hasnt been deindexed or anything. Just built a few (10 or so) high pr links today. Make it look more natural than bombarding 100 everyday

I still wouldn't really worry about 100. You're vanishing because Google is trying to figure out where to rank you. It'll stabilize over time.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6203539].message }}

Kragsig

14 years ago

Pagerank checker :Google SERPs checker: results many countries Google Pagerank SERPs index results web SEO tools
Maybe you can find it here, but not visually (crazy but true)
A faster way to get the page visible is by bookmarking, with e.g. onlywire (free).

No worries I have tried it several times

Thanks

Signature

Learn How to Create a Lucrative and Sustainable Online Business by Leveraging a Proven Business System + Get My Secret Strategy to Getting Free Leads from Facebook Without Being Pushy.

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6202154].message }}

ThatAblaze

14 years ago

I also get 4 or 5 people clicking on my comments a week, but I put them on moderated sites and make them either interesting or at least on point. I always read the article in question before commenting, and then contribute to the discussion. That is a quality link.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6210731].message }}

uoftenwinny

14 years ago

Right, build more quality backlinks and unique contents.
Google likes unique but not duplicate.

Thanks

Signature

Android 4.0 Tablet PC electronics wholesale

Epad Android Tablet PC

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6211363].message }}

brandonthomas

Banned 14 years ago

Leaving comments often on blogs, it is a good way to increase the amount of inbound links pointing to your site's pages.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6212431].message }}

OmarNegron

14 years ago

I agree with several comments above. You are moving around because G is trying to see where to rank your site after they most likely found some of the links.

You are probably dancing. Keep building good quality links...you should be fine.

-Omar

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6212464].message }}

rizoalbert

14 years ago

Don't worry just try to build these type of good links it'll be back soon.You are right its because of google dancing.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6217596].message }}

edegreeusa

14 years ago

Originally Posted by allsystems

I have found two PR7 AA blog comment links with OBL of 60 on the page. Now I placed two links on each of these something like "keyword" and "click to buy "keyword". 4 links ttoal. Firstly the sites moved afew spots higher overnight and now this morning it has totally vanished from the SERPS. I have heard of a google dance but this is worrying me. Any suggestions guys?

Originally Posted by allsystems

Im not sure at all. I am worried because I am thinking that I have overdone it. I have done 100 manual PR2-PR7 blog comments in last 2 days. I think I have to just continue building the links now

Allsystems,

Now what Google is doing is a daily dance and fooling oneself by creating spam links will not be left by Google as today or tomorrow you will be penalized as that's what happened with you. You posted useless comment by hyperlinking a keyword and then writing click to buy 'hyperlinked keyword'. If you would have linked just one keyword and made a genuine personal comment to the point to the blog post then I am sure your ranking would just have risen. The penguin update is the clear message that no more unnatural link building will be accepted. However as far as blog commenting is concerned it still works, I can assure this.

There are several ways to raise rankings and I would suggest you choose the difficult but promising path rather than the easy path that could drop you anywhere.

Thanks

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6218332].message }}

JSProjects

14 years ago

Originally Posted by edegreeusa

Allsystems,

Now what Google is doing is a daily dance and fooling oneself by creating spam links will not be left by Google as today or tomorrow you will be penalized as that's what happened with you. You posted useless comment by hyperlinking a keyword and then writing click to buy 'hyperlinked keyword'. If you would have linked just one keyword and made a genuine personal comment to the point to the blog post then I am sure your ranking would just have risen. The penguin update is the clear message that no more unnatural link building will be accepted. However as far as blog commenting is concerned it still works, I can assure this.

There are several ways to raise rankings and I would suggest you choose the difficult but promising path rather than the easy path that could drop you anywhere.

Thanks

Which is why I'm commenting on moderated blogs almost exclusively. Pointing comments from auto approve blogs directly at your main site is pretty risky. You never quite know who you're going to be sharing link space with. Moderated blogs are a bit safer since the blog owner has to approve each comment.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6218913].message }}

puvanahim

14 years ago

I got some idea that good

Thank you very much

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6220136].message }}

hirithk

14 years ago

hai
you should slow down the links

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6222033].message }}

dmtaylor247

14 years ago

Originally Posted by allsystems

Im not sure at all. I am worried because I am thinking that I have overdone it. I have done 100 manual PR2-PR7 blog comments in last 2 days. I think I have to just continue building the links now

Too many 3/4 per week is sufficient

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6223345].message }}

JSProjects 14 years ago

Originally Posted by dmtaylor247

Too many 3/4 per week is sufficient

3-4 a week? That is nothing.

100 is absolutely fine. Even 100 is a VERY small # compared to plenty of other sites.
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6236201].message }}

ysb888

14 years ago

If that link is nofollow, then I think it doesn't affect your page ranking. I think this problem is caused by other factors.

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

*** Authority Guest Post Backlink That Force Penguin To Rank Your Site ***

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6223383].message }}

dmtaylor247 14 years ago

Originally Posted by ysb888

If that link is nofollow, then I think it doesn't affect your page ranking. I think this problem is caused by other factors.

They're not, he's a dofollow commenter/link builder, just be careful.. these links are really powerful.
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6223467].message }}

bswanson

14 years ago

I wouldn't be too worried about the two AA blogs that you mentioned affecting your rankings. It sounds like a coincidence being that your site dropped rankings the next day, the likely-hood that your comments were even indexed at that point are extremely low.

You should review other factors when trying to find the cause of your drop.

Thanks
1 reply

Signature

Professional, Cheap, Business Cards with Raised Letters | Business Cards Blog

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6237321].message }}

JSProjects

14 years ago

Originally Posted by bswanson

I wouldn't be too worried about the two AA blogs that you mentioned affecting your rankings. It sounds like a coincidence being that your site dropped rankings the next day, the likely-hood that your comments were even indexed at that point are extremely low.

You should review other factors when trying to find the cause of your drop.

Good point. It generally takes more than a day to get a backlink indexed and a site shifted due to that backlink.

And again, 100 a day is nothing compared to what others are doing.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6242567].message }}

gearmonkey

14 years ago

Being's it's nofollow, I doubt this is the issue. That PR7 link gives you no SEO benefit in Google.

Just make sure to not use the same anchor text too many times. Mix it up a lot more. Use more "click here" or entire URL as the link... or just use your name for blog comments.

Thanks

Signature

My Guitar Website | My SEO Blog - Advertising spots available.

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6242764].message }}

acec0de

13 years ago

WOW I wander how you find the time to build 100 links a day, you should slow down building organic links over time is better than blasting and then you run a risk of being sandboxed

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6865778].message }}

JSProjects

13 years ago

Originally Posted by acec0de

WOW I wander how you find the time to build 100 links a day, you should slow down building organic links over time is better than blasting and then you run a risk of being sandboxed

100 is still relatively small compared to what others are doing. I'd prefer quality over quantity. But 100 still isn't much.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6869086].message }}

Tim Wallace

13 years ago

The number of backlink for high PR sits should not be too more in short time. it is my viewpoint. The higher PR, the stricter.

Thanks
1 reply

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6865859].message }}

paulgl 13 years ago

Why do old threads get dug up? To cargo on more nonsense?

Originally Posted by Tim Wallace

The number of backlink for high PR sits should not be too more in short time. it is my viewpoint. The higher PR, the stricter.

Does that include no less than 4 links in your sig? I'd slow the pace
down here on commenting and posting....you know....high
number = penalty, right?

Back to reality.

If the nonsense you say was true, you would not be cramming sig links
here, and, you would have to put a sign on your site with linking instructions:

"Please don't link to me. I need to keep a close watch on the number
of backlinks and I can't risk other people linking to me and messing me
up with penalties and stuff...and if you have a high PR sire, PLEASE do
not link to me. I need to be strict."

Originally Posted by Bestseller91

Are you a jerk?

ROTFLMAO!

I'd like to see anybody post a real PR7 blog post that has dozens of
spammed comments and links. I'll be riding my unicorn when I see it.

Paul
- Thanks
Signature

If you were disappointed in your results today, lower your standards tomorrow.
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6869290].message }}

Yaduvanshi

Banned 13 years ago

[DELETED]

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6865912].message }}

bolocancristian 13 years ago

Im not sure at all. I am worried because I am thinking that I have overdone it. I have done 100 manual PR2-PR7 blog comments in last 2 days. I think I have to just continue building the links now
- Thanks
{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6865926].message }}

Suir1980

13 years ago

Depends on whether or not there are 10,000 other comments / outbound links.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6869239].message }}

yukon

Banned 13 years ago

You guys worry too much about little things. Google could care less If the link is in content or a comment.

He$$ this entire forum is nothing more than comments, yet most people spam the he$$ out of it with forum sigs. It's like your on both sides of the fence at the same time (pick a side). :rolleyes:

Now a link at the bottom of a page is something else. I do believe Google favors above the fold for most on-page SEO. Still, a comment on a blog is no big deal. Obviously you don't want 700 (or whatever) out-bound links on a single page.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6869334].message }}

Vivers

13 years ago

Sounds like a lot of backlinks to me but I build them so slowly myself. I agree with most and concur you should continue to build but make it a smaller amount and slower. Also try to find low OBL as you can.

Thanks

Signature

Carpet cleaning mission viejo

Carpet cleaning orange county

tile cleaning orange county

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6869346].message }}

whiterock

13 years ago

You should keep your pace slow because there is a chance to get in trouble by google if you have a very fast pace

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6869361].message }}

gearmonkey

13 years ago

Personally, I avoid blog comments at all cost to my money sites. I find blog comments are only good for my 2nd tier links.

And if these are wordpress blogs, chances are it is nofollow anyhow... unless they use comment luv plugin.

Thanks

Signature

My Guitar Website | My SEO Blog - Advertising spots available.

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6869436].message }}

Samung19

13 years ago

Better to build 100 links over the course of a month than in a couple of days. Slow down, and mis it up with other link types - also make sure you are varying your anchor more than two types of keywords.

Thanks

{{ DiscussionBoard.errors[6872913].message }}

how powerful is a pr7 blog comment link?

Trending Topics

I have an app - now what?

Page B ranking for my target keyword instead of Page A

Anyone watching the Super Bowl Sunday?

What is the future of SEO and Blog?

How long do you test a method before dropping it?